Most Helpful Customer Reviews
27 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Very Interesting story of an ongoing spiritual search, January 18, 2002
This review is from: It's Here Now (Are You?) (Paperback)
I was very interested in reading this book especially after reading "Be Here Now" by Ram Dass. I had wondered after reading that book what became of Bhagavan Das. First I will say that Bhagavan Das deserves credit for his honest account of his journey. He certainly paints a picture of himself that I personally did not find too admirable and I give him credit for his honesty. This book has tremendous energy and is very hard to put down. The different experiences he has are described vividly and with focus and emotion. You feel like you are living each sentence with him as he goes through his ever changing situations. Bhagavan Das is constantly caught in a battle between the spirit and the flesh. He's almost analogous to a manic depressive who experiences extreme highs and lows, except in his case he goes between extreme devotion and extreme narcissism. I did get very disturbed by his self indulgent behavior, not just in his narcissistic drug, sex and spiritual phases but in the way he abandoned his wives and children so that he could indulge in his spiritual quest. This seemed to be a major cop-out to me. He seemed to run away from his responsibilities in the name of spirituality. Also from a spiritual standpoint he seemed too obsessed with finding spiritual experiences of "bliss" which seemed also a form of escapism. True spirituality (in my opinion and experience)has very little to do with "states" of bliss but rather are found with finding the beauty in life itself in the present moment. All the "spiritual fireworks" he speaks of seem to be no more than a lot of spiritual masturbation. One thing in particular I found particularly disturbing is that after his first wife Bhavani dies from an overdose he doesn't let the reader know what happens to his daughter Soma. He says that his new wife doesn't want to take her in but he doesn't seem to say anything about what he does to take care of her. Not that I need to know his personal business, but he tells you all this stuff and then never explains what happens to this poor child. Rather, he goes off on some Peyote trip and gets into his own selfish headtrip. Anyway, in spite of my personal disgust about much of his behavior, I do think this book is very worthwhile to read. I think he lays it all out there for the reader to make his own decisions about things. While I certainly wouldn't take any spiritual advice from Bhagavan Das because he still seems to be anywhere but "here now", I truly wish him well.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
49 of 53 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Bhagged Down, October 25, 2006
This review is from: It's Here Now (Are You?) (Paperback)
This book should be called "I'm Escaping The Present Moment And All Responsibility For My Actions Now, Are You?"
This book is hard to review without judging the man who wrote it. In terms of literary merit, it is not well written. It reads more like an outline of a vast array of psychedelic events that never goes into any one event very deeply. That being said, it is a fascinating tale of an extraordinarily conflicted man who constantly contradicts himself and loves to swing between extremes. A great, if tragic character.
The value in this book is not found in any wisdom Bhag. Das may (or may not) have gleaned, but in the colorful picture it paints of the spiritual scene in late 60s India and early 70s America. The book is an intriguing portrait of what it was like to be right in the middle of it. The real gurus, the fake gurus, the zealous devotees, the drugs, the sex, the confusion. In India he studied with several famous teachers and when he gets back to America, Allen Ginsberg, Alan Watts (who was apparently a notorious drunk!) and Ram Dass, among others are constantly floating in and out of his life. It is also an interesting to see how he dealt with his unwanted fame.
Bhagavan Das says that in America he was living like a "spiritual rock star." Spiritual hypocrite is more like it. The book is rampant with examples of how he uses his spiritual quest as a way to escape from his own present reality. For example, in a chapter in which he claims to have been learning about devotion from his Native American "grandfather", he also describes how he had a stream of girls going in and out of his teepee while his wife and child were "in the background" in Santa Fe. He describes how he prays for hours, upon days, upon years to the great mother, the goddess Kali Ma, and yet he was utterly unable to remain faithful to his own wife. He even gets another woman pregnant while he was still married. While he was surrendering his soul to the Great Mother in the sky, he was womanizing and boozing his way through the females here on earth. Actually, he even blames Kali Ma for destroying his relationships with women out of jealousy. It isn't the fact that he was incapable of taking responsibility for her personal relationship - Kali Ma just becomes one more woman who screwed things up for him. While he was busy seeing everyone as god, he forgot that they were human beings who were affected by his actions. Even after the years of austerities and meditation he practiced, he was still unable to conquer his enormous ego.
Bhagavan Das uses his spiritual quest the way he uses drugs - as a way to get high and to escape. It is ironic that he was the hero of Ram Dass' "Be Here Now" because he is always looking for the next guru, the next vision, the next party, the next woman, the next high, the next narcotic. I never knew that bliss could be so depressing.
I have seen Bhaghavan Das perform live and I love the "Now" CD. His singing has brought me a lot of joy. Listen to the music, not the man. That's my advice.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
28 of 30 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A facinating life, but some pretty flaky ideas, May 27, 1998
By A Customer
Bhagavan Das has led a fascinating life: going to India as a very young man & becoming a full-fledged Yogi, returning to America as an icon of the spiritual counter-culture & encountering others icons such as Ram Dass & Allen Ginsburg, & ceaseless bouncing between Hinduism, Buddhism, Native American peyote ritual, hedonism, capitalism, AA, born-again Christianity, & probably a few other isms I've forgotten. His tale is worth reading for those of us interested in spiritual seeking & how it relates to India, psychedelic drugs, & "the 60s." Seeing how the author continues this seeking with great energy through difficult circumstances can be inspiring to our own efforts. It's also interesting to see how the author, who was presented as a Great Holy Man in Ram Dass' "Be Here Now," was in fact a confused kid bumbling his way along like the rest of us. The downside of the book is that the author, in spite of the numerous zigs & zags of his life & path, in spite of the obvious suffering he's brought to others along the way (such as the woman he impregnated, married, & cheated on), still considers himself a teacher. That is, the tone of the book isn't just that of a fellow seeker sharing his experience, but of someone with Great Insight to impart to the rest of us. These Insights, sprinkled throughout his tale, come off as flaky. Bhagavan Das often doesn't clearly distinguish what's happening objectively from what's going on in his mind. Whereas Ram Dass was able to write about Indian spirituality without abandoning "Western" rationality, Bhagavan Das *doesn't* have a background in rationality, & comes off as a spaced-out hippie. He makes profound-sounding proclamations that seem too naive by 30 years. For instance, he visits a certain temple & suggests that everyone who goes there gets their prayers answered by God. Were such magic really available, I imagine India would be in much better shape than it is. Many of us begin our spiritual search feeling like we'll find Truths to make us holier & more special than ordinary people. After years of efforts, we hopefully gain the humility to see that, while our chosen path may be wonderfully helpful to us, it doesn't make us holier than others, or give us the standing to preach to anyone else. I was fascinated by Bhagavan Das' tales, & disappointed that he still doesn't seem to have found this humility.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|