Customer Reviews

It's Not Funny If I Have to Explain It: A Dilbert Treasury

5 star:		(10)
4 star:		(2)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(1)

 

 

I am extremely choosy about compilations of comics, but have to go on record as highly recommending this volume. "Dilbert," while normally enjoyable, has some true standout strips, and this is a collection of Scott Adams' personal favorites with handwritten notes by Adams about each one selected. There is no question that Adams hits the nail on the head regarding personnel in modern American companies, and touches on everything from the ridiculous and grotesque management compensation packages (My favorite of that ilk concludes with underpaid Intern Asok complaining "I make my own underpants from sandwich bags."), management by cliches, pointless corporate reorganization and departmental name changes (I am particularly familiar with this one.), outsourcing (I love the Elbonians.) and Adams' (and my) personal pet peeve, "Management by Analogy" which has management saying something absolutely stultifying to employees while not ever recognizing their own gaffe.

I highly endorse this book. If you work for a big company, you will definitely see your organization here in some form or fashion. I just wish the real workplace was as much fun as this book.

This is the second time Scott Adams has published an annotated guide to some of his better strips; the first was "Seven Years Of Highly Defective People." This time, the book is just a straight-through compilation of his favorites over a seven-year period, with his handwritten notes below each one. He comments on everything from what he thinks was funny in a particular strip to reactions he got from them (some confused people, for instance). I always think it's fun to hear the cartoonist talk about his work. But I'm a comic strip geek.

Granted, there's no new material here, but this really is a "best of" collection. What really makes it work, though, are the "Jay Leno-ish" comments that Adams inserts after each strip "explaining" the humor in it, or what his inspiration was, or making some other strangely innane comment about it.

Seriously. What makes a book titled "It's Not Funny If I Have To Explain It" funny is the explanations.

See, it's the irony. Irony is funny.

I received my Dilbert Treasury and it is even better than I imagined. Not only is it full of some of Scott Adams' best Dilbert cartoons, it also has his own personal comments after each one! Some of his comments are even funnier than the cartoon above it! :-)

I keep mine on my coffee table and people just love to browse through it. It was on sale and I feel an excellent value for the price!

Love it!!!

This book had me LAUGHING OUT LOUD on the airplane - I am sure everyone was jealous that i was having such a great time with JUST me & my book -- it is VERY funny. Only read this book in public if you won't mind people looking at you because you are laughing so hard!

I bought this book anticipating nothing more than a rehash of "Seven Years of Highly Defective People". Instead, however, Adams starts right where "Seven Years" left off, in terms of the comic timeline. The book is very much like "Seven Years" in that Adams provides funny handwritten comments under almost every comic, but unlike "Seven Years", the book is organized chronologically, and not by character. That said, the book is very funny and very enjoyable to those people (like me) who like a bit of a "behind-the-scenes tour" now and then.

This is the best Dilbert Collection I've ever read. Usually, (While Adams does make a lot of gems) you have to comb through his books to find something that just makes you laugh hysterically. With this book, your search can end, and you can lean back and enjoy Dilbert at it's finest, with little, strange, but somehow normal seeming comments by Scott Adams himself underneath each comic. This is truly a masterpiece, and I suggest it to any funny comic fan (including Dilbert), because it will leave you pasting many of these comics on your cubicle and laughing on end.

This book is amazing. I would probably say that of most of Dilbert books, but what I truly appreciate about this strip treasury is the careful selection made by the Author and also the handwritten commments below every stip. Thanks to these add-on you can get much more of the behind the scenes on how the humour of the characters is conceived and on how to draw and compose comics. For me this is an interesting added value while maybe someone just prefer to enjoy the comic stand-alone. I would reccomend buying it mainly if you are already a Dilbert fan although it can be a very insightful introduction to newcomers of Dilbert's world

I enjoyed Scott Adams comments on this collection of less obvious, and often less funny, strips, but by mid-way the comments become repetitious and only rarely improve the strips.
I rate the quality of Dilbert compilations by the number I want to copy and post and this volume produced few of these.
Jack Layman

For some serious office humor, that actually occurs within your very own workplace, this is a gift to give to any work colleague who can use a laugh or two because it's not funny if you have to explain it.