3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
A terrible disappointment, May 31, 2008
This review is from: International and Intercultural Public Relations: A Campaign Case Approach (Hardcover)
Seeking a textbook on public relations campaigns that I could use outside of the United States, I adopted International and Intercultural Public Relations as the text for a senior-level public relations class.
I was taken aback by some of its unsupported assertions, the most egregious being its proclamation that assuring that a campaign's action strategies are in the public interest is "unworkably complicated." The authors' basis for this assertion is "there simply is no such thing as the public and therefore no such thing as the public interest." (p. 35) The cartoon selected for this section of the book shows two business men at a desk, with one saying, "Our best strategy may be to destigmatize embezzlement." This cartoon illustrates the problem with this book, in my opinion. The tenor of this section seems to be a throwback to the "public be damned" era of the 1920s.
Instead of advising students on how to conduct ethical campaigns in the public interest, the authors recommend attending only to advancing the client's objective. The best they can offer students who are concerned about ethics is to advise their clients to pursue goals that "meet the reasonable expectations of target publics." Anyone who has lived with segregation in the U.S. South or apartheid in South Africa is aware that expectations of target publics are not always ethical.
More than half the book is dedicated to case studies. The titles sound as if they are truly international campaigns, but they are for the most part campaigns by U.S. companies to improve their image in foreign countries, including companies that have been internationally scorned for not operating in the public interest. This emphasis was of little help to a class outside the U.S. in a country already bombarded with commercial messages from U.S.-based conglomerates.
I discontinued use of this insidious book in midterm. I will for now have to return to using an older, frankly U.S.-centric textbook, but at least it is well centered on ethical campaigns.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Some good, some bad, but it worked for my class, December 2, 2010
This review is from: International and Intercultural Public Relations: A Campaign Case Approach (Hardcover)
Lacking on the "international" factor most cases are USA relating to the rest of the world, with a few notably good exceptions.
In general not so well written, but again with a few notable exceptions of great case studies.
Bottom line: there are not many books on this subject so this one flies until something better shows up.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No