16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Richie's Picks: JAKE REINVENTED, September 8, 2003
I believe that on the first night I went to Gatsby's house I was one of the few guests who had actually been invited. People were not invited--they went there. They got into automobiles which bore them out to Long Island, and somehow they ended up at Gatsby's door. Once there they were introduced by somebody who knew Gatsby, and after that they conducted themselves according to the rules of behavior associated with amusement parks. Sometimes they came and went without having met Gatsby at all, came for the party with a simplicity of heart that was its own ticket of admission."
--F. Scott Fitzgerald, 1925
"Everybody was there--most of the football team, their girlfriends, the cheerleaders, and a bunch of their boyfriends and friends, the cooler people from student council, and a collection of athletes from basketball and track. I noticed some sophomore girls whose names I didn't know--they'd really filled out over the summer; and a few guys who played in their own rock band. It was the guest list that really made this bash what it was. If I could put together the party of my dreams--not that my parents ever left me alone in the house for more than five minutes--this was exactly the kind of crowd I'd want. I marveled at how a newcomer like Jake Garrett could waltz into town and instantly know all the right people to invite.
"I turned to Todd. 'Do you see him?'
"Todd shook his head. 'Must be upstairs.'
" 'Don't his parents notice there are fifty kids going nuts in their house?' I asked.
"Jake's dad's out of town five days a week,' Todd explained. 'His mother lives in Texas somewhere. He picked up a slice of pizza from the table that was loaded with the stuff, folded it expertly, and took a bite."
--Gordon Korman, 2003
In the same way that Will Shakespeare's immortal work has long benefited from West Side Story, Francis Scott Fitzgerald's masterpiece, THE GREAT GATSBY, will undoubtedly profit from the publication of JAKE, REINVENTED, an extremely well-crafted contemporary retelling by Gordon Korman. Korman, a master of smart-mouthed characters whose own twist on the Bard's star-crossed lovers--last year's SON OF THE MOB--was one of 2002's funniest YA books, has taken a slightly more serious turn with his latest story.
"Jake gave a nervous laugh, 'I guess you've figured out my little side job.' "
Frankly, it takes a little imagination to visualize swarms of teens of my grandfather's generation (no less this generation) taking GATSBY to heart as a cautionary tale. But transformed into a contemporary YA, it is quite easy to see how Rick's (think Nick's) narration of this story of obsession, acceptance, and popularity will have many teens thinking hard about the consequences of these characters' actions. It is said that teenagers reinvent themselves on a daily basis. This believable tale of metamorphosis will surely serve them well.
"I began to push my way through the clammy bodies.
"Marty Rapaport grabbed me and held back my progress. 'Hey, cross-bite, what's going on? What is this, the O.K. Corral?'
"I heard Jake's greeting to Todd. 'Glad you could make it, baby. What's up?'
"For a second there, I toyed with the possibility that he could brazen it through, that his sheer faith in who he'd become might do the job for him. This wasn't the old Jacob Garrett. This was Jake, reinvented. But as soon as Todd started talking, I knew the battle was lost."
In Korman's version, you still have the Gatsby figure creating everything for that girl from his past. You have the corresponding infidelities at the center of things. And while the ultimate outcome is toned down from car crashes and gunshots to cracked skulls and exiles, it feels no less tragic. Think about West Side Story. If anything, Maria's being left alive and alone at the end of the story, with her rage at the prejudice that caused Tony's death, is MORE powerful than Juliette's self-absorbed suicide.
"They began to close the distance between them, moving in that trancelike state that is so dramatic and all phony. It would have been a real romantic moment except for the three guys standing on their heads against the wall trying to chug upside down while a cheering section bellowed encouragement. I think they were betting on the outcome."
Hey, this is Gordon Korman after all. I didn't claim there was NO humor in the book!
Just as viewers of West Side Story or readers of SON OF THE MOB lose little of the entertainment value by not being familiar with the inspiration for those stories, readers of JAKE may lose many interesting contrasts, but don't lose the relevance of the story by never having heard of GATSBY. (Having myself read GATSBY during my first semester comp class, I can just hear some college freshman in a few years, complaining that GATSBY is a rip-off of that Korman story about the kid who made all that money in order to win the beautiful girl.) Sophisticated readers will move from JAKE to the original and benefit from getting the whole enchilada. (Less ambitious readers will at least rent the video, like I did last night, and still get a taste.)
" 'You were right the first time,' I told her. 'It's all about you.'
"I walked out, slamming the bathroom door behind me."
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Entertaining, easy read, but some gaps in logic, January 15, 2006
From the first page, Korman sucked me into his novel. Mimicing "The Great Gatsby" in a much more simplistic style, "Jake, Reinvented" follows high school students who attend parties every Friday night at Jake's house. He's the new, mysterious kid in school who instantly wins over the "in" crowd by joining the football team and throwing parties where the beer flows, the pizza is free, and the beautiful people go to mingle. Jake, of course, has reinvented himself to win over the beautiful, self-absorbed, and unavailable Didi. He does win her affection -- somewhat -- but it's not enough for him, and soon his obsession has dire consequences.
The story is narrated by Jake's new friend and all-around nice guy Rick, and the novel really shines when Rick displays his wry sense of humor.
Some of the storyline lacks believability, though, which I found distracting. For example, the parties are so crowded that no one can drive up and down the street. In reality, a neighbor would have called the cops. Also, Jake's house is destroyed every weekend, and Jake cleans it up himself before his father returns. Based on the description of the wild activities at the party, restoration of the home would seem an insurmountable task without a team of professionals.
Jake's secret former life was a letdown. I was expecting something a little more shocking than a nerdy past. In reality, it would take something more than one being highly intelligent to instantly turn off an entire student body to the new kid. The real world has plenty of advanced students who are popular because, ultimately, popularity is more about personality than anything else.
Rick's motivation for supporting Jake through the end of the novel, including in court, was not well supported in the story. I would have liked Korman allowing us to get a little deeper in Rick's head to learn exactly why he was continuing to support Jake after everyone abandoned him.
What I did like was Korman's portrayal of some of the leading "in" crowd characters -- Didi and Todd in particular. High school wouldn't be complete without shallow, self-absorbed people like them. However, Korman also allowed us to see them when they were vulnerable, adding depth to what could have been otherwise wooden, stereotypical characters.
Despite a few problems with the storyline logistics, I enjoyed the book and would recommend it for young adults. I've seen other reviewers here give the book one star because it's not written as well as Gatsby, but "Jake, Reinvented" isn't trying to replace the classic just as "Clueless" wasn't trying to replace Jane Austen's "Emma." Just read "Jake, Reinvented" for pleasure, and get a little kick out of it when it mimics Gatsby.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
