Most Helpful Customer Reviews
32 of 36 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Exactly what is needed, November 4, 2003
This review is from: Introduction to Linear Algebra, Second Edition (Hardcover)
Dr. Strang's book is, hands down, the best introductory Linear Algebra text on the planet. Other reviewers complain about the "discovery" approach and the conversational style; in my view, these are strengths not flaws. First of all, we have lost our way with modern mathematics texts by all but eliminating the idea of discovery. Nothing can strengthen the learning and understanding of mathematical material more than having to "find out for yourself" what is going on. Absent that process, one can only reach a superficial understanding of the topic at best. Second, it's refreshing to see a truly conversational approach. Once again, there are too many dry definition-theorem-proof texts out there ... they're maybe appropriate for a more advanced exposition, not for an introduction. In many ways I agree with Dr. Strang that we teach too much calculus and not enough linear algebra. The former has been the standard sequence for undergraduate mathematics for years; nifty stuff but seldom, if ever, seen outside the classroom. Linear algebra, on the other hand, is alive and well in industry and just may be the most useful set of mathematical tools available to the technical types. Everone studying or using linear algebra would find time spent with Dr. Strang's book an excellent time investment. And for those not liking discovery or conversation, maybe you should try a different course of study ... you've missed the boat on this one!!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
66 of 87 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Too much emphasis on "discovery", June 17, 2003
This review is from: Introduction to Linear Algebra, Second Edition (Hardcover)
With only two days from my final exam in Linear Algebra, I figured it's a good time to review this text, briefly. I really like the author. I enjoyed watching the video lectures at the MIT website associated with this book, given by the author himself. The problem is that he doesn't explain the topics as clearly in the text as he does in his lectures. There is entirely too much emphasis on the "discovery" approach. Instead of just clearly explaining many of the important subjects like Determinants and Eigenvalues/Eigenvectors, he chooses to leave the student in the dark to "discover' these for himself or herself. I don't mind this method in small doses. However, it ends up being a frustrating experience when trying to do homework assignments. He dips into the abstract without warning, draws many conclusions that require one to read the sections over and over again, trying to grasp the concept. In future editions, I would recommend removing some of these more difficult concepts from the problem sets and, instead, placing them into the text where they really belong. As a final example, I would appreciate it if Dr. Strang would link-up the concepts of Column Space, Nullspace, etc to Orthogonals to Eigenvalues/Eigenvectors in some way....How about a two or three page sidebar that ties them together. This would have made the subject much clearer than it is in this edition.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Best Linear Algebra Textbook for Qualified Beginners., September 25, 1998
By A Customer
This review is from: Introduction to Linear Algebra, Second Edition (Hardcover)
I hope comment writors can be more responsible about his or her comment. Try not to put emotion words in display. A great book will not be shattered by those words. As an educator for half of my life at an advanced institute, I have used this particular textbook for entry level class successfully. Each university attracts students of different interest and level. No textbook is fit for all level of students. If teacher agrees with his students this book is too difficult for his class. Maybe they should consider to change the textbook. For elementary level class, Bernard Kolman's Introductory Linear Algebra with Application is very good. For entry level science and engineering class, Strang's textbook is by far the best. For math students at higher level, Lax's Linear Algebra is the best choice. Unfortunately, the college student's math level has been down persistently for many years. For my class, this is still the textbook for beginners, maybe I should say qualified beginners.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|