From School Library Journal
K-Gr-2-In this cumulative rebus story, a boy is sick in bed and begins to list the things he needs in order to feel better. "I need Clyde the cat with me in bed,/and another pillow for my head,/and an extra blanket if you please,/and a box of tissues in case I sneeze-." The book also doubles as a memory test because readers must continuously review the ever-growing list of items accumulated. Parker's childlike rebus illustrations replace the text for each essential the youngster requires. The story line is reminiscent of Shel Silverstein's poem "Sick," but lacks its playful spontaneity. Neitzel's rhymes are formulaic and uninspired. While the premise and rebuses are inventive and fun, this offering is not as fresh or engaging as this team's earlier titles.
Louie Lahana, New York City Public Schools Copyright 2001 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Ages 4-7. The team that produced
The Dress I'll Wear to the Party (1999) and other books presents this new story in which a young boy describes the things he will need "since I'm not feeling well today." Like the earlier book, this one is made up mostly of cumulative verses and rebuses that allow prereaders to participate and increase their sight-word vocabulary at the same time. Parker's crisp pictures, expertly rendered in watercolor and lightly outlined in black pen, depict each item on the boy's list--TV cartoons, puzzles, puppets--as a large, nearly full-page illustration, then again as a rebus in the text. The boy's list of needs ends about three-quarters of the way through the book, and a funny rhyming text takes over: "You say if I were really ill, I'd not complain, I'd just lie still?" In a surprising plot twist, the boy finds out that school was cancelled for the day: "Hurrah! Hurray!" The cumulative verse element of the story makes this a good choice for choral reading, with each child or group of children reciting a line and perhaps creating their own rebus picture. Older children can also make up their own cumulative verse and rebus stories as an enrichment activity.
Lauren PetersonCopyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.