Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
brilliant and intoxicating, May 17, 2005
I'm very careful about what science (or math. or anything that's not MBA) that I read, because usually these texts are dry, boring to the point of What's the Point? Why would an author write a book that seems to deliberately set out to lose readers is my question. But The Invisible Century is one of those extremely rare books (Bill Bryson's Short History of the World is the only other one in recent memory I can think of) that is not just fascinating, but also fascinatingly written, and that makes some extremely difficult ideas -- Einstein's theory's of relativy, hello? -- almost thrillingly understandable. I put down this book, and for the first time felt I understand what Einstein was driving at. Ditto went for Freud's theory of the unconscious.
Panek's amazing point (kind of profound, when you think about it) is that Einstein began probing the heavens at the same time Freud began experimenting with his theories of the unconsicous -- that basically both men (who did meet once, acc. to Panek!), were after the secrets that lay behind invisible screens -- Einstein the sky, and what lay beyond it, and Freud our dreamworld and our id. Really fascinating stuff.
Now as a topic, none of this is easy sledding. But it's RIchard Panek's great gift to make these profound contributions by two of the towering geniuses of the last century into something succinct, intriguing, readable, and easy-to-understand, while never patronizing the reader, or lapsing back into over-intellectual science talk. Except for the Bryson book, I didn't think there was such a thing as a science book I could not put down. But this is one. Buy The Invisible Century right now! You'll be glad you did!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting comparative study, May 4, 2011
Well, not so much a 'study' per se as an extended meditation on science, imagination, and the history of both in which Einstein and Freud serve as exemplars. Those critiques of TIC which take issue with its seeming elevation of Freud to a status, as theorist, on par with that of Einstein are, I think, mistaking Panek's intention. Though it is true that Panek has little to say about the empirical shortcomings of Freud's project (though not nothing altogether), he is quite right, I think, to see in Freud's project the same seeds of creativity and motivated truth seeking that propelled Einstein's own work. Panek's point is not that Freud was a scientist like Einstein was a scientist, but that both were representative of their time and similar in some important ways. Panek does a very nice job of establishing who these seminal figures were, what they did, and why, and why the life/work of one sheds light on that of the other. Less one star for a certain degree of redundancy in the writing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4.0 out of 5 stars
Very accessible, March 7, 2011
Panek is very good at describing and explaining technical topics at the intelligent-layman level. This book and his "4% Universe" can actually give you a decent understanding of cosmology and the link to particle physics without the burden of having to know mathematics! 4% Universe would be a nice history introduction to a physics or astronomy student, but is not the place for finding actual technical data. The Invisible Century is also a very good high-level description of how modern science and scentific theory evolved from earlier scientific and pre-scientific thinking and analysis. The Einstein and Freud stories are discussed in parallel and you will be able to see how the combination of mathematical prediction and reproducible experiments distinguished the field of modern physics from psychoanalysis. This is also seen in the 4% Universe, as cosmology evolves from "just talk" to math and experiment-based science.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|