Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle Reading App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Apple
Android
Windows Phone
Android
To get the free app, enter your email address or mobile phone number.
{"currencyCode":"USD","itemData":[{"priceBreaksMAP":null,"buyingPrice":34.84,"ASIN":"0842524665","isPreorder":0},{"priceBreaksMAP":null,"buyingPrice":20.38,"ASIN":"0842524797","isPreorder":0},{"priceBreaksMAP":null,"buyingPrice":10.55,"ASIN":"1887752307","isPreorder":0}],"shippingId":"0842524665::QId078dx4FAirzc%2FvaYoU%2F2SN36a4mvoo16Y6O5Sq7q1uK1MBOb8b9z3YOfPkIcjimwjjJhaep%2FEuW0aDfJWdXPNpHOncC7yjPXPEiK343w%3D,0842524797::IppYd%2Bug78CJ217nd5NqVwyOqIU7QByOL%2B6qfpnF%2FDVd12z5dYgsqZDiy1n7dXtIpzqdhwoXiigMRiLzZ%2Bex0qmwVPUTUGYvPN5GT7bK908%3D,1887752307::Ptc3QjWCrxO8SA%2F4ItrYzWykwJHcH%2FIq8yRv0X2mnRjgFMP5mazR8y6KaNWzlSGr6zikGVTjw08XWNVQPhcLKN6oD5D3H9qB27rI8uiC5Fs%3D","sprites":{"addToWishlist":["wl_one","wl_two","wl_three"],"addToCart":["s_addToCart","s_addBothToCart","s_add3ToCart"],"preorder":["s_preorderThis","s_preorderBoth","s_preorderAll3"]},"shippingDetails":{"xz":"same","xy":"same","yz":"same","xyz":"same"},"tags":["x","y","z","w"],"strings":{"addToWishlist":["Add to Wish List","Add both to Wish List","Add all three to Wish List","Add all four to Wish List"],"addToCart":["Add to Cart","Add both to Cart","Add all three to Cart","Add all four to Cart"],"showDetailsDefault":"Show availability and shipping details","shippingError":"An error occurred, please try again","hideDetailsDefault":"Hide availability and shipping details","priceLabel":["Price:","Price for both:","Price for all three:","Price For All Four:"],"preorder":["Pre-order this item","Pre-order both items","Pre-order all three items","Pre-order all four items"]}}
Best Books of 2014
Looking for something great to read? Browse our editors' picks for 2014's Best Books of the Year in fiction, nonfiction, mysteries, children's books, and much more.
Product Details
Series: Brigham Young University - Islamic Translation Series
Hardcover: 580 pages
Publisher: Brigham Young University; Second Edition, 2nd Edition edition (February 5, 2002)
Though only a sparse number of Medieval Muslim thinkers are familiar to Western readers, al-Ghazali is likely to be one of the most often mentioned names as THE representative classical intellectual of Sunni Islam. Not too rarely is he compared with the Christian intellectual giant, St. Augustine. This is not an inaccurate portrait. As such, many curious readers may desire to read something by al-Ghazali in order to sample his thought. This volume might be tempting to some since it is one of his most famous works. I regret to say that I must recommend against it, for although the work itself is a classic, a masterpiece of Islamic scholarship, it is also deeply abstruse. Moreover, there is little that is asserted in the positive sense of al-Ghazali's personal beliefs. Being that the main aim of the work is to show the feebleness and vanity of philosophy to surpass revelation, most of the work can be characterized as principally deconstructive. In this regard, it is as vicious as it is systematic, rigorous and disarming even if the consequences al-Ghazali pointed to, such as atomism and the denial of all forms of causality, appear highly tendentious to all modern currents of thought. All but the most intrepid readers, I fear, may despair at its contents. I wholeheartedly recommend the potential to start elsewhere, such as Deliverance from Error, an autobiographical work.
With this caveat in mind, a few words about this edition for the non-initiate. The translation and the editing of the Arabic text are absolutely top-notch, and the parallel placement of the English-Arabic columns are easily followed by those familiar with both languages. Accompanying the text throughout are expository and explanatory notes that are immanently useful for both understanding cross-referencing the text with the works of the likes of Ibn Sina and al-Farabi. The aim of this series to create a parallel of the `Loeb Classics' for Islamic Studies appears to be directly on course.
