25 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Warning: Useful for Beginners, but Not for Advanced Students, June 21, 2001
This review is from: Introduction to Korean History and Culture (Hardcover)
INTRODUCTION TO KOREAN HISTORY AND CULTURE has now passed through at least three editions, so it is probably the passing standard for histories of Korea. It is useful and generally correct, however, it is no longer cutting edge.
Recent archaeological discoveries and the continuing maturation of South Korean political culture have increased debate about many topics in the history of the Korean peninsula. But, still, Professor Nahm's role in this movement has to be acknowledged. His works are probably the first popular tomes most non-Koreans have consulted about Korean history.
The most serious deficiency about this book, and nearly all mass market books about Korea, is the perspective, that Korea is a political entity existing since prehistory. Many nations have existed on the Korean peninsula and in Manchuria, and the idea of a Korean national history is problematic and controversial. This book adds nothing, because it antedates it, to this contemporary debate. It is highly questionable, if Choson peasants or Koryo aristocrats had a national consciousness. Identifying Koryo or Choson as Korean is a subtle form of propaganda, not good historical writing.
This book is also riddled with awkward phrasings and typographical errors. As with most books on Korea, the transliteration scheme is always problematic, and the use of different schemes, is confusing. Because, for instance one person (e.g. Lee Syng Man) is known best in the West as Syngman Rhee, his name is so transliterated, but other persons and places are transliterated differently. This confusion is always irritating.
The final sections on modern South and North Korea are sparse and uncritical, and do not reflect the depth of debate in South Korean society. if Professor Nahm has any perspective, it is pro-development, but by which political regime? By echewing partisan labels, this book sacrifices substance and depth. This book is no more critical than the bad history taught in the schools.
As a quick reference quide, this book is still useful, but with a great deal of caution. There are other more relevant and insightful introductions. But this book has a deserved place in the evolution of Korean scholarship, and in Korean history.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Introduction to Korean History and Culture., January 6, 2012
This review is from: Introduction to Korean History and Culture (Hardcover)
I HAVE KNOWN AND MARRIED A KOREAN-AMERICAN FOR 37 YEARS. IT MAKES ME PROUD TO KNOW OF MY WIFE'S CULTURAL AND HISTORICAL ROOTS. IT SEALS THAT BOND WHEN TWO PEOPLE OF DIFFERENT RACES ARE TRULY IN LOVE.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No