"A superb collection of essays... that examines in a remarkably rich and varied way the construction of otherness and foreignness within this complexly 'national' cinema tradition.... Excellent on all counts." —John MacKay, Yale University
(John MacKay, Yale University 2009)
One way Soviet films define Russianness is by contrasting outsiders (usually foreign visitors) and insiders ("ours"). The examples in the first essay, about early Soviet films, are clear and specific. The second essay shows how Soviet films reedit for foreign consumption and make incoming foreign films more ideologically acceptable; e.g., "Happy endings would be removed as suggesting that one can be happy under capitalism." The third essay examines clothes. Another, on Ivan the Terrible, says foreigners are "caricatured, parodied, ridiculed and dehumanized, sexually ambiguous, demonic, and animal-like." The emerging danger is stereotyping, or propagandizing: Soviets are good, outsiders are scum. The nine essays are wonderful in their analyses of films. But a cloud of exclusion or manipulation hovers over the topic. Vigilantism? An essay on Aleksei Balabanov's films is fully aware of that possibility. Contradictions within the culture are not allowed... in cinema. Since the topic of national identity is hugely important, the question of how closely cinema emulates reality is crucial. Surely articulating nationhood, here beautifully explored, is only fractionally cinematic. For full context, readers should seek out National Identity in Russian Culture, ed. by Simon Franklin and Emma Widdis (CH, Mar'05, 42-4189). Summing Up: Recommended. Upper-division undergraduates through faculty. --ChoiceP. H. Stacy, emeritus, University of Hartford, Feb. 2009
(P. H. Stacy, emeritus, University of Hartford 2010)
"... The nine essays are wonderful in their analyses of films.... Summing Up: Recommended. Upper-division undergraduates through faculty." —Choice, February 2009
(
Choice 2011)
"... Stephen Norris and Zara Torlone have... produced an anthology that is the best I have ever had the pleasure of reading...
Lucidly written, well researched, persuasively argued, lavishly illustrated, Insiders and Outsiders in Russian Cinema can be read with pleasure and profit by anyone from the general reader interesed in Russian culture to the most seasoned Russian film specialist." —Denise J. Youngblood, University of Vermont, RUSSIAN REVIEW, Vol. 68.2 April 2009
(Denise J. Youngblood, University of Vermont
RUSSIAN REVIEW )
"...a fine collection of essays by leading film scholars...." —Brigit Beumers, University of Bristol, SLAVIC REVIEW, Vol. 68.4 Winter 2009
(Brigit Beumers, University of Bristol
SLAVIC REVIEW )
"In a word, the theoretical richness and sophistication of this collection parallel the complexity of its topics and serve as an excellent cross-section of how the theme of foreigners and outsiders is examined in comtemporary studies in film." —Slavonic & East European Journal, Volume 54, Issue 4 Winter 2010
(
Slavonic & East European Journal )
"[The editors] and the volume's contributors offer an insightful survey of how Soviet and Russian cinema constructed the meanings of Soviet, Russian and foreign identities over the course of the twentieth and early twenty-ï¬rst centuries.... It will be useful to graduate students and scholars working in the area of Russian and ï¬lm studies." —Slavic and East European Review, V.89.3 Jully 2011
(
Slavic and East European Review )