1 Comment
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes No
Sending feedback...
Thank you for your feedback.
If this review is inappropriate, please let us know.
Sorry, we failed to record your vote. Please try again
27 of 30 people found the following review helpful
We need more! The `Incoherence of the Philosophers' (Tahafut al-falasifa) is part of a series of books in which Ghazali intended to explain his position vis-a-vis philosophy and kalam. (For our purposes here, Kalam is speculative theology.) The first book, `The Aims of the Philosophers' (Maqasid al-falasifa), is a fair and neutral exposition of the philosophy of Avicenna. Indeed, as Marmura notes, Ghazali "wrote this work of exposition to explain the philosophers' theories as a prelude to his refuting them in the Tahafut." Note that although Ghazali speaks of both al-Farabi and Avicenna in the Incoherence he usually is speaking of Avicenna. The next book in the series is this book, the Incoherence, and it is intended to be the refutation of philosophy. Then comes `the Standard for Knowledge' (Mi'yar al-'ilm) which, according to Marmura, "is an exposition of Avicennan logic, the most comprehensive of such expositions that al-Ghazali wrote." Ghazali considered logic philosophically neutral and thus a fitting tool for both theologians and jurists. Note that this position is itself controversial among the defenders of orthodoxy - see, for example, what Ibn Taymiyya says about Greek logic. Now, Ghazali considered his work on logic an appendix to the Tahafut. Lastly, in this series, Ghazali writes his `Moderation in Belief' (Al-iqtisad fi al-i'tiqad) which is an exposition of Kalam, specifically, Ash'arite theology. This Ash'arite theology is the type of Kalam that Ghazali then adhered to. Of this Marmura says that in, "the Tahafut al-Ghazali intended to refute and negate; in the Iqtisad, to build and affirm what he declared to be true doctrine.Read more ›
Comment
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes No
Sending feedback...
Thank you for your feedback.
If this review is inappropriate, please let us know.
Sorry, we failed to record your vote. Please try again
21 of 24 people found the following review helpful
A first-rate translation, by a top scholar, of a great, rich, and historically important text by one of the most significant thinkers and most influential figures in Islamic history. Does anything remain to be said? Okay, a bit more: For anyone interested in the relationship between revelation and reason or between faith and philosophy, or in Islamic intellectual history, or in the history of philosophy, or in a number of other fields, this is a must-read.
Comment
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes No
Sending feedback...
Thank you for your feedback.
If this review is inappropriate, please let us know.
Sorry, we failed to record your vote. Please try again
While this is an exellent translation and is especially useful in that it includes the original Arabic text. Sadly however there is little in the way of a biography of al-Ghazali or an in depth study of the book itself.
The introduction just gives the reader a brief introduction to the book itself and al-Ghazali. I would have liked a lot more of a comentary on the text and perhaps a comparison with ibn Rushds famous reply to this book the "Tahafut al-Tahafut"
The actual translation however, is well written and presented in an English that is fairly easy to understand thought the readers would need more of a background both in al-Ghazali and in philosophical thought in the Muslim middle ages. To help with this I would recomend first Watts Islamic philosophy and theology which gives both an exellent introduction to the topic and also the conflicting debates that raged throughout Islams history. Secondly I would recomend "On the harmoy of religion and philosophy" by Averroes better known as ibn Rushd. This book was a more brief reply to al-Ghazalis book.
It should be pointed out that al-Ghazali's writing of this book was concidered a turning point in Islamic history, it is generally thought that from this point onwards philosophy in the Islamic world went on the decline after receiving such a crushing blow from religion in the form of al-Ghazalis writings. While there wsa a decline in philosophy post al-Ghazali it is far too simplistic to claim that he was responsible for this (It is almost as bad as the Arab nationalist theory that the decline of philosophy in the Arab world was due to Turkish dominiance. Needless to say, this agrument completely ignores the fact that many 'Arab' philosophers were not even Arabs anyway).Read more ›
Comment
Was this review helpful to you?
Yes No
Sending feedback...
Thank you for your feedback.
If this review is inappropriate, please let us know.
Sorry, we failed to record your vote. Please try again