Customer Reviews

JSA Presents: Stars and S.T.R.I.P.E.

5 star:		(1)
4 star:		(1)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(1)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

The comics collected herein are among the best examples of how the legacies of comics' Golden Age can be built upon with respect, and still be great reading. Johns and Moder skillfully develop new relationships with some of the most revered characters of the past from Robotman to the Metal Men's Dr. Will Magnus to the whole huge Starman backstory to the JSA. Very adroitly, Star Spangled Kid quickly became a vital and prominent part of the DC Universe. Of course, none of that came at the expense of strong characterization, intricate and interesting plots, and great storytelling. This is a fine collection; certainly a must have for those of us with huge love and respect for the Golden Age, but also anyone who just loves great comics. Highly recommended.

JSA PRESENTS: STARS AND S.T.R.I.P.E. collects issues # 1- 8 of the 1999 series featuring the first regular DC work from Geoff Johns. Johns is now recognized as a major architect of the modern DC Universe, and as his work is so closely associated with the JSA, this series was begging for a collected edition. Regular readers of JSA have probably picked up on the origin of the second Star-Spangled Kid, Courtney Whitmore. Well, Stars and STRIPE is where it all happened, and like so much of Johns' other JSA work, it has strong ties to DC's Golden Age.

Courtney's mother has just remarried, and her husband is none other than Pat Dugan, aka Stripesy (the sidekick of the Golden Age S-SK, Sylvester Pemberton). Courtney is not happy about either the marriage or their recent relocation to Blue Valley, Nebraska, and while digging through some of Pat's boxes, Courtney comes across the original Kid's cosmic converter belt and costume. Without her mother's knowledge, and against Pat's protestations, Courtney begins to adventure out on her own. Pat realizes he must put his formidable mechanical engineering skills to use in order to watch over her and ensure she makes it home for dinner in one piece. Encased in a suit of high-tech armor, Pat once again plays sidekick to the Star-Spangled Kid, but this time as S.T.R.I.P.E.

Overall, I enjoyed this story. It's a great prelude to the magic that Johns would work in later years, paying homage to DC's rich history and bringing back classic characters in various forms. There are nice references to the Seven Soldiers of Victory, the original Robotman, Ultra the Multi-Alien, and even some ominous appearances by Solomon Grundy and the Nebula Man! Unfortunately, there's just not a lot of meat here. The writing has some painfully rough edges, and the ongoing plotlines involving Shiv, kidnappings at Courtney's school, and her quirky principal, got old quickly. Also, it's difficult to sympathize with Courtney when Johns writes her as a one-sided smartmouth whose only objective is to annoy her parents. It seems to me that the easiest solution to Pat's dilemma would be to just take the belt from her. As for the art by Lee Moder... too cartoony for my tastes, but it gets the job done.

Anyway, I am looking forward to volume 2. Hopefully it will address some of the issues Johns brings up in the first volume and tie the series more firmly to the JSA title.

Geoff Johns' first comics work is somewhat what one might expect. Tones and voices that are now familiar but a little rough around the edges. Having read Courtney's adventures in JSA before, I already knew the character but seeing her origin was fun. The plotlines were pretty campy but decent. The art by Lee Moder was bubby and alright but got too cartoony at times. Overall its what it is, an origin book for Courtney and Geoff.

When I picked up this title I thought: "Wow! Teenager discovers that her step father is a retired super hero! And now they're going to team up to fight crime? What a cool concept!" I was so sadly mistaken. This idea had such great potential for character development and the chance to watch an unusual partnership flourish. Unfortunately, the characters are rather flat, dated and the interaction can best be described as an ADD Mind Trip. Not only that, but there is so much back story left unexplained, and plot holes that are left unfilled that even as a long-time Comic fan, I couldn't ignore...or even understand.

Most importantly, you never end up liking the characters. The Star Spangled Kid, while true to most angst-driven teenagers, is a brat (and that's putting it mildly). Her stepfather, Pat Dugan, despite such a fascinating background...never grows on you.

I know I sound kind of brutal in this, and I hate to criticize what I'm sure was a lot of hard work and effort, but if you're like me and expect this to be a character-driven piece...think again. Maybe Volume 2 will make a lot of this clear and will progress the characters more.

I think this book is okay, once you accept the weird idea that a guy in a robot suit follows his daughter around. I would like it better if Stargirl would do her super-hero business alone. Stargirl goes to high school, so I immediately figured it's a female version of Peter Parker, and soon I realize high school setting and all is probably made for younger audience of readers. Exemplified by the cartoonish artwork. I like females who know how to kick butt, but Stargirl doesn't yet rank with Supergirl or Black Canary.