This is a must read for all students of early Mormonism, nineteenth-century Illinois, or American religious history. This fifth volume in a limited edition series of early Mormon journals and autobiographies is composed of six journals and three appendices. Although most of the journals are in print elsewhere, here they are conveniently collected and abridged into a single volume covering the years from 1840 to 1853, from William Clayton's conversion to Mormonism in England, through the Great Trek west, to his return to England to try to explain polygamy. Since Clayton was a confidant of Joseph Smith and Brigham Young, he records as an insider. He was unsophisticated, faithful, and an excellent observer. He was also candid, wrote much that is not recorded elsewhere, told some tales out of school, and was an enthusiastic polygamist--ten wives, forty-seven children. Readers of the Illinois Historical Journal will find his intimate account of the secular and religious life during the Illinois period of Mormonism (from 1842, when Clayton arrived in Nauvoo, to 1846 when he left) compelling reading. He includes polygamy (especially his unique account of its practice before the revelation of 1834 and his own ardor to live it), temple work and other "secret" affairs, the Word of Wisdom, money family troubles, and his warts-and-all-portraits of some Mormon leaders. Furthermore, his journal of the 1846-1847 Mormon Exodus is simply unparalleled, a classic in the field of westering. Of lesser interest will be the journals on "England and Emigration, 1840-42," "Visit to Utah Settlements, 1852," and "Polygamy Mission to England, 1852-53," and the appendixes. The book is enriched with a preface, introduction, a chronology, lists of wives and children, twenty-six photographs, five maps, notes, and an index. As previously noted, these journals have been abridged. Keeping in mind the old adage that one person's trash is another's treasure, some readers may wish to consult the unedited versions, even though Signature Books has an excellent record in careful and thoughtful editing. Readers interested in the trek west are especially advised to read the original. Editor George D. Smith and the publisher are to be commended for their work. Enjoy! --Stanley B. Kimball, Illinois Historical Journal
William Clayton lived his life on the periphery of early Mormon leadership circles. Welcomed as a scribe, he never played an important role in church decision-making and the occasional pointedness of his exclusion hurt his feelings. How ironic it is then that through his journal writing his significance has eclipsed most of those who exercised greater authority in the early church. Clayton was twenty-three years old and living near Preston, England, when he embraced Mormonism in 1838. In 1840 he ventured with other British converts to Nauvoo, Illinois, where the ten year old church had settled following its forcible expulsion from Missouri. There he became a church clerk and, in 1842, the Prophet Joseph Smith's private secretary, serving in that capacity until Smith's murder two years later. When in 1846 the church at last despaired of American society, Clayton joined the main body of the Saints in emigrating to the Great Basin, rather incidentally composing Mormondom's best known hymn, "Come, Come, Ye Saints," en route. Although he subsequently served in a number of minor political offices, Clayton gradually drifted away from those in power. Chosen in 1852 as a member of a Mormon mission to England to justify the church's adoption of polygamy, the trip proved a personal debacle when his license to preach was briefly revoked after his being charged with immorality. Sent back to Utah after a mere three months service, he lived an active but quieter life until his death in 1879. Since most of these journals (covering 1840-1855) have been both previously published and extensively mined by historians, there is little here that will come as news. Still historians of Mormonism will turn perennially to them. Clayton's writing is remarkable neither for its acuity nor for its literary grace, he was no Phillip Hone much less a Samuel Pepys, but he provides a richness of information found nowhere else. His 1845-1846 Nauvoo Temple journal, for example, offers a fascinating theological discussion of the subordination of women to men. Moreover, one can see clearly in Clayton's chronicle of everyday life the turbulence among the rank and file and better appreciate the necessity of Brigham Young's marked sternness in regulating the behavior of his flock. And, as is frequently noted, Clayton's story of Joseph Smith's introduction of polygamy and the trials and tribulations Clayton experienced in adopting the practice is wonderfully vivid. In recent years Signature Books has come to publish some of the most important works on Mormon history. This particular volume is the fifth in a series dedicated to the publication of early Mormon journals and diaries, and follows, among others, a highly useful collection of Joseph Smith journals. Unfortunately, it must be noted that the current Mormon Church continues to suppress those portions of the historical record it deems embarrassing and a significant part of Clayton's writings from the Nauvoo period are consequently missing from the volume. That unhappy fact excepted, this edition is in other ways definitive. The journals are prefaced with a lengthy biographical sketch of Clayton, a life chronology, lists of his wives and children, maps and photographs, and three appendices comprised of some of his personal shorter writings. The method of annotation, however, is quite irregular. One is surprised that generally known places and events in American history are explained in the notes, as is a passing reference to the city of Detroit, while much about Mormon history is left unexplained, as are Clayton's relatively cryptic references to the trial of Joseph Smith's assassins. Still, the comprehensiveness of the volume will make it the standard reference for Clayton's writings. --Kenneth H. Winn, Journal of the Early Republic
The William Clayton Journals elevate Signature Book's series of nineteenth-century Mormon diaries to a high level of primary documentation. Although excellent biographies of Clayton have already been published, George D. Smith has brought six specific journals together in a single volume. The result is an in-depth view of a unique Mormon life between 1840 and 1853, one of Mormonism's most dynamic periods. Clayton's own words take us from his conversion to Mormonism in England, through his transatlantic crossing, to his position as Joseph Smith's private secretary in Nauvoo. George Smith also chronicles Clayton's 1847 migration to Utah, his polygamous activities, and a missionary journey to England in the 1850s. Clayton lived twenty-six years after these journals end, yet Smith's exceptional introduction gives both context and perspective on his entire life in a biographical sketch. The author's history of the edited documents is beneficial as well. Elaborate notations throughout the text, utilizing a vast array of complementary sources, add significantly to an understanding of the journals and the man who wrote them. The book's appendices include a number of notebooks, private books, extracts from writings, and Clayton's written testimony of Joseph Smith, the Book of Mormon, and later leaders, are also helpful additions. Clayton's view of the amazing internal workings of Church leadership in Nauvoo is fascinating, as is his lengthy discussion of the building of the Nauvoo Temple. An in-depth reading of these documents adds significantly to an understanding of Mormonism during a number of internal and external crises. Clayton's journals depict the life of a man at the footstool of power who was involved in polygamy at an early stage and who obviously believed in the doctrine, felt he should be an exemplary practitioner, and influenced many others to do likewise. His unabashed pursuit of some young women is rather startling and underscores his fervent belief that a righteous posterity was the key to celestial realms. Ten women married him, and he fathered forty-seven children. Though Clayton never reached the highest level within the Mormon hierarchy, that of General Authority, he did serve on the Council of Fifty, which had hopes of world government. He discussed all of these activities very openly in his journals. George Smith's careful and detailed presentation of these journals sets a new standard for Signature Books' series of journals. His attention to detail, much like George Ellsworth's in The Journals of Addison Pratt, demands elevated standards for editors and publishers. To provide complete historical context, editors of diaries, as Smith has done here, should meticulously research their material, examining and noting contemporary sources. The fascinating details of a life spent in the councils of Joseph Smith, Brigham Young, and other Church leaders summaries of discussions, off-hand conversations, and reactions to revelatory decisions give readers a great feel for William Clayton and his times. It is unfortunate that the high price of this edition [the original, limited edition, not the paperback] may limit the number of readers who have access to Clayton's universally appealing story. --F. Ross Peterson, Dialogue: A Journal of Mormon Thought