Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Slightly below "Jane's" usually excellent standard, December 8, 2001
By A Customer
Barron's series featuring Jane Austen as sleuth is one of the most delectable of the famous-person-as-detective genre. Barron's Jane is penetrating, quick, and energetically determined to see justice prevail - and she always does just in time to avert even greater evils. Our new Jane also has the internal qualities we would expect: introspection, sensitivity, dry humor, and concern about finances and her disappearing bloom. And, being a romantic, Jane has quite a lively interest in men, and they in her. All these elements are present in "The Prisoner of Wool House" but this most recent of Jane's adventures just isn't a gripper. The premise - the court-martial of brother Frank's naval friend and a mysterious French prisoner of war - is fascinating, but the military, shipping, and naval details become tedious, and the necessarily coastal venue was not inviting, possibly because Barron's descriptions are spare and sparse, and possibly because Jane herself wasn't terribly excited about living there. Many of the characters fail to come truly to life, although the surgeon Mr. Hill, and the accused officer's depressed wife Louise, were interestingly drawn. I had hoped for sight of the Gentleman Rogue, but he must have been off on an adventure of his own. The ever-scrupulous Cassandra was away too, though Mrs. Austen decidedly was not, and was as wonderfully obnoxious as ever. Brother Frank, like all of Jane's brothers, was somewhat self-absorbed but nonetheless quite likeable. All in all, the "Prisoner" was an enjoyable read but doesn't quite make it to the top shelf. Jane's earlier adventures, particularly "The Man of Cloth", are all up there, however, and are as much fun as even the historical Jane could have wished for.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Better and Better She Gets..., May 25, 2004
By A Customer
This review is from: Jane and the Prisoner of Wool House (Jane Austen Mystery) (Mass Market Paperback)
... but less and less like Jane Austen. So? Who cares? Well, the Austen purists do, but they probably quit reading the series long ago. Yep, Jane is behaving downright unnaturally for a true Regency spinster--isn't it fun? The endless reflection and ratiocination of the earlier books is replaced with more action in the recent books, and I for one consider the change an improvement. This is my favorite book so far; when I read Netley, that will undoubtedly become my new favorite. Read Jane Austen if you want to read Jane Austen; read this series if you enjoy good mysteries with interesting characters and well-researched local/historical color.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Another engrossing entry in a wonderful mystery series, January 20, 2002
Stephanie Barron's Jane Austen mystery series has maintained its freshness and appeal through this, the sixth in the series. These books are supposedly Austen's "discovered diaries" edited by Barron, whose explanatory footnotes help the reader better understand the time period and locale. This episode finds Jane in Southampton in 1807. Her brother Frank, a post captain in the Royal Navy, is convinced that his good friend Tom Seagrave, a captain who stands accused of violating the Articles of War (the punishment for which is death), is innocent. Jane becomes convinced as well, and together, they set out to prove it. Their conviction takes them from Southampton's finest homes to its darkest slums, from the sickroom of French prisoners of war to the discovery of espionage and finally, a revelation of ultimate betrayal. Barron shows herself to be a master of plot here, as a tangled (but never convoluted) web of intrigue and revenge is slowly revealed. The many characters and motivations are complex and fully drawn, and Jane's enthusiasm for the Navy gives us a glimpse into a time when military service could mean the making of a fortune. I'm not an Austen scholar, but I am an Austen fan, and I enjoy the entire series for the way it evokes Austen's sly sense of humor in reporting the events and people that surround her. The only thing that kept me from giving 5 stars is that I was able to solve the mystery myself.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|