Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your email address or mobile phone number.
James Fairfax Paperback – August 1, 2009
|New from||Used from|
Top 20 lists in Books
View the top 20 best sellers of all time, the most reviewed books of all time and some of our editors' favorite picks. Learn more
More About the Author
Top Customer Reviews
When half-blind James Fairfax is added in, all the characters assume subtle differences that keep building. Even the dynamic between Emma and Mr. Knightley gains new perspective, which culminates in Emma's final insight: that her behavior is more like the Mrs. Elton she despises than she'd comfortably assumed. The new scenes add dimension to the tale, making me wonder at times if the ending would be all changed. I appreciated the way that Campan brought the close to a parallel to the original, but with profound changes to characters, especially Elton.Read more ›
In his brilliant variation of EMMA, Adam Campan removes this single obstacle and then lets the story unfold. The historical basis for this conceit is not utterly untoward. As Campan points out in his Foreword, many among the nobility of Europe had preferred their own sex, but married conventionally for the sake of the proper passage of property and rank. What if, Campan asks, same-sex marriage ("marriage a la mode") were permitted by royal decree? What else would change? More significantly, what would remain the same?
Unlike many Austen pastiches, which lay into the original stories with a heavy and insensitive hand, Campan's touch is deft and sure. Much of the original text is preserved (hence Austen's name quite rightly appears in the byline), but subtle details that at first appear to make little different. But as Campan allows those tiny changes to build on one another, a startling revelation emerges, one which is both faithful to Austen's premise and relevant to today's social mores: even in a world in which sexual preference is no hindrance, nothing has changed. In marriage as in all else, people still betray--or follow--their own hearts.
Austen would have been proud.
The "central" love triangle of the novel works well. Adam Campan has reimagined Jane Fairfax as a man (James Fairfax) and the triangle of misunderstandings and error between Emma, Frank Churchill and James Fairfax works as beautifully as it does in Austen's original novel. There is a strong feeling of truth to the premise that Frank Churchill is only using Emma as a smokescreen, but he never falls for her because he is really in love with James Fairfax.
However, this is (in my opinion) the only part of the novel which works well. Unfortunately, turning Jane Fairfax into a man distorts most of the other relationships in the novel and is in general a distinct drawback. For example, when Mr Knightley rebukes Emma for not paying more attention to James Fairfax and how he would have been a companion more suitable than Harriet Smith - it reads rather strangely. Similarly all the parts about poor James having to go out and earn a living as a teacher don't work nearly as well for a man. I didn't feel sorry for him, as I might have for Jane Fairfax - I just felt that he should pull up his socks and stop hanging around with his aunt and get on with it. The plot device of having him very short-sighted doesn't really overcome this problem, again, in my opinion.
The other relationship which doesn't work at all well in this setting is the premise of Mrs Elton as "Lady Patroness".Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
I think it is a bit disrespectful to put something like this with Jane Austen's name on it. Shouldn't it be put as co-author or something? I think it's a little misleading.Published on August 16, 2009 by Anonymous