Customer Reviews

The Irish Cinderlad (Trophy Picture Books)

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

I enjoyed this reversal (in more than one way) of Cinderella. Here its a boy--with big feet. (Made me wonder if Tolkein had read this somewhere along the way). He is mistreated by his stepmother and sister, but instead of a fairy godmother, gets a magic bull. (This really proclaims the irishness of the story to me, instantly bringing Cuchulain to mind).

The story is fun and I really loved the last line that the princess has. I liked the illustrations, for the scenery, but the people were weirldy childish looking to me, especially in comparison to the magnificent bull that we get to see our hero befriend.

The Irish Cinderlad is a continuation of Climo's journey in theCinderella folktales. Children can see how a boy can also be part ofthe Cinderella story. Educators can use this story to demonstrate thesimilarities between different cultures around the world. The illustrations in this book continue with the high standards set in the other "Cinderella" stories in this series.

This is a Cinderella book but based in Ireland. The Irish have their own twist on this classic in which Becan our Hero is the awkward boy growing up with the evil Stepmother and Stepsisters. Perfect for those little boys who are going through the tough stages that not all Mommy's can help with.

I also recommend The Rough Faced Girl, and Yeh Shen to go with this collection.

Our family is collecting Cinderella stories from around the world. With our Irish heritage this is a great addition! The illustrations are done very well.

If you want to compare and contrast Cinderella stories, this one has a lot to write about. Some of my students were amazed at the cultural differences. It takes a bit more mature group (I teach 3rd grade), but is definitely a good comparison.