Most Helpful Customer Reviews
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Gripping Police Procedural, July 13, 2009
This review is from: Internal Affairs (Hardcover)
In general, I'm more concerned with the story than the biography of the author telling it, but in this case, Dial's twenty-seven-year career in the LAPD is relevant because it lends tremendous credibility to her debut novel, a police procedural set in the sprawling bureaucracy that is the Los Angeles Police Department. When a female police officer, Alexandra Williams, is found dead in the trunk of a car parked outside Deputy Chief McGann's home, it's a foregone conclusion that the investigation is going to be a mess. No one wants to deal with it, but it must be dealt with. When it turns out that McGann had been having an affair with the dead officer, Internal Affairs launches an investigation into the illicit relationship, while a parallel investigation in the Robbery Homicide Division teases out Alex's other relationships. Burned-out Sergeant Mike Turner, serving his time in IA and waiting for a promotion, ends up working the murder investigation, re-igniting his passion for police work and jeopardizing his relationship with promotion-minded girlfriend Lieutenant Paula Toscano. Turner is afraid that the police chief will protect McGann at the expense of the truth, so he walks a fine line between doing the right thing and keeping his job.
Dial's police officers run the gamut from decent people who make decent cops to a self-involved Chief of Police, to a spineless Captain, to cops who abuse their power. She doesn't give all the women in her fictional LAPD a pass, either, and I found that aspect of the novel particularly interesting. Sally uses her sex appeal to go after promotions, Captain Connelly was promoted only because she's a woman and she can't make a decision to save her life, Paula is determined and hard-working. I found Dial's portrayal of female police officers intriguing, and the diversity in quality really rang true.
This is the most illuminating police procedural novel I have ever read. Dial's long experience in various capacities with the LAPD puts the investigation in a solid context of bureaucracy that sometimes has to be finessed to serve justice. By the time Turner makes his decision to basically lie to his superior officer to keep working on the murder investigation, the reader understands why this is necessary to bring the truth to light. The particulars of the investigation detail dedicated surveillance, scanning of telephone records, and witness interviews that lead to the truth. This murder mystery is the perfect choice to make use of Dial's knowledge; since a cop is involved, Internal Affairs must be involved, complicating matters, and the department is caught between its mission of truth and justice and its desire to protect itself. The officers involved in the investigation have complex motives, and the backstabbing, promotion-mongering, and various relationships ring true. One wonders how many of these characters are based on real officers in Dial's past. She also portrays both sides of the bureaucracy; on the one hand, it provides the structure needed for such a massive organization to function, but it can also impede officers who are just trying to do what's right. Turner has to navigate the bureaucracy carefully, stepping outside it when necessary. Dial walks the civilian reader ably through the web of bureaucracy without being patronizing. An organizational chart and list of characters are very helpful to keeping the various departments straight.
There are certainly trade-offs in a novel that so elegantly portrays bureaucracy, organization, and structure. While I liked Mike Turner, I didn't feel particularly emotionally invested in him or the other characters. Part of the problem was a wandering point of view. Multiple points of view were necessary, but establishing Turner as the protagonist from the beginning would have been helpful. The novel begins from McGann's point of view, with Mike's point of view becoming dominant with the second chapter. Often, long sections of exposition substituted for more evocative scenes, especially when complex relationships were involved. Confrontations would be summarized instead of shown through dialogue, which would have been more powerful. Many of Turner's motivations are told, rather than demonstrated. In fact, when forty pages before the end, Turner is shown making an omelet for Paula and reflects that cooking relaxes him, I found myself wishing that more of these personal details had been revealed throughout the novel. I would have felt more connected to the characters as people, rather than as cogs in a wheel of bureaucracy.
That said, this was a cracking good read. The mystery was satisfyingly complex, with plenty of suspects and investigative threads that either didn't pan out or led to other clues. As the killer becomes more obvious, the focus shifts to Mike finding a way to prove it to the satisfaction of his boss, and that process, too, is interesting. I highly recommend this book to fans of police procedurals, anyone interested in an insider's look at the LAPD, and hard-boiled mystery readers.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Authentic Police Drama, August 5, 2009
This review is from: Internal Affairs (Hardcover)
Reading this book, it was clear to me that the author has inside knowledge of how police departments work. The book is a gritty crime thriller that starts when an LAPD Deputy Chief finds a gruesome dead body in the trunk of a car blocking his driveway. An Internal Affairs investigator, Mike Turner, teams up with Robbery Homicide detectives to investigate the crime. The plot is interwoven with a greater picture of the politics and hierarchy of the LAPD with a very large cast of characters. Although the insider's view of the inner workings of the police department is interesting and authentic, in certain spots this caused the plot to drag a little bit. At the end of the day, however, the murder investigation and compelling characters made this a great read. I would like to read more books involving Mike Turner and his RHD partner, Detective Montgomery.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Exciting Story, August 10, 2009
This review is from: Internal Affairs (Hardcover)
LAPD Deputy Chief Jim McGann is irritated when he finds a car blocking his driveway as he goes for his morning run. He's downright angry when the car is still there on his return. Then he realizes that it's an unmarked cop car and it seems to be leaking blood. When the trunk is opened, it contains the naked body of a brutally murdered young woman, soon identified as Alexandra Williams, a beautiful young patrol officer who was briefly McGann's lover.
The affair violates departmental policy and Internal Affairs investigator Mike Turner gets the personnel complaint that follows. Chief of Police Sam Martin wants a quick resolution to the complaint, a resolution that includes a liberal dose of whitewash. Captain Nancy Connelly, Turner's boss, is spineless and indecisive and will not buck the Chief. But McGann has to be looked at in the murder investigation too, and the two inquiries are thus intertwined. That's okay with Turner, who relishes returning to real cop work by working with the homicide team. Besides, a young cop is dead and Turner wants the murderer.
Turner and his homicide cohorts, Montgomery and O'Neal, have to delve into the darker regions of the LAPD. The top brass' primary goal is to safeguard their careers. Secondarily, they want the Department to look good (see primary goal above). Third, they would like, if possible, to protect McGann (see first two goals above). Oh, and they would also like to catch the cop killer (see three goals above). Because the brass doesn't hesitate to hurt or destroy the careers of any cop whom they see as imperiling their three main goals, their attitudes impede the efforts of working cops. So does the endless bureaucracy and rules that have enmeshed the Department in recent years. How the homicide team works with, through and around these problems to get the truth is a large part of the story.
Dial uses the knowledge from her 27 year career in the LAPD, during which she went from patrol officer to division commander, very effectively. Her descriptions of the Department (regrettably) ring all too true. So do the conflicting loyalties and ethical problems that result. Dial's plotting is good, although in the end it turns a little too much on a hunch and on improbable revelations. But Dial's prose is fluid and clear, her main characters interesting and the story exciting throughout. A good book and a lot of promise for the future.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|