Customer Reviews

The Iron Dream

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(7)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(2)

 

 

Holding a spot in science fiction/fantasy legend as 'the book that was meant to be bad', Norman Spinrad's "The Iron Dream" is a thought provoking look humanity's violent impulses and the dark side of bad pulp writing. The concept is simple enough: Adolf Hitler, dismissing the nascent Nazi Party as a bunch of beer hall debaters, leaves Munich for The United States in 1919. He scrapes by as an illustrator and fanzine editor for several years before switching to science fiction novels. "The Iron Dream" purports to be his last work, dashed off in a mere six weeks before he died in 1953.

As an exercise in tedious, repetitive action and sledgehammer philosophy, "The Iron Dream" makes its point in bold strokes. We follow protagonist Feric Jagger as he travels to his homeland of Heldon, the only genetically untainted homeland in a world otherwise overrun with foul mutants. Musing on the importance of genetic purity in almost every paragraph, Feric forms a motorcycle gang into 'the Knights of the Swastika' and marches off to dominate first Heldon, then the world. The second half of the book unfolds as an orgy of violence, as Feric's forces slash, smash, and blast their way through massive armies of mutants under the sway of the mind-controlling Dominators of Zind.

Through this exaggerated take on pulp SF, Spinrad makes us look the aspects of our genre that many may wish to deny. For sure, a lot of crap science fiction and fantasy has featured unbridled bloodlust and unsublte promotion of a philosophy not far from fascism. For all that, though, one might be tempted to say that Spinrad went too far, and that surely not even the dumbest fan would be tricked by something so absurd. This would be wrong. Not only did much pulp nonsense from the 50's and 60's actually reflect such idealogy, but so does some stuff getting published today. Anyone who's had the misfortune to come across books by Terry Goodkind or Robert Newcomb, for instance, knows how those authors hew uncomfortably close to the faux Hitler's celebration of fascism, genocide, and ultraviolent misogyny. (Interestingly Goodkind and Newcomb also duplicate the lesser details of "The Iron Dream", such as the hilarious abuse of phallic symbols and the creepy obsession with boots and skin-tight black leather for both genders. Perhaps Spinrad should consider a plagarism lawsuit.)

The book's crown jewel is an afterword by a stuffy academic. Homer Whipple of New York University offers biographical details (Hitler suffered from syhpilis late in life), saucy gossip (he was known as something of a Don Juan at science fiction conventions), fan reactions (the fanciful costumes he described in the book are now favorites at costume parties), historical background (the fall of Germany to the communists in 1939 remained a sore point throughout Hitler's life), and much more. Having decided to write the book, Spinrad milked the concept for everything it was worth. For instance, the inside cover urges us to enjoy another list of fine SF classics by Adolf Hitler. It starts with inoccuous titles like "Emperor of the Asteroids", but then moves to more sinister titles such as "The Master Race" and "The Thousand Year Rule". How many SF authors have begun their careers with harmless pulp adventure, but swamped their later works with barrels of dsitrubing personal philosophy?

"The Iron Dream" is not perfect. As Ursula K. Leguin remarked in a review, it could have been quite a bit shorter. But though not a great novel, it is an important novel. Regrettably it is out of print now, but if you spot a copy floaitng around in your local used book store or at a garage sale, snap it up.

I read this book years ago and enjoyed it immensely. Call it satire, call it alternative history; whatever you call it, it's amazing. If I were reviewing the actual printed version of this novel, I'd give it four or possibly even five stars.

But I give the Kindle Edition one star because it is absolutely RIDDLED with errors. I can live with a few mistakes, but this goes just too far. There is a character named "Waffing." Literally half the time he is called "Waning." "Feric," the book's protagonist, is often "Peric." Exclamation points are replaced with the number one. It's clear that no care, attention to detail, or effort was put forth in preparing the electronic version. If they were charging a buck for it, fine. But this is $8.00, a real book price. For that I expect a real book.

This edition is just disgraceful. It shows no respect for the book, the author, or the readers.

Ostensibly THE IRON DREAM was written by one Adolph Hitler, who, rather than remaining in Europe and starting WW 2, emigrated to the United States in 1919 and made a career as an artist and writer of science-fiction. It concerns the career of one Feric Jaggar on a far-future Earth, where only he and his great weapon, The Steel Commander, stand between what remains of humanity and its annihilation at the hands of the evil Dominators and the mutant hordes they control. Reading it, one's first reaction is that if the Museum of Bad Art had a literary wing, this book would be in it, because it is a book "too bad to be ignored." But then, about a quarter of the way in, one begins to see the strong parallels between the fictional career of Feric Jaggar and the actual career of Adolph Hitler and his Nazi followers -- allowing, of course, for the fact that wish-fulfillment on the part of author Hitler makes the book's ultimate denouement rather different than the turns history actually took as a result of politician Hitler's impact on it. By about halfway in, one begins to notice another set of parallels: that between the style and subject of this book and those of a great deal of the less reputable output of the science-fiction community over the years -- and the mind-set of so many of s-f fans, who gobble up that output with the mindless enthusiasm of a horse going at a bin full of oats. At that point it is crystal-clear that this book is a masterful send-up of all that's wrong with the culture of science-fiction, as well as a psychohistorical tour de force that reveals in all its appalling chaos the workings of the mind of one of history's most famous psychopaths, Adolph Hitler. Spinrad never loses control here for even a moment. A truly wonderful read for those who appreciate history and love the best in science-fiction, rather than its worst, this is even better than his THE MEN IN THE JUNGLE, which has to be among the fifty best works of science-fiction ever written.

