Most Helpful Customer Reviews
20 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Immature, December 24, 2005
This review is from: I'm No Saint: A Nasty Little Memoir of Love and Leaving (Hardcover)
Had heard rumblings of the books from therapist friends and a couple editor friends, none positive. But I like to read for myself and make up my own mind. To be honest I didn't find the book as one reviewer noted, to be 'hilarious journey of sex, drugs, marriage, dating after marriage, child-rearing, career hunting and surviving life on the Upper East Side of Manhattan.' And no I do not think as another reviewer wrote 'Everyone (young/old, male/ female,single/married etc) will love this book.' Simply because I found it a terribly sad book about a terribly sad woman, who uses herself and others for what amounts to a quick fix. Unless you consider allowing men who don't like you, much less respect you to bed you and pay you like a prostitute and then complain about the customer and what he got from you to be sexy or bright. I don't find abortion, drug use funny at all and I think anyone who sees the author as a devoted Mom, had better rethink what devoted means since to me it means being a good role model and putting ones childs needs ahead of ones own lusts and greed. One can be sexy, brillant, exciting and not loose. The author doesn't come off as the type. And I agree 100% with Ada Calhoun an editor at Nerve.com who wrote in the NYTimes book review section 'And her sex scenes are both clinical and vulgar'. Actaully felt the need to take a shower after reading the book. Some people need to keep their lives private.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Cautionary Tale, and an Old Sad Story, May 29, 2006
This review is from: I'm No Saint: A Nasty Little Memoir of Love and Leaving (Hardcover)
While the cast of characters in this story whirling around Ms. Hayt, the protagonist, are the overly educated, upwardly mobile denizens of New York City and its suburbs; with the fast-talking and the intellectualism and all eyes focused on seats of power; this memoir, in the final analysis, details a old sad story, and it's this: That if you don't understand in your gut that lasting love and fulfillment in this life comes from the giving and not from the getting, you will wind up alone and feeling unlovable which will keep you alone. Lasting love begins by selectively allowing other people all the way in to your very soul -- that means finding others who you believe may be worthy, evaluating whether they seem to have some real interest in knowing who you really are, and then gradually revealing your most private inner thoughts and dreams and cares and woes to those people, and then evaluating, by their words and actions, whether they really do care. If they do, you will feel cared about, and the feeling that you are cared about is so unbelievably wonderful that it will inspire you to allow those selected individuals in even further. This trust of allowing others in is the highest form of giving, which will engender trust from those people, and they will allow you in. And this is the way bonding happens, spirits intertwine, and love happens. And then you don't need lots of food, drugs, gambling, booze, etc., etc. to feel alive, because you'll have the real thing, which is true love, which really means feeling deeply cared about by another and knowing that the other person feels deeply cared about by you. Again, it doesn't come from running around trying to please others. Anyone can spread their legs. Anyone can learn to make gourmet dinners. There's no giving in that; there is no exposure of self in that; there's no trust in that. To get the fulfilling, lasting love, you must allow others all the way in and trust that the frightened, scarred, insecure, and highly imperfect soul inside you is wonderfully lovable as is. This is the old story that has always been true, and memoir will tell you what happens to people who don't understand this very fundamental emotional truth.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Bourgeois Scratching, December 21, 2005
This review is from: I'm No Saint: A Nasty Little Memoir of Love and Leaving (Hardcover)
A "blog" by a person of privilege who believes that spreading her legs or her lips is the ticket to catapulting her spirit beyond the boredom of a bourgeois "life." Connection or commitment (to family, friends, husband and child or just about anything) is constantly trumped, in Hayt's... err ...mind by scratching her itch. Truly a remarkable admission of breaking "taboos" by someone who values confessional tales of grabbing, stroking, pulling, licking or humping as perhaps the most heroic set of actions available to the upwardly mobile with education,money and opportunity. Oh, there are drugs and deadlines, too.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|