Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
So so, December 5, 2007
This review is from: India Sublime: Princely Palace Hotels of Rajasthan (Hardcover)
I was very eager to purchase this book as I am heading to Rajasthan next year for a holiday. The book features 21 palaces/forts that have been converted into hotels. It is produced in the coffee table genre - but it's not that inspiring, appearing a bit old-fashioned. I think there are 5 main problems. First, ... the complete absence of any map showing the location of the various hotels in Rajasthan. Second, most of the hotels are rather obvious choices ... names one will come across simply by browsing big glossy tourist brochures. There are not many surprises / discoveries. Third, the photographs are usually just of the main structure and/or public spaces, providing little information about accommodation (if that is what one is seeking to know). This is important because some of the converted palaces have absolutely charming public spaces, but unfortunately provide dingy accommodation. The photographs themselves are not particularly inspiring . Fourth, the authors' decision to include a brand new Oberoi Hotel in Udaipur - a building constructed in 2002 that has no princely origins whatsoever ... is highly questionable, and, I think, ultimately regrettable. Fifth, the book itself smells very very badly from the production inks ... making it almost off-putting to turn the pages. I tried leaving it on the balcony to breathe a bit for many hours - but it still smells. It is printed in China - but one would think that it is possible for the publishers, Rizzoli, to control such factors. Overall, I am not upset I have bought the book - it's mildly useful - but I don't find it inspiring or exciting ... which is surprising given the content.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Palace conversions, June 18, 2008
This review is from: India Sublime: Princely Palace Hotels of Rajasthan (Hardcover)
This well produced book contains many important palaces that have recently been converted to luxury hotels. Naturally, the original architecture, decor, and mood of the traditional buildings have suffered the renovations and the hyper cleanliness demanded by today's luxury seeking tourist. Nevertheless, many of the buildings are so spectacular that, in spite of conversion, much of their original brilliance remains. Many palaces are in distant reaches of Rajasthan and not on the usual tourist circuit. In general, these are the most exceptional. The book is nearly worth having merely to see the fantastic high ceilinged, completely tiled rooms of the Raj Niwas in Dholpur, or the magnificent complexly mirrored room at Kuchaman Fort in Kuchaman; both of these sites are amazing. Most of the hotels in this book retain their major architectural elements and are often newly decorated, but in a style that aptly suggests earlier periods. These are wonderful to see. A few palaces have been too up-dated and feel somewhat false and dead, and one hotel (Udaivilas in Udaipur) was built in 2002 in a bastardized traditional style and should not have been included in this book. In one instance, a large interior room of a palace has been transformed into a room for an indoor swimming pool. Nothing wrong with that for the tourist trade; but, the spirit of the original enclosure is entirely lost. In general, the hotels have been too manicured,too meticulously repainted according to contemporary taste, and decorated with standard hotel amenities reminiscent of Martha Stewart. In these instances, the feeling is that of the standard international luxury hotel, rather than sensitively refreshed examples of the great Indian palace styles of former times.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A broad overview of Rajastan's gorgeous former palaces now hotels, abundant with photos., October 3, 2008
This review is from: India Sublime: Princely Palace Hotels of Rajasthan (Hardcover)
I've gone through several books on Indian architecture and interior design and noticed this book didn't recycle pictures or use the same sites, making it an excellent inclusion in a picture book collection on India. Each chapter is a different hotel and there is a directory in the back but no map. There are full page and two page picture spreads throughout the book, showcasing beautiful architectural details, such as jalis or carved/perforated windows, arches and intricate tile & mosaic work. The views of furnished rooms provide plenty of inspiration for decorating at home, such as wicker and wood furniture, lighting, stained glass, lighting, mirror-work as well as use of color and fabric. With the number of sites, each hotel is not explored in depth and usually show the public areas (dining rooms, pools, gardens) and suites. Most of what is written is a short history, location and broad information. What I liked best was the uncluttered yet rich colorful design and displays how to mix classic with modern use. I'd recommend this book for somebody who is looking for ideas on color, architecture, interior design. I would have liked for there to be more information on the materials and techniques but this is fine, considering the subject. As these are hotels, don't expect to find something very traditional but the uniquely Indian feel is certainly there.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
|