Most Helpful Customer Reviews
21 of 25 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Phenomenal, May 14, 2004
Iron Dragon's Daughter, an amalgam of steampunk and fairy, will have you screaming, laughing, and crying all at the same time. This is perfected madness, incredible storytelling. Iron Dragon is one of the smartest books I've read in ages. The story follows a changeling, Jane, who is placed in a factory to work alongside other enslaved fairy children. Their task . . . to build weapons. The conditions are awful, the quality of life is awful, and the future is less than promising. That's until the Dragon, Number 7332, begins to tempt Jane with tales of the outside world. He offers her freedom, but the cost . . . Honestly, I am going to have to read this novel again. Swanwick has a tendency to jump around, and it's not that it's poorly done, it's just sometimes difficult to follow. I'm sure I missed things, and the quality of this story is so great, that I want to make sure I catch every last detail. Fans of fantasy, steampunk and fairy stories in general will adore this book. It's worth the investment. I borrowed the copy from a friend, and have since gone out and purchased my own. I don't want to share it! Happy Reading!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
23 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A powerful, challenging, and useful book, June 22, 1998
By A Customer
Those who come to "The Iron Dragon's Daughter" expecting a straightforward fantasy story (or even a semi-straightforward steampunk story) are destined to be disappointed. It is a complex and open-ended book that places heavy demands on its readers. However, readers who struggle through the whole thing (and it wasn't a struggle at all for me -- I read the book in a few days, enjoying myself enormously after getting used to Swanwick's deliberate, meditative pace) will be rewarded by a book that is intricate, delicate, and possessing an optimism that completely belies its surface darkness. Its plot is convoluted and fugal: the same set of themes is repeated three times, and then, in a coda which is _not_ the equivalent of "then she woke up", is repeated as a counterpoint for a fourth, final time. The characters are difficult and often unsympathetic: the changeling child Jane, who sits at the focus of the book, possesses such a weak moral compass (and suffers so much abuse) that by the end of the novel, even the most sympathetic of readers will have given up on her. Finally, the questions posed by the novel are not resolved in any straightforward way: much of the most interesting information in the book is buried in implication, and some things we just aren't meant to figure out. The surface story is simple: Jane is a changeling girl, a drudge straight out of Dickens who labors endlessly in a large and grimy dragon factory. The dragons are one of the first of many delights in the novel, being sentient and ruthless stealth weapons used by the elven overlords of Jane's world in their endless battles for supremacy. They are, in short, total cyberpunk wish-fulfillment devices. Jane is contacted by an ancient, powerful, and cagey dragon, who outlines a way by which both he and she can escape the factory. His plan brings about the first of many compromises that Jane is pressured into within the book, and from there the book is about the tension between Jane and the dragon, as she reach! es towards maturity and her own flawed understanding of the world and her place within it. This book can be read as a parable about growing up, an allegory of the tradeoffs necessary to get ahead as a woman in contemporary society (presented in the bleakest, most savage terms imaginable), or simply as a satire of genre fantasy and cyberpunk. I've always thought of Swanwick as being a slightly more accessible Gene Wolfe, and nowhere is that impulse towards virtuosity and subtle command of the English language more evident than in this book. This is one of those books that continues to grow, luminously, in my memory, and one of a very small collection of science fiction novels that I think everyone should read.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
It was only a Dream...not really, January 1, 1998
This ultimately is a sad book, in more ways than one. The (lost or stolen? it is never cleared up) human child Jane toils in the Steam-Dragon Plant, seeking escape and solace; she seems to find an ally in the disabled Moloch Dragon in the scrapyard, together planning to escape....and then the novel gets lost, or more properly never decides on a direction. Yes, it does defy stereotype, refusing to follow *expected* rules--just when I think I know what will happen to Jane next, something else twists the tale completely out of shape. This should be a good thing, only here it keeps disappointing. Jane seems to be the only human in a semi-magic world--she is not really discovered nor is her significance quite explained. Ideas are introduced, the enchanted toys Jane is supposed to play with, the addition of Decembers into a long, cold winter, the College of Magic, the Mechanical Horse who befriends Jane, yet they ultimately pan out, or never develop. The symbols of a needle and a dogs tail are seen frequently--but what did they mean? The great Moloch Dragon Jane steals to escape--this is one of the high points of Swanwicks novel, the exhileration....yet it only leads to another drab end, Jane seems to spend much time in an enchanted shopping mall and school, just another *ordinary* adolescent? I found Moloch himself less Evil than sullen, selfish--he bickers with Jane yet desires her aid. And in the end? The Dragon exhausts himself, reduced to a tiny fluttering thing...Jane *awakes* from possible autism...into what kind of world? The beginning bore almost a macabre beauty, the end was just another confused young woman--had anything been really answered? Though Swanwick avoids the cliches of fantasy, he also avoids any fulfillment of it either. Only for those who *chuckle at Kafka*.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|