Customer Reviews

Introduction to Modern Statistical Mechanics

5 star:		(7)
4 star:		(4)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

The best part of this book is that it is modern. You have chapters on Monte Carlo simulations, the Ising model, and more. You don't get long chapters on the partition function of an ideal gas, for example. The bad part about this book is that it is not immediately transparent if you're reading stat mech for the first time. I like it more the more I know about stat mech, but it's not a good beginner's book, and I think it's better to have another book with it - maybe Hill or McQuarrie - since it's not really that long either. Still, recommended (get the soln. manual too) with these caveats.

This was a great book. It covered the important material and left out all of the extra garbage that most books carry on for pages about. The presentation was done using clear mathematics and modern, easily followed notation. The book is short making it practical to actually read the entire book if you are extremely busy. We used the book in conjunction with Hill. I don't recommend Hill because it is hard to follow.

I used this book while taking the course for which this book was designed, Prof. Chandler's stat mech course for first year graduate students.

I agree with the reviewer who wrote that this book avoids a lot of filler that can distort the main thrust of the material at hand.

I disagree with the reviewer who wrote that this is not the book for a beginner. I used this book having studied undergrad p-chem but essentially no stat mech. Being a concise text, one must read carefully to extract the point of each paragraph. I sometimes found myself re-reading certain sections a few times in order to understand them. The abundant prose should be evidence that the author is trying to provide a physical picture to improve the scientific intuition of the reader.

This doesn't mean the book isn't for a beginner. It just means what you should already know: you will not learn stat mech by skimming any text just once with a pint of beer in your hand.

I constantly return to this book for review of thermo and stat mech concepts. For my grad qualifying exams I mostly used McQuarrie for general p-chem overview, but switched right back to IMSM for thermo and stat mech review.

If you're looking for a reference book with every possible stat mech problem worked out to help with your problem sets, this is not it. If you want to understand stat mech this book is the first step.

If this is your first time taking a grad-level course in statistical mechanics, this should not be your only book. Chandler's writing is incredibly difficult to follow and often frustrating unless you already have a decent grasp on the concepts. My impression is that if you already understand stat mech fairly well, the conciseness of this book may aid you in getting a "big picture" view of the most important methods and results of stat mech without the dross that tends to dilute other books. (One advantage in this regard is that Chandler often uses more general forms of statistical mechanics equations, e.g. not limiting work to P-V work in many contexts.) If you are looking to acquire an understanding of stat mech for the first time, try Statistical Mechanics by McQuarrie.

After learning almost nothing in my graduate course on stat mech taught by a famous physicist, I decided I would have to teach myself Stat Mech over the summer. When I found this book, I really started to make progress. Right away I got the big picture on what statistical mechanics is all about, and that made all the difference. I was able to work my way quickly through the book, doing the problems as they came along in text and understand almost everything.

I wasn't able to make it through the denser chapters at the end on nonequilibrium stat mech on my own, but the book was well worth the price and is one of my favorites. The explanations are pure gold.

A few tips for the reader:
1. Do the problems as your read. The best place for the problems in a textbook is in the text itself, not at the end of the chapter.

2. Get the solutions manual
I purchased the solutions manual so that I could check my solutions. It had about half the solutions and only half of them worked out in detail, but it was still very useful for getting started on some of the problems I wasn't sure how to approach.

3. Make a notation conversion chart
Some of the greek letters are different than the usual notation for physics courses, so I had to make a notation conversion chart on the front inside cover and that was very helpful.

4. If you find the book too hard, use Schroeder's book as an introduction.

5. Be prepared to see a missing spot on your shelf.
I'm constantly loaning this book out to people in my research group and other students.

A clear, concise explanation of statistical mechanics. Some people may complain about the "concise" part--in many cases, mathematical exercises are left as exercises to the student. However, this practice allows the reader to really understand the material by doing, not just reading. I learned stat mech for the first time from this book, and only examined other texts (mcquarrie or hill) afterwards.

The book starts with an adiabatic system instead of isolated system, which makes the following derivation more pretty and casts a new insight into the stat. mech.. The only flaw is that it is too concise.

This is by far the most concise treatment of thermo and stat mech. I have came across. If you want something that goes to the point and is filled with gem, this is it.

However, it is very mathematical and at times hard to follow. This is not a book you can sit down in the sun and glimpse through. But at the same time, it is a great introductory textbook for those willing to accept the challenge. Unlike the other textbooks, this provides a physical intuition and leaves no rock unturn. In short, it is a hard book...but a good book.

This book is very brief, and a nice reference to have, but I would not recommend for an introduction to statistical mechanics. McQuarrie's text is much more thorough, and great for a upper level undergraduate or graduate course. For a very basic overview of the canonical ensemble Molecular Thermodynamics, by McQuarrie and Simon is a nice resource. Overall, Introduction to Modern Statistical Mechanics is stat mech in its briefest form, and useful for a physical chemist's reference shelf.

Chandler's "Introduction to Modern Statistical Mechanics" is a wonderful book: clear, complete, intense, enjoyable and short. Yes, it is short, because here there are no useless digressions or repetitions, it gets straight to the point, sometimes condensating a lot of results in a sentence.
I used this book to fill the gap between the basic thermodynamic and modern statatistical mechanics, expecially for understand the concept behind monte carlo simulation I studied for the computational physics course. I made the right choise using this book.
I have to remark that this book, while very satisfactory, is not "simple". It assumes that the reader has other references at hand(I used Hill's "introduction to statistical thermodynamics" and Fermi's "thermoynamics") and the many exercises do not have solutions.
Anyway, Chandler's book is perfect for understanding both thermodynamics (the first chapters are pure art) and statistical mechanics with an eye on computation.