Most Helpful Customer Reviews
5.0 out of 5 stars
Common Iranians and their crude reality., May 15, 2010
This review is from: Iran on the Brink: Rising Workers and Threats of War (Paperback)
This is a solid book, supported by local research and self contrasted with relevant authors on the field (Abrahamian, Afary, Maziar, Hiro, Parsa...)
The book is divided in two parts, the first one deals with the iranian common citizen and its fate through revolution and islamic regime up to 2.006, that's after Ahmadineyad's rise to presidency (and good insights on this event indeed).
The second part deals with the current international crisis with Iran, and clearly shows why the common iranian, although has very little to gain from his own regime, won't have any other choice but to support it. Sadly, that's the conclusion.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
0 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Why the world focuses on Iran, February 8, 2008
This review is from: Iran on the Brink: Rising Workers and Threats of War (Paperback)
Andreas Malm and Shora Esmailian provide a thorough if leftist history of the fall of the Shah of Iran and the rise of the ayatollahs. Their political perspective weights this complex story as they delve into the political parties, conflicts, motives and factional disputes that brought the ayatollahs to power. Today, Iran has a very complicated political environment as Communist and U.S. ideologies confront radical Islam. The authors reach a few odd conclusions, fall into hackneyed rhetoric about the bourgeoisie, and present very tainted views of Israel, though, if you must quote Ahmadinejad to meet your book's purpose, it's hard to avoid rhetoric straight from the source's mouth. The authors know Iran and analyze its politics in depth. They provide background on the leftist labor parties, their interactions with Islamic radicals, and Iran's controversial nuclear and oil policies. getAbstract thinks that those who read this with an awareness of its filters will find a telling, alternative perspective on a dangerous problem.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
0 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Leftoid Account of Important Matters, July 29, 2008
This review is from: Iran on the Brink: Rising Workers and Threats of War (Paperback)
As Patrick Clawson stated in the Middle East Quarterly, the dramatic polarization of American politics has led leftist critics of the Bush administration to assume that Iran's Islamic Republic cannot be all that bad if President George W. Bush describes it as part of an "axis of evil." Feeding this attitude are suspicions that the crisis over Iran's nuclear program is a tawdry rehash of the dubious intelligence about weapons of mass destruction that helped instigate the Iraq war, or the belief that displaying any concern for the Iranian people plays into the hands of Bush administration warmongers. This narrative leaves little room for concern about what is happening to the people of Iran--even the left-wing Iranian workers' movements that should be natural objects of leftist sympathy.
As reporters for the Swedish left-wing weekly Arbetaren (The worker), Malm and Esmailian approach Iran from a position of traditional left-wing concern about workers, human rights, and despotism. They spent much of 2004 traveling around Iran, meeting with those facing the growing repression to which the reform movement was subjected as it was being shut down. Their focus is on ordinary Iranian workers, not on the Westernized intellectuals who usually win foreigners' attention. Malm and Esmailian provide graphic accounts of those workers' suffering under the cruel tyranny of the Islamic Republic and of the vicious repression to which they are subject.
Make no mistake: This book is situated firmly in the camp of the hard Left, which sees Israel's evil hand everywhere and cannot imagine Bush ever doing anything good. Malm and Esmailian's discussion of nuclear issues is a mélange of conspiracy theories, ill-informed speculation, and plain error. Iran on the Brink can hardly be recommended as a guide to Iran and the challenges it poses to the region and to world peace. That said, it is nice to see some leftists who are willing to highlight the Islamic Republic's brutal treatment of the poor people of Iran.
Malm and Esmailian spend a great deal of time on Iranian history, primarily to highlight the evils inflicted on the country by Western imperialism--disregarding that the development of the country's oil resources is what allowed Iran to modernize under the shah. However, their historical account also brings out in detail what the Islamic Republic works so hard to suppress--namely, that the 1978-79 anti-shah revolution was a broad social movement that was hijacked by Islamists who were distinctly in the minority among the revolutionaries.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|