A satire of fascism, the bulk of "The Iron Dream" purports to be a novel penned by popular science-fiction writer Adolf Hitler, whom we are told in the prologue emigrated to the United States after WWI. Set many generations after a nuclear war, the novel follows the career of Feric Jaggar, genetically pure human, as he mobilizes the post-apocalyptic remnants of homo sapiens to war against various races of mutants who contest the supremacy of mankind's hegemony over the Earth. A loose retelling of the real Hitler's career follows, complete with a perversely happy ending in which the protagonist ensures that his armies of "blond-haired, blue-eyed supermen" will forever rule the world. Important in its accurate portrayal of Nazi mentality as well as for convincingly displaying that the tropes of science-fiction and heroic fantasy easily lend themselves to fascist ideology. Particularly disturbing is the author's demonstration that Hitler's worldview was at once evil and highly Romantic, replete with mysticism, noble heroes, foul villains and a powerful sense of destiny. Worthwhile reading for strong stomachs.

This is a truly remarkable book. I first read it upon the recommendation of my father. I was 12. Four years later, it is still one of my all time favorite books. Set in a post nuclear-holocaust era, it traces the rise to power of a nobody, who lived among the mutant pools, and only moved to the pure human area as an adult (Hitler lived in Austria, was a nobody, came to Germany...). He fights his way to power over the corrupt government (the Weimar Republic), and has an obsession, it seems, for tight black leather and huge crowds. He vows to destroy all mutant scum (Jews) and defeat the cold, heartless superpower led by evil, mind-controlling creatures (Communism, led by Jews). He succeeds, with a surprise twist at the end. The book is supposedly written by an Adolph Hitler, who was a mediocre science-fiction writer. The Second World War never happened.Satire within satire. It is a rather gory book, so I wouldn't recommend it to the very young (OK, so my dad is a little weird!). But if you love science fiction, satire, Second World War history, or if you want a chilling yet amusing futuristic view of a world where Hitler would win - READ IT.

What would have happened if Hitler left Germany, came to the states, and wrote sci fi? The question will sound absurd, but only until you read this novel. Many people describe Iron Dream as satire, but I think it is far deeper for such a term. Rather, Spinrad forces the reader to imagine the world in the way Hitler saw it and then makes you hope his side wins (in this book they are the good guys). As an intellectual exercise, reading this novel is both exciting and perverse but well worth the read.

Fascinating and hilarious alternative-universe what-if about Hitler. Spinrad takes Hitler's way of writing and turns it into a wild and blood-soaked tale that is just a notch more sadistic and weirdly romantic than most such post-apocalyptic SF tales.
The battle scenes are expressive of an artistic imagination that can't imagine anything more noble than the utter annihilation of one's racial enemies. Some reviewers find that to be boring--I don't! It's intriguing in a sociopathic way, extremely vivid, and just what Hitler might have written. Nice to see that Spinrad has really been studying Mein Kampf!
My only criticism is the homoerotic flavor that pervades the story. I have yet to see any convincing evidence that Hitler was gay, and I think it is simply unnecessary to add it here.
The best part was the Afterword by "Homer Whipple," who points out that the Soviet Union murdered millions of Jews, and now the Unites States and the Empire of Japan is surrounded by the Soviets, leading one to wonder if that alternative universe is any better off than ours. Is this a certain Nazi sympathy on Spinrad's part? Read his intro to "Hitler Victorious" and decide for yourself.

This book is a brillant satire on the scifi genre, the people today stating that "this would not have happened to me", and the fascist ideas of Hitler. Be sure to get the irony; in Germany this book was not published till the mid 80s because of "young readers cannot be supposed to understand that this is a satire"... Just one question: what's the point in a satire? That everything is obvious, or what? This book encourages thinking about WWII and European (especially German) history MUCH more than any history book I presently know of...

This book should remain in print and it's sad it hasn't. Simply, it helps point out how so much of our culture--like the whole Lord of the Rings schtick--is easily transmuted into Nazi ideology. This was a brave and brilliant book.

I'm sorry one reviewer was annoyed by the wooden writing. It is meant to be a parody of that kind of stuff, and the kind of mentality that goes behind it. Far too much older science fiction reads like this.

The Iron Dream is a brilliant, perversely fascinating book. It claims to be the science fiction novel Hitler would have written if he had immigrated to the U.S. in 1919 and become a novelist. It is the story of Feric Jaggar, the purest of the human genotype, as he battles mutants for world domination. You find yourself rooting for him, half realizing that it is meant to parallel the Nazi party. Thought provoking, and be sure to read the afterword