29 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Get this book if you want to understand Wall Street antics, July 14, 2003
This review is from: Infectious Greed: How Deceit and Risk Corrupted the Financial Markets (Hardcover)
This book is an absolute must read if you want to understand Wall Street shenanigans. Partnoy has done a phenomenal job of demystifying the world of swaps, derivatives and other exotic financial instruments. Even better, he shows how investment banker antics have affected Main Street inhabitants including yourself. How did Orange County and so many other municipalities get so deeply in trouble? The author explains.
I have a Ph.D in business and many finance courses under my belt, but I never quite understood the systemic dangers of the 'financial innovation' that is sweeping our markets. Now that I have, I will sleep much less well at night.
Partnoy describes the evolution of exotic instruments and the characters involved in this evolution. How CS First Boston made securites of virtually any type of debt, Salomon pioneered the CMO and so on. He details the specific wrongdoings of companies like Enron, Global Crossing and WorldCom. He shows you the enabling role played by gatekeepers like accounting firms, law firms, analysts and credit rating agencies.
Even more important, he shows you exactly how the collusion happened and why. He gives you both an aerial view of the markets and a down-in-the-trenches description. I often wondered why, in efficient markets, participants voluntarily involved themselves in such convoluted transactions that had high costs in terms of record-keeping and fees. The answer, as Partnoy shows, is that virtually all of these arrangements permit some set of parties to subvert law or regulation or both. This is true domestically and internationally.
He graphically describes how lobbying keeps regulators at bay and the venality and ineffectuality of politicians. The chairperson of the Commodities Futures Trading Commission, for example, exempted important parts of Enron's business from regulation and, just weeks later, joined Enron' board. There are many such stories that show exactly how self-serving our legislators and regulatory guardians are.
My quibbles are minor. While Partnoy is clear, his language is colorless. Perhaps his legal background has something to do with this. Given the strength of his material and the depth of his research, he could have made this book a popular bestseller if he had used more forceful colloquial expression.
Also, he does not talk at all about the role of technology in this evolving mess. Greedy, incredibly smart bankers have always been with us. What has permitted them to have this huge impact now is the ability of computers to churn massive amounts of data, pick out the faintest of patterns and keep records of incredibly complex transactions involving dozens of parties over vast stretches of time.
This said, this is the best book I have yet come across that explains how and why large scale financial malfeasance happens. And why it is hardly ever punished. You will understand why the perpetrators of Enron, Global Crossing, Adelphia, WorldCom, Sunbeam and so many others will walk and hold on to their vast gains. Start praying that there is justice beyond our courts.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A chilling summary with very thorough analytical background, June 23, 2003
This review is from: Infectious Greed: How Deceit and Risk Corrupted the Financial Markets (Hardcover)
In a much more serious project than his previous FIASCO, Partnoy gives an extremely persuasive explanation of how the interaction between financial product developments, legal change and administrative character have led to the series of financial scandals witnessed over the last twenty years. Few books on the subject have managed to explain the bizarre stories of Enron or LTCM in an understandable way but Frank puts together a convincing interpretation. The story depends not just on developments of financial products but also on accounting and legislative reforms, which he details. I'm not sure any other book on the subject approaches this one in detail and scope. Many have been written on individual cases but this is perhaps the first work to explain an overall pattern of corruption and it's evolution. The most familiar scandals are no longer bizarre events but can be seen as almost a logical consequence of a system going off the rails.
Other reviews have suggested that Frank is anti-derivatives but this is not at all the case. He makes it clear that derivatives are in many case useful structures with a role to play but that they have been used at other times to less beneficial ends. There is an undertone of indignation in the writing but such anger is surely more than justified considering the huge injustices which have gone more or less unpunished.
The suggestions for financial reform at the end of the book should be a blueprint for new legislation worldwide.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A very good book, but not of the FIASCO type, November 11, 2003
This review is from: Infectious Greed: How Deceit and Risk Corrupted the Financial Markets (Hardcover)
I always regard FIASCO as the Morgan Stanley version of Liar's Poker. Both of them are outrageous. It's certainly great fun to read insider stories, which are interesting but fifthy, of how the supposedly honorable banks screwed their customers. Naturally I had very high expectation of this book before I started reading it. To my minor surprise, the author had adopted a completely different style writing this book, making it a very serious and exhaustive account of how big banks like Bankers' Trust, CSFB, LTCM, Morgan Stanley and gigantic conglomerates like Enron, Worldcom, Orange County made use of dubiously legal practice for their own profits or demise, but certainly at the expense of shareholders. This material is really qualified to be a testimony before the Congress, which the author really did.
I do appreciate the author's sincerity of warning the public about the legal and moral problems of the real financial world with the advance in technology and financial techniques. A reviewer here said that the author was living in an ivory tower. I feel so sorry for that critic and those who thought so. As a professional trader, I assure you that the real world is indeed more dangerous and fifthy. Anyway, I do recommend this book as an indispensable material for anyone, especially govt officials (though I doubt very much they will humbly read and take this book seriously) who want to look into this. For those who just want to read for fun, FIASCO might be a better choice.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
