Customer Reviews

Into the Crucible: Making Marines for the 21st Century

5 star:		(36)
4 star:		(5)
3 star:		(1)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

There are several book available about Marine Corps bootcamp, but this is the only one that reflects the restructuring of recruit training in 1996 that culminated with the addition of The Crucible--the final test that every recruit must complete before receiving his Eagle, Globe, and Anchor and earning the title United States Marine. I went through The Crucible, and this book made me understand its purpose, value, and signficance more than the actual experience itself. Capt. Woulfe has structured this book around the various "events" of The Crucible and explains the historical inspiration behind each event as well as its purpose in recruit training today. Although this book focuses on The Crucible (rather than on bootcamp in its entirety), it is a must-read for anyone about to ship off to bootcamp--reading this book will bring a greater understanding and sense of purpose to the daunting and often chaotic experience of Marine Corps bootcamp. I would also recommend this book to parents and friends of recruits, because it will help to explain the purpose of what goes on in recruit training. Additionally, I think any Marine who went to bootcamp prior to the much-talked-about addition of The Crucible will find this book to be a very enlightening dissection of how bootcamp has changed recently. "Into The Crucible" combines the best elements of a Marine bootcamp guide and a Marine Corps history book to make one motivating read! I highly recommend it to all Marines, past, present, and future--and to anyone else who knows a Marine or is interested in Marine history or training procedures. Semper Fi!

"Into the Crucible: The Making of a 21st Century Marine," by James B. Woulfe, is a fascinating nonfiction book that takes the reader into the Crucible, a component of U.S. Marine Corps training. Woulfe describes the Crucible as "a fifty-four-hour endurance course in which recruits conquer challenge after challenge in increasingly demanding conditions [. . .]. It features little food and sleep, plus forty miles of hiking." Emphasizing teamwork and leadership, the Crucible features a series of obstacles named after heroic Marines, most of them Medal of Honor recipients. In his brief foreword to the book Lt. Gen. Victor H. Krulak (USMC, ret.) describes the Crucible as "the classic culminating event of a rigorous revolution in the recruit's life."

Woulfe's narrative follows a group of recruits and their drill sergeant as the team works its way through the grueling rite of passage. As the squad passes through the stations they learn about the extraordinary heroism of the Marines after whom the obstacles are named. Woulfe describes the obstacles, which test both the recruits' physical abilities and problem solving skills, in intriguing detail. Woulfe weaves into the narrative much information about Marine Corps history. He writes about pioneering African-American Marines and the history of women in the Corps; he also covers Marine achievements in the Civil War, World War I, the Vietnam War, and other conflicts.

The author skillfully weaves a portrait of the Corps that brings together its past (in the history recounted) and its future (in the recruits). We learn about the backgrounds, personalities, and goals of the recruits. Woulfe vividly portrays the physical toll that the Crucible takes on these aspiring Marines. The book illuminates Marine esprit de corps, values, and heritage while revealing the complex process that transforms young men and women into Marines. I found this book to be both informative and inspiring. As an Army officer, I salute Woulfe for his work, and I salute the Marines whose stories he tells.

There are many books that look at the Marine Corps as a phenomenon, as a culture, as a training system, and as a psychology. There are many biographical and autobiographical surveys of those who make up the Corps past and present. However, this book is unique in looking at what has become known as the defining moment in the making of modern Marines -- the Crucible, a 54-hour rigourous test, an obstacle course to beat all obstacles courses, that recruits at the end of their basic training must pass in order to win the title of U.S. Marine.

This is the culmination, the capstone of the training. Author James B. Woulfe, now a captain in Marine Corps, who started out in the enlisted ranks in the 1980s, is assistant director of the Drill Instructor (DI) school at MCRD San Diego, the western training ground for Marines (recruits from east of the Mississippi go to Parris Island). Woulfe's book follows a dozen recruits and their DI through the stations of the Crucible.

In the Crucible, the body, mind and spirit of the recruit is tested. There are limits on food and rest designed to tax the recruits even more, as they work through the different trials of the Crucible. No one can make it through the Crucible alone -- most of the tests can only be done as a team; often members of the squad have to take a back-seat to their companions, sometimes dramatically (if a recruit has to pretend to be injured for the sake of the exercise, he is at the complete mercy of his squad's performance).

The Crucible has many stations, 32 combat exercises to complete in the 54-hour period. These challenges draw on the core values and chief skills developed during the previous weeks. As part of the indoctrination into the Marine Corps, the history of the Corps is written across the challenges. Eleven of the obstacles are named for Medal of Honour winners, with a twelfth named for another outstanding Marine; significantly, they are all enlisted/NCOs, not officers. The backbone of the Corps is the enlisted ranks, with sergeants at the top; there are more enlisted to officers by ratio in the Marine Corps than in any other service.

