From School Library Journal
Kindergarten-Grade 2—Living alone in his little house on a hill with a tiny yard big enough for his dog and a single tree, Mr. Potter has a perfectly cozy arrangement. However, the night he decides to let the dog in to enjoy the fire begins a chain of events that includes bringing the tree inside, too. Soon the growing tree wants to go back outside, so Mr. Potter makes a big hole in his roof to accommodate it. Now the tree has plenty of sunshine and critters, and all is well until it begins to storm. After days of rain, Mr. Potter moves his favorite chair, stove, and teapot into the dry, warm barn just as his house collapses. He is happy with his new arrangement until he realizes how lonely the cow out in the field looks, but this is a thought that the dog immediately nips in the bud. Smith's text is perfectly complemented by the illustrations. Without saying a word, the dog clearly wonders along with readers what ill-advised thing will Mr. Potter do next. Parkins uses a mix of realistic details, excellent facial expressions, and varying perspectives to bring the story to life. This kindhearted tale is best read aloud with plenty of extra time for laughter and bemusement.—
Catherine Callegari, Gay-Kimball Library, Troy, NH Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Mr. Potter’s cozy, logical world—his tidy home with a tree in the yard and a dog beneath it—is turned topsy-turvy when he makes some illogical decisions. After bringing the mopey dog indoors, Mr. Potter also decides to plant the tree inside so it will not be so alone. Eventually a hole must be cut in the roof so the tree can grow, which causes all sorts of zany calamities. He and the dog ultimately make themselves comfortable in the barn, at which point Mr. Potter contemplates moving a forlorn cow in with them . . . until the dog nips him in the seat to bring him to his senses. The cartoon-style illustrations depict placid, richly colored scenes of Mr. Potter surrounded by his accoutrements in his cottage-style house and give no hint of the chaos that will soon ensue with twisty tree branches, nesting birds, and rainwater everywhere. For another story about a special tree, look for This Tree Counts! by Alison Formento (2010). Preschool-Grade 2. --Randall Enos