Customer Reviews

It Is & It Isn't

5 star:		(2)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(3)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

Gordon Haskell is probably one of the most forgotten former King Crimson members. He provided vocals on the tune "Cadence And Cascade" from the In The Wake Of Poseidon LP,as well as bass guitar and vocals on the Lizard album. This version of Crimson, though awesomely creative in the studio didn't hang together long enough to tour. A year after this sadly overlooked release Haskell recorded this,his first solo record. His trademark vocals are wonderful and his lyrics poetic and introspective. This is much more mainstream in sound than the densely experimental work Crimson did in this period, though still progressive.Haskell opts for acoustic guitar as his instument of choice, while future Crimsman John Wetton provides the bass, along with backing vocals and organ. Very nice arrangements. "Sitting By The Fire", "Worms", and "Benny" are standout tracks; but it's hard to pick favorites on this all around fine release. A must for Crimson fans and lovers of early seventies progressive rock in general.

Who's on it:
Looking through the credits, the only name I recognise apart from Gordon is John Wetton; Wetton handles the bass work in good style. It's good enough for a close listen. As usual he's adept, interesting and serviceable. You have moments that hark back to some Prog Rock feels, but generally the whole album is a good deal more laid back than any Prog Rock album. It comes across as more of a thoughtful, Blues Rock/Folk Rock kind of work with small bursts of Prog stylings.
David Kaffinetti of Rare Bird handled keyboards. Apparently, he went on to become 'David Kaff' who played Viv Savage, the Keyboard player for Spinal Tap... So to speak.
If you thought that was obscure, a Bill Atkinson was on drums - I can't find ANYTHING on him.
An Alan Barry provided the Lead guitar; another person who I can't find any info on.

What's Good About it:
Surprisingly, the songs are good. They are not polished, but then that would be the point of an album that is filled with ambivalence. As we can tell from the album title and song titles, Haskell's album is a catalogue of ambivalent scenes, emotions, observations and a whimsical non-participation in the Rock-posturing common in 1971. He's opting out here. Haskell sings, but also plays acoustic guitar; he's a much better player than I remember him to be. There are plenty of nicely rendered acoustic passages; some sound a bit like Pete Townshend's acoustic guitar work on Rough Mix. Even the voice reminds me of Townshend's 'Street in the City'. However that's only in parts.

The overall vibe is mellow, relaxed and mature. This is a very mature kind of sonic experience; something I had not really given thought to as a teenager hanging out for a bit of excitement. You don't expect testosterone charged youths to stop and consider the ambivalent feelings in life. Yet, it's an album that asks you to relax and take it in gently. Not, grab you by the throat and throw you around the room like, say, 'Red' by King Crimson. And that is perhaps why Gordon was asked to leave; he wasn't really intense like the other guys in 'Crimso'.

What's Wrong With It:
Haskell's vocals aren't very strong; he doesn't give his melody the best they could get. The mix is bad; it's a murky, un-inspired mix. The arrangement is often unimaginative or inappropriate. The best bits are sometimes just Gordon singing simply with his guitar strumming. Unfortunately the producer felt things had to be shoved in it to make it more 'exciting'; and yet it never gets exciting. Alan Barry's lead breaks are pedestrian. If there's anything to single out as a dislike on this album, it's the unimaginative blues-rock guitar figurations of this one Alan Barry. It's like third rate Eric Clapton on valium. Clearly the album deserved a more inventive approach, but it is Barry's playing that drags it back to the ordinary. It could've been good; he ruined it!

What got me as a teen, years ago was how there wasn't any intensity. The whole album is just so laid back. As an adult I can appreciate that it's meant to be an entirely different offering to Prog Rock, but the answer wasn't to denude Prog Rock of all intensity. It is as naff as I remember it; but oddly enough I don't mind the naff-ness of it. If I want intensity, I can go put on 'Larks' Tongues In Aspic'. This is a deliberately different venture and I should give it the credit it deserves.
It might be a really good album to chill out to at the end of a long night's conversation about way-out things. Or on a Sunday afternoon, something to listen to instead of watching the Arts shows on TV give you the politically correct review of films.

The mellowness of this album is soothing, and that's got to be good. - It's also got Viv Savage on it!

It's been years since I first heard this album, and I'm glad to see it on your lists. My understanding is that Haskell wrote all the tracks on this album for his kids -- as songs for bedtime.

While there are no duds, I'd have to say Benny is my fave.

If you like quieter albums, with childlike, innocent themes, you can't go past this classic! Thanks Amazon for stocking it!

Nostalgia is a tricky thing. I recall buying a promotional copy of this record on vinyl for fifty cents at a synagogue bazaar (someone must have had connections to Atlantic Records, the label the vinyl was originally released on.)

I recalled Mr. Haskell (no relation to Eddie) as a member of King Crimson for a couple of albums, and specifically as the lead singer of "Cadence and Cascade" from "In The Wake Of The Poseidon," a second album which was quickly forgotten in the wake of the first record.

It's been years since I've sold my vinyl and Mr. Haskell's record was in my purging of snap, crackle, and pop. I DO remember the song "Could Be" rummaging around my head for decades, though. Listening to the sound samples, there are other nice tracks but that's as far as it goes. I remembered something "epic," but "epic" this is not. It's no prog-rock classic, no mellotrons, no masterful lead guitar. It's just a nice, quiet, self-deprecating little folkish offering, more in the mode of Nick Drake than Robert Fripp. For some reason it also reminds of me of Fleetwood Mac's "Bare Trees," but that may have as much to do with synchronicity as actual sonic similiarity. I also liked Rare Bird from that era-thank God someone finally introduced me to John Coltrane. This one gets three stars because of the nostalgia value of "Could Be."

I am very much a Gordon Haskell fan. I don't think he is capable of making a bad album. I thoroughly enjoy his voice and every song he has written appeals to me. He is a fine artist and deserves more recognition. Listen to him and agree.

Quiet, unassuming melodies that grow on you after a few listenings. Nothing close to the intensity of Haskell's brief Crimson stint. Overall a very acoustic set. I've seen reviews that try to pidgeonhole his vocal stylings, but I've always liked his voice simply because it IS difficult to define, with a unique timbre unlike any other vocalist I've heard since.

Nothing really noteworthy on the CD, but several unassuming simple tunes that you may find yourself humming after a few listenings; a lovely little record with childlike innocence written all over it. But a warning to prog fans--this disc is NOT prog...it spins more like folk music to me.