Most Helpful Customer Reviews
11 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Decent, but Light on Military Detail, October 22, 2009
This review is from: Israel's Lightning Strike - The Raid on Entebbe 1976 (Paperback)
The second volume on Osprey's new Raid series, Israel's Lightning Strike by Simon Dunstan, covers the famous raid on Entebbe airport in 1976. This is a thrilling subject - one of the most famous commando-type missions since the Second World War - but this volume seems to plod through the various political machinations prior to the raid and then zip through the actual combat action. While this series is still gelling, this one seems not to cover its subject as well as it could have and left me with too many questions about the actual operation. Indeed, it seems less a military history than a crisis account. Nevertheless, readers interested in modern special forces and military operations would benefit from going through the lessons learned in these pages.
The author begins with a 4-page introduction that outlines the history of aerial hijacking and the rise of Black September, followed by a nice sidebar on the various Palestinian militant groups. The author then moves into a rather long-winded, 15-page discussion of the hijacking of Air France Flight 139 by the PLFP-SOG and their diversion to Entebbe airport in Uganda, where Idi Amin gave them support. This section has useful items, such as Israeli efforts to gather intelligence on Entebbe, but it eventually bogs down into a day-by-day, blow-by-blow account of the Israeli deliberations about what to do about their hostages. There are also sidebars on Yonatan Netanyahu and Ehud Barak. This section is followed by a 9-page section on Israeli plans for the raid, which is frankly pretty thin on military details. The author seems to assume that all readers are intimately familiar with the Israeli special operations community, so he makes no effort to discuss the organization or tactics of Sayeret Matkal (this is where a sidebar would have been great). Unlike other volumes in the Raid series, he does not provide any kind of organization chart or breakdown of the raiding force and consequently, various individuals just "appear" at various points in the narrative. I was particularly confused by the vague discussion of the refueling operation required to get the raiding force out of Entebbe - how did that occur?
The raid itself is covered in a 23-page section, which includes four maps (two of them 3-D style) and a battle scene, which reduces the text to about 15 pages. Since there is no discussion of the Ugandan forces at Entebbe, it is difficult to see what the raiding force was up against. It is also odd to see that the Israelis went to all this effort to insert an elite raiding force to rescue the hostages but then sacrificed surprise because they failed to quietly take out the first two Ugandan guards they encountered. The author never questions the Israeli tactics, but they don't seem particularly brilliant in the end-game. The Israeli failure to wear body armor in the assault force is never addressed, but this probably would have reduced their casualties considerably. Indeed, a sober analysis would likely reveal that the Israeli tactics were rather crude and brute force, rather than smart. They worked, but against a dumb and rather sleepy opponent, albeit at the cost of 1 killed and 5 wounded in the raiding force. Nor does the author attempt to incorporate anything from Palestinian or Ugandan sources - this account is entirely from the Israeli perspective. Overall, this volume does not have a high level of military detail and does not attempt any real analysis of the raid.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Isreal's Lighting Strike - The Raid on Entebbe 1976, March 7, 2010
This review is from: Israel's Lightning Strike - The Raid on Entebbe 1976 (Paperback)
An excellent understanding of the prep and excecution of one of the Best Raids for rescue in the history of Special Ops. Especially true due to the history of the Isreali Defense Forces dificulty in intergrating the known factions that still existed.
Readable for anyone interested in an Op where Murphy had limited access.
Michael L. Snowden
U.S. Army Retired
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1846033977/ref=cm_cr_rev_prod_title
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Raid on Entebbe, April 28, 2010
This review is from: Israel's Lightning Strike - The Raid on Entebbe 1976 (Paperback)
Author Simon Dunstan does an excellent job in his book Israel's Lightning Strike. In his introduction, he traces the history of hijacking planes, something that was all too common in the 1970's. The Israel's have a tough "we don't negotiate with terrorists" policy and that theme runs heavily in what happened in July 1976.
Members of the Palestinian Liberation Organization seized a French plane and headed off to Libya first, then Uganda which at the time was under the rule of Idi "Dadda" Amin. Now the Israeli government had to decide what to do. That was no easy task, Uganda was 2,000 miles from Israel. Just getting there was going to be difficult, let alone surprise the hijackkers and free the hostages. The airport was in the middle of a jungle and these were times before GPS.
Dunstan takes us through the decisions, plans made, discarded, the political pressure on those who had to make the tough choices. In doing so, he quotes those who were there, giving the book a human touch and a better glimpse of the struggles everyone faced.
There are ample photos of the people involved, maps, and of particular value, 3-D renderings to show what was taking place during the raid. That the Isrealis were able to rescue the hostages with minimal casualties speaks very highly of the skill of those involved. I thought the book was very informative, technical enough to appreciate the logistical and military difficulties in pulling off this raid, yet acknowledging the human element. I recommend this book for anyone interested in Special Forces, Hijacking, raids, Commandos, military buffs.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|