Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A delightful concoction --, February 17, 2001
In the great houses of England, many of which were somewhat isolated and therefore at least somewhat self-contained, the Stillroom maid was a sort of combination lay-apothecary and general medical practitioner. According to the medical rules of the time, that is. Her strength was in the knowledge and use of herbs and other assorted items that could be blended together to cure--or at least treat--nearly every ailment known to man. If the medicaments as put forth at the beginning of each chapter of this book are as factual as stated by the author, I confess to surprise that not more of the Stillroom maids were cruelly murdered. Many of them were accused--rightly or wrongly--of witchcraft. Of course, Tess Arnold was a bit more than just Stillroom maid to the household in which she was employed. Just how much more, became the problem facing Jane Austen in this, her fifth crime to solve. Jane, after all, had come across the mutilated body of the young person, dressed in gentleman's evening clothes, and with a bullet hole in the middle of his forehead. Imagine the surprise of everyone--including Jane--when the local coroner identified the corpse as not a young man, but--the Stillroom maid from Penfolds Hall. Jane, her sister Cassandra and their mother, in the company of Edwin Cooper, the nephew of Mrs. Austen, and a vicar (who was clearly the model for Mr. Collins) visit Derbyshire in company with George Hemming, a gentleman friend of Edwin. The two gentlemen and Jane had gone trout fishing in the dales, providing the opportunity for Jane to have a little commune with nature, but resulting instead in the horrid discovery of the body. Jane's 'Gentleman Rogue' Lord Harold has been invited to nