Most Helpful Customer Reviews
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Captivating Mystery Series, April 10, 2008
I am an adult who was an avid fan of Nancy Drew as a child. This series is fabulous on many counts. At the center of the story we have a brave and oh-so-resourceful 13-year-old GIRL, Ingrid, who seems to me very realistic. Echo Falls, her town, is a magical place that is a kind of Everytown-- you might want to move there yourself. As the mysteries unfold, Ingrid is trying to learn her way around town. (Can you adults remember a day when the geography of your hometown was a mystery to you?) The mystery plots are well-crafted, but beyond that how comforting it is to find yourself, in this three-book series, in a familiar place where you feel you know-- through Ingrid's eyes-- the local orthodontist, soccer coach and ice cream parlor. And when you meet Mom, Dad, Grampy, big brother Ty and dog Nigel, your world is complete. Although some may find this third in the series "dark," I found the Lemony Snicket series much darker and unpleasant. And as I recall, some not-so-good things happened in Harry Potter. Bravo to a wonderfully-written, imaginative series. Can't wait for the fourth installment!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Not your everyday detective story., May 19, 2008
As an adult who's read Holmes, and as a child who read every single Nancy Drew book she could get her hands on, along with the Hardy Boys and Boxcar children, I'm no newcomer to the mystery genre of any age group. And I have to say, Ingrid is my favorite gumshoe of all. This series is excellent for fans of the Sammy Keyes books (another awesome heroine.) Echo Falls is filled to the brim with shady characters, and Ingrid's prepared to take them all down. In this third installment, Abrahams really gets into the dark (haha, see what I did there?) nitty gritty, with Ingrid's parents' marriage in trouble, and her grandfather in the worst trouble of all: he's become a suspect to murder. Ingrid, of course, is on the case with her trusty sidekick dog, Nigel (a throwback to good old Watson). Into the Dark encompasses a wide range of real-life situations in addition to the murder she must solve. The family problems are deep, and Abrahams does a good job of mirroring reality (he really takes no shortcuts). For any parent who wishes to supply their child with a great role model, give your kid the gift of this series. Ingrid isn't perfect, but she marches her way through her problems with a dignity and shrewdness that many adults don't have. Which is why I also recommend this book to adults. I'd say a few of you could learn a thing or two from Ingrid.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A New Definition of Courage, May 8, 2008
Abrahams packs his stories of Echo Falls with so much symbolism and hidden (or deferred) meaning an adult will read them with as much satisfaction as the child. He proceeds intuitively, as Ingird does, always referring back to the logical methods of Sherlock Holmes to ground her. In the present case, INTO THE DARK, don't you love how little Brucie tries to force everyone in the play into adopting Dr. Strangelove-style German accents when they are going to be putting on HANSEL AND GRETEL? It's a cute scene but when you finish with the whole book you can see it as a foreshadowing of what eventually happens to Ingrid when she attempts to rescue Nigel from the place where he has been confined. I did guess the reason why the conservation agent had been shot to death, but the story is nevertheless breathtakingly told and the last eighty pages rush by in a single clump. Abrahams uses the bleakness of the snowy landscape--the white of the snow, the brown of the trees, the gray of the sky--to illustrate how little by little everything that Ingrod once took for granted has been stripped from her--her belief in the sanctity of her parents' marriage, her dependence on "Grampy," even the fact of her dog always being there for her. I still don't exactly understand why Grampy kept quiet when he was being accused of murder, but maybe the fourth book in the series will explain it a little better. In any case this is the most exciting crime series being written in this country, either for juveniles or adults, so we're lucky.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|