Customer Reviews

Innocents with Dirty Hands

5 star:		(3)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Opening scene: Romy Schneider is sunbathing outdoors on the lush green lawn of her San Tropez estate, nude. A mans kite slowly comes to rest on Romy's back. The man approaches and asks if he can retrieve his kite. Romy rolls over exposing herself and asks, "is there anything else you want?". So begins Claude Chabrols 1975 Innocents With Dirty Hands.

Chabrol has made lots of movies and this in my estimation is his sexiest. Usually in his late sixties and early seventies pictures Stephane Audran is Chabrol's star and she is beautiful but also icy cold. Audran seems encased in her beauty and expresses very little in the way of emotion. It is nice to see an actress in a Chabrol film who express as much emotion and sensuality as Romy Schneider and there are lots of different kinds of emotions and sensuality to be expressed in Innocents. As to be expected in a Chabrol film the plot involves infidelity and murder but unlike many of Chabrols other treatments of his pet themes this film has some real heat. Chabrol loves to film the decadence of the rich as they enjoy their leisures and pleasures and San Tropez provides the perfect setting for this story of the idle rich playing dangerous games. Hitchcock is always mentioned in the same breath as Chabrol but Chabrol subverts Hitchcock as much as he borrows from him. In Hitchcock no matter how complicated things got there was always a comfortable resolution. In Chabrol complications do not work themselves out so neatly. Things get tangled and they remain tangled. In Chabrol's world everyone is a fallen creature, each character just realizes it in a different way and at a different time. Romy Schneider appears in one striking outfit after another, including one scene in a very cool caftan, another in black silk with cascades of diamonds. Her sensuality seems luxurious and this is a woman who basks in the glow of her luxury. Two men want her bad enough to kill, her husband played by Rod Steiger and the kite flying writer who lives next door. One plot gives way to another as each character tries to gain the upper hand. I've seen maybe 20 Chabrol fims and this one I would place very near the top of the list. The acting is tremendous by the main three characters and by the minor characters as well, ie the police detectives(great duo of detectives) and lawyer(great actor, Jean Rochefort). The ending as always with Chabrol is unexpected. A very sexy and very satisfying film which will please the most discerning filmgoer and delight anyone who already considers themselves a Chabrol fan. Also recommeded by Chabrol: La Ceremonie, Wedding in Blood, Le Boucher, The Unfaithful Woman(Le Femme Infidele), Cry of the Owl & This Man Must Die.

First at all Rommy Schneider was one of the most beautiful women in all the story of cinema . In this opportunity Schneider plays the role of an unhappy woman who decides break the rules .
An intense drama will be developed in this puzzle of intrigue , erotism, jealous , betray and murder .
The amazing script plays in the european style . Deep focus , expressive close up , slow paced , careful attention to the corporal and visual language , characterized by a clear resources economy plus a script loaded with high caliber tension .
The shame will be flowing through the mind as a new element that it will never leave her .
Intense thriller that reveals once more to Claude Chabrol as the suspense french master .
Chabrol has common roots with Hitccock , but he plays harder . You can watch in Hitchcock a deep respect for the established order , and all his suspense is under this premise . After the torment , everything will reassume a new order (With the glorious exceptions of The wrong man and Vertigo of course) . But Chabrol always walks beyond the limited boundary . And the characters will never be back .
Watch this film . You will love and will adopt it as one your favorites ones.!

Dating from 1975, this French mystery almost sets a new standard for its superbly convoluted plot and amoral characters. Director Claude Chabrol has often acknowledged Hitchcock as an influence. In the first scenes, a love triangle develops and the elements of a classic murder plot are set up. Then, after the murder has seemingly been carried out flawlessly, the plan begins to unravel. As layer upon layer is peeled off, it soon becomes apparent that nothing was ever quite what it seemed. The detectives, who struggle to make sense of conflicting evidence, provide an interesting foil for the characters, who are caught up in their respective intrigues. This edition is available both in French with English subtitles, and dubbed into English; it works better in the original French.

The more films I see directed by Claude Chabrol the more impressed I am with his work. He has now found a place among my favorite filmmakers. I have mostly seen his work of the 90's "L' Enfer", "La Ceremonie" (Kind of a comeback movie for him), and "The Flower of Evil", though I have been able to sneak in a few of his classics such as "Les Biches", and his first film "Le Beau Serge".

"Innocents With Dirty Hands" has a Hollywood noir feel to it. Something along the lines of "The Postman Always Rings Twice" or "Double Indemnity". The story is similiar.

Romy Schneider plays Julie Wormser. A wealthy but unhappily married woman. She soon starts an affair with a neighbor, Jeff (Paolo Giusti) and they immeditaly decided to kill Julie's husband Louis (Rod Steiger).

The beginning of the film is a little hazy. We don't suspect this intense love affair is going on, and nothing before hand would lead us to believe the murder plot, but this is a Claude Chabrol film so what were you expecting to happen?

Once the plot starts to set in the movie in very involving. And the performances given by Schneider and Steiger really bring the movie together. I must admit though my eye did tend to follow Schneider more. She's the focal lead.

But there is a fault with this movie as the conclusion starts to come the movie becomes far moe complex than need be. It's almost like something out of a soap opera. Remember the simpliest touch is always the best one. There's no need to try and add layers on a story. A good story can get by without twist and turns at every corner.

Also the material doesn't seem as rich as in "Le Boucher" or "Les Biches", but despite everything "Innocents with Dirty Hands" works.

The movie has that Chabrol "feel" to it and we can sense we are in good hands. Chabrol will deliver the goods.

No matter how confusing the end may get there's one thing you have to admit, Chabrol puts on a good show. And that more than anything is one reason why you should see this movie.

Bottom-line: Despite whatever faults it may have this is one of Chabrol's best and belongs up there with his classics. The performance from Schneider is a standout. Well worth seeing.

i remember this movie from when I was a young girl growing up in Europe, but haven't seen it in years. Romy Schneider was a great actress and that alone makes it worth seeing. It impressed me so much at the time, I'll give it four stars...also recommended: Chabrol's "The Butcher" (Le Boucher).

The english version, of the subtitles have nothing to do with the english spoken the copy wasn'y perfect but it's possible to see it and enjoy, the seller was timely correct

Like Hitchcock films, this was ahead of it's time for 1975. Of course today it's dated with cliches but consider movies like this started the cliches for all movies that followed. When taken into context Dirty Hands is pretty good.

I love Chabrol's movies, my favorite being Le Boucher. Even his worst (can't think of one) is better than most films today and worth watching. This was not one of his best. A very complicated story (which is not always a problem) but Steiger was definitely miscast). The two detectives were adequate but not the sharpest tools in the shade. While watchable (and Schneider is unbelievably beautiful) I cannot recommend it to those who have never seen a Chabrol movie. This follows his usual ambigous endings. Several of his movies are heartbreaking and he makes no easy answers. This one I didn't care what happened to anyone and it really wasn't shocking. And his character studies weren't that deep.

This loosely adapted biography of prima ballerina Jodi Lee Pavlova involves her affair with Rudolph Nureyev and the hundreds of impossible-to-detect ways she made her permanent mark on the ballet world. It was she who defined the now classic character of the little matchstick girl in the well known ballet "Ou Est La Bibliotheque, Bebe?" by appearing onstage under harsh lighting with a lit cigarette in her mouth, curses on her ruby lips, and a bad attitude that won hearts all over the world. But the scene she is most famous for is the 1977 Covent Garden Christmas Eve production of the Nutcracker. For it was there that she and Nureyev cemented their permanent love-hate, sex-surfing-disco-and-death manifesto by actually slugging it out in the lobby during intermission. Along the way to becoming a legend in her own time, she is widely credited with introducing the elegant, aloof, Nureyev to bowling and putt-putt golf, sex in glass elevators at high noon, crank phone calls in the middle of the night, insomniac pirouettes on balcony railings on weekday evenings, and obscure Chinese wines every weekend (who in the ballet world can forget the sight of Nureyev onstage as Prince Floramund with the "head shivers"). In return, Nureyev became her often petulant, blatantly misogynistic, constantly carping, somewhat embittered, often disoriented,love slave. And oh my! Can anyone ever forget her cat claws bared, fur flying, spitting and howling, tutu-ripping backstage brawl with Gelsey Kirkland after Kirkland called Nureyev "a lunatic?" Cinematographer Boogie Scheinfranken has created a timeless work of stunning visual beauty as seen through a prism of stage lighting and lots of glittering green eyeshadow (Nureyev's). A Must See!

The man who made La Ceremonie & La Boucher is bound to have a few clunkers in his repetoire, & Innocents with Dirty Hands fits the bill. The film fits into almost every suspense cliche I can think of; the most prominant being the stale story of the pretty girl who marries the fat,unattractive man for his money, then finds a young stud who helps plot and execute his murder.

The twists are tired and easy to predict, and while the camera work is skilled & occasionally quite fun to watch, it doesn't make up for the plodding storyline and silly theatrics.

And could someone please tell me why everyone is speaking in French except for Rod Steiger, whose mouth is moving over words in English, yet dubbed and subtittled in French?

If you're looking for quality suspense, keep looking.