3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Native Men vs. the Prison System, October 25, 2005
This review is from: Indians in Prison: Incarcerated Native Americans in Nebraska (Hardcover)
The author details the unique factors that affect Native American prisoners. She asks and answers why they are disproportionately incarcerated and have trouble obeying parole. She analyzes whether correctional facilities are allowing them to practice their religion as courts have demanded. I love a Native American man in jail and it was fascinating to have this book that discusses the issues that he and many others face.
This book says a lot about prison matters that affect inmates of all races. This would be a useful text for the loved ones of any inmate. As a non-Native man of color, I imagine that many people of color will relate to what is described here. Like Natives, Blacks and Latinos are also disproportionately represented in prison. Many Blacks and Latinos may feel uncomfortable in prison programs where they are the minority or their cultural concerns are not addressed. Many members of minority groups worry that the failure of one person may have a negative impact upon the entire community.
The book focuses on men because they are the grand majority of inmates, regardless of race. Still, the author mentions when rules or programs differ for female inmates. The book never addresses masculinity, or many of the concerns in men's studies, but this does not diminish from the text. Kansas was at the forefront of litigation for Native prisoners; this state was not selected just because that is where the author teaches. Though the area of inquiry is not the Dakotas, most of the subjects in this work are of the Lakota (which the author spells "Lakh'ota") Nation.
As a reader, it continually surprised me how different these Native Americans viewed the majority country and its culture. Yes, reservation life is supposed to have its own vibe and uniqueness. Still, all Natives were deemed American citizens in the 1930s. Native Americans speak English, watch American TV, etc. This book implies that they just cannot relate to the larger culture. I don't doubt it, but I'm surprised how separate the nations can be more than a half-millennium after Columbus' voyage and especially given the large amount of miscegenation between Native Americans and European Americans.
Many readers will be pleased that this is book is neither rigorous statistics nor gushy personal narratives. Still, there is a way in which this author is just summarizing stuff. It's not terribly academic. The figures she presents I'm almost sure were collected by various prison bureaux anyway. I loved this book, but it sure isn't tenure material. You can tell the author admires the Native inmates that she met. However, in her introduction, she makes them look TERRIBLE and cites phenomena that will only revive racist images of Native Americans, and men of color generally.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No