Most Helpful Customer Reviews
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Hidden Gem of a Movie, August 3, 2009
Two academics study the natives in a remote land and are deeply affected by what they learn along the way. Pageantry, adventure, romance and an essay on cultural differences, all in one wonderful film. Rufus Sewell is fascinating and nuanced as Mick the pearl trader.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
EXCELLENT MOVIE & SERVICE, August 21, 2009
I really enjoyed this film - great story, acting, cinematography, locale, direction etc. Newcomer actress, Maya Stange, stole the show, and she was up against some great actors including Rufus Sewell (who did an in-depth emotional, yet quiet, performance). Note: This film is about a very spunky lady, during WW2, and therefore might not appeal to all men. Also received fine service via Amazon (as usual!).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A Confused Presentation of Trobriand Culture, December 13, 2010
I purchased this hoping to get some insights into the authentic Trobriand Culture. But in fact it mixes up Trobriand myths with reality, mixes up the Trobrianders with a more violent and superstitious group of probably Dobuans later in the film, and all without much effort to separate out what is the degenerate situation of their culture today, as compared to what it was in the time of Malinowski, much less in the early 1940s. If you read the original reports of the anthrpologist Bronislaw Malinowski, this is fairly clear. The Sexual Life of Savages They proclaim the "Bukamatula" or children's house to be the "men's house" without elaboration, and show a mythical event of women gang-raping and pissing on a tied-up man as some real thing. Also, the tree-jumping suicide was an extreme rarity, as the Trobrianders had little in the way of sexual shame to feel so terrible about. There was repression and misery to be found among the Chief's clan, and later where the missionaries had their influence, as with the women wearing shirts and such -- the film touched upon that with accuracy -- but for the most part this film does not represent the original Trobriand ways. Many of the bare-breasted women shown in the film may not even be Trobrianders, who tend to be taller and slim, and of a darker complexion than the lighter-skinned and shorter women in the film. Or possibly, this is due to contact with caucasians over the years. The story-line focuses upon the trials and tribulations of Western folk living among the natives. Little is shown of the magnificent Tula-trade boats, which went all the way from the Trobriands to India and Eastern Africa, of which the boats shown in the film are degenerated examples. No discussion of the yam harvest or farming methods, though some of the ornate village yam houses are shown. Some of the native dress and dance appears as it was in the past times, as from older photos and films, but the confusion with the violent Dobuans was perhaps the most horrible error. The Trobrianders originally had no word for "stealing" in their culture, for example, but we are shown a "Trobriand" village which points spears at outnumbered strangers, makes threats with machetes, and robs one of the westerners of all they have, clobbering her to the ground in the process. Anyhow, enjoy the film, or not, depending upon your interests. I personally found the plot line tiresome, but I was looking for something authentic, not a fictional narrative.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|