23 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Welcome to "Jalna", March 5, 2005
And you thought YOUR family was hard to live with. In "Jalna," first of the Whiteoak Chronicles series, Canadian author Mazo de la Roche introduces readers to the passionate, rebellious Whiteoak family. The plot twists sometimes become too soap-operaish, but at least "Jalna" is fun.
The mansion of Jalna has an array of uncles, brothers, and a sister, all presided over by semi-senile Grandmother. And one day, sharp-tongued Piers shocks all of his relatives -- he marries pretty, delicate Pheasant, who is the illegitimate daughter of his sister Meg's ex-lover (got that?), much to the horror of his family and bratty Meg. What's more, budding poet Eden falls in love with a pretty fan from Brooklyn, Alayne, and marries her.
Neither marriage is immediately accepted, although Grandmother somewhat approves of Alayne because she thinks the girl has money. But things become more complicated when Alayne falls in love with her earthy brother-in-law Renny, and Pheasant falls in love with sensitive Eden. When Eden and Pheasant are overheard together, the family is thrown into turmoil...
Mazo de la Roche wrote many books about the Whiteoak family, but this novel lays the groundwork, with all the characters that the sequels and prequels branch out from. Taken alone, it's an entertaining dramatic read, although the semi-incestuous attractions and affairs start to get away from de la Roche as the book continues.
de la Roche had a robust writing style, with plenty of fights, sometimes violence, mild comedy and repressed sexual tension. Her dialogue does sometimes go over the top, but she gets across the stifling effects that Jalna and its inhabitants have on Alayne and Pheasant, as well as the devastating long-term effects that an illicit affair can have.
The Whiteoak family comes across as robust and passionate, whether "gentleman farmers" or artists, such as the intense, neurotic finch or the mockingly lovely Eden. The only exceptions are the women -- Meg is a whiny self-absorbed brat, and Grandmother is a bit senile. The girls who marry into the family -- Pheasant and Alayne -- are far more likable.
"Jalna" sometimes borders on a family soap opera, but Mazo de la Roche keeps the tense, dramatic plot from ever getting dull -- wouldn't it be great if a TV show were based on this?
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
15 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This should be a series on HBO, January 24, 2007
Canadian author Mazo de la Roche wrote 16 novels about Jalna, the Ontario estate of the Whiteoak family. This is the first book, but it actually starts in the middle, with three generations living. Subsequent books deal with both past and future events; this one is set in the 1920s. It is one of the best books I have ever read (first time 40 years ago). At the center is Grandmother, one hundred years old and as alert as anyone in the family. The description is beautiful (if you've seen Ontario, you'll be able to picture it all) but doesn't get in the way of the plot. With marriages, affairs, divorces and birthdays from the oldest to the youngest, there is never a dull moment. Many of these books are out of print in the U.S. You may need to get a used copy or buy one from amazon canada, which I've just done with the second book. I can't get enough of the Whiteoaks.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No