Woulfe begins with an introductory chapter that gives a very quick overview of the timeline of basic training as well as the emotions experienced through the eyes of several recruits. The beginning of the Crucible begins in the early morning hours, long before dawn, such that three days later the end of the Crucible will coincide with breakfast time, when survivors of the Crucible will eat their 'warriors' breakfast' as Marines.

Woulfe makes an important point throughout that while these are special men doing special things, they did not start out as being special other than that they opted to be Marines. The Marine Corps takes the average recruit and makes them something special -- Woulfe indicates that the Corps could take a bus-load of recruits heading to any of the services and turn them into Marines; still, it remains a success for the men who undergo this trial, one they are rightly proud of completing.

Through all of the grueling challenges, presented in good detail including the physical elements as well as the emotions of the men paritcipating, Woulfe carries the the narrative through at a brisk pace. The epilogue is moving, starting really with the final challenge, the climb of 'Mount Suribachi', the first pronouncement by the sergeant major of the recruits' transformation to Marines, and their final victory as men in the Corps. Truly inspiring!

As an active duty Marine with experience in both recruiting and recruit training, I can attest to both the accuracy and import of Capt Woulfe's book. He has synthesized the near-mystical process of making United States Marines using the experience of the final graduation event as a template for all of the lessons of Marine boot camp. In particular he focuses on the Corps' core values of honor, courage, and commitment and how they pertain to the ethos of the warrior. Past, present, and future Marines (and their parents and loved ones!) will benefit from this contemporary canvas of the longest and arguably the finest recruit training of any arm of the U.S. military. If I were truly interested in the development of the basic Marine, I would read Thomas Ricks' book first, followed by Jim Woulfe's book for the most accurate and descriptive account of the current process of minting America's Finest warriors.

Many books have been written about recruit training for the United States Marine Corps, but very few of them are based at San Diego, and most are of a period prior to the activiation of the Crucible as the final component. This book gives an accurate view of what the "Hollywood Marine" recruit goes through in their quest to become a Marine. The descriptions given place you there in the Crucible with the recruits and give you a small glimpse of what our young men & women face in the final days before they earn the title of MARINE.

This book is a must read for ALL families of Marine Recruits, east or west.

I highly recommend anyone with an interest in the nations military readiness to read, INTO THE CRUCIBLE" By Marine Capt. Jim Woulfe. The book is well written by a Marine on active duty that is participating in the training of young men that aren't always from the best of families, or the best environment. Some grew up in a world where crime, drugs, and gangs is the norm. Even after careful selection the Marine Corps recruiters cannot always select what the Corps would like to have in a recruit.

Having served in the Corps in WW-II I can testify that a youngster going into deadly battle is seldom trained sufficiently. However, the current final test when primary boot camp is completed is known as INTO THE CRUCIBLE. This final test is 56 hours of willpower, endurance and skill. When you read this well written book you will at times feel the pain of blisters on your feet, and the twinging of muscles in your arms and legs all accompanied with a growling and empty stomach. Whether lyou have went through Marine Corps Boot Training or not, you will believe that you have been there, done that, when you finish.

The books greatly describes the rigors of US Marine boot camp. I am a Lance Corporal in the Marine Corps and have been in for about a year, so I can tell you this book is up to date and accurate. This is another book I read prior to joining and it motivated me. I would recommend this anyone interested in learning what the recruits go through to earn the title of United States Marine. Robert_Ticehurst@Scudder.com if you want more comments on the Marine Corps or books.

This book was so interesting that I could not put it down. As a girlfriend of a Marine - it has helped me to understand more about his experiences and has increased my already considerable respect for the Marine Corps as a whole. This book will help you to understand just why it is the Marines are the finest fighting force in the world. I had expected it to be a dry read, but the narrative was so smooth that before I knew it I was at the last page. Highly recommended.

I just finished reading this book today, I am about to head on down to boot camp myself this summer and wanted to just get a little taste of what its going to be like in the crucible, this is a non-stop action packed book, it was so hard to put down, and usually I can't keep intrest in books. This told you the story of young men making their way to becoming a United States Marine. I recommend this for anyone who is joing or has joined or just anyone wanting to read an amazing book, it will give you a whole respect for what the USMC is all about.

Semper Fi

If you have an interest in Marine training, especially this very challenging drill that young men in boot camp must master to graduate, then this is a very informative read for you. I have a son who is a Marine and I wanted to understand the 13 week process that they go through in their training. By studying the training schedule and reading this book, I had more of an understanding of what he had gotten himself into. This is an incredibly grueling 52 hour "march" and training regimen--this Crucible. The author takes us through the very beginning of the march, what the recruits are thinking, feeling, their fatique, all the way to the long march back to bootcamp. We actually finally see a human side to the drill sargents, because they are participating in this as well. I really liked the way that the author took the reader from station to station and explained how each challenge was named for a particular Marine who had given his life and the valor behind the story. That is something you will not forget after reading this book. Another point is that there is so little contemporary material available concerning Marine training for readers such as myself, and this is so fresh and fairly easy to understand.