James Shelby Downard is the most outrageous of all conspiracy theorists. He initially achieved cult notoriety for his wacky theory that the JFK assassination was a ritual sacrifice carried out by Free Masons as part of a complex magical spell meant to set society on a path toward chaos and moral decay. His writings are crude, but highly entertaining in their extravagance. His method of deduction amounts to a game of word association gone haywire, and his autobiographical writings read like a tripped out, ultra-paranoid version of The Young Indiana Jones Chronicles - "we see the recurring theme of good triumphing over evil, with our hero in the role of a 'Pharmakos' (Masonic sacrificial victim) who wasn't going to take it sitting down; a bad ass dude with a lifelong battle against The Brotherhood." One of my favorite escapades involves the time a pre-pubescent Downard took a trip to Jekyll Island (birthplace of the Federal Reserve), where he witnessed none other than "Alexander Graham Bell (or one of Bell's 'doubles') engaged in homo-erotic sex magic fellatio in which 'vital energy and/or occult power described as a type of magnetism is transferred.'" Yeah. The guy is THAT bonkers. And it makes for a pretty good read.
Gorightly doesn't do him justice though. There's a million directions this book could have gone in. It could have been a simple, well organized overview of Downard's writings and ideas, either straight-faced or comical. It could have explored further the possibility that Downard is just an elaborate hoax perpetrated by Adam Parfey and Michael Hoffman. It could have placed Downard in his socio-historical context, examining the pervasive fears of deviant sexuality, loosening social mores, and racial miscegenation that run throughout his various fantastic claims. At the very least, we could have gotten a curated selection of the highlights from Downard's writings. Instead, Gorightly quickly moves beyond Downard altogether, and the majority of the short book is filled with pretty standard, run of the mill conspiracy stuff about MK-ULTRA, the Son of Sam, the Jonestown massacre, blah blah blah, with no connection to JSD whatsoever. It doesn't help that Gorightly is a dry, boring writer who for the most part seems to lack the sense of humor his subject requires of him. You're better off going straight to the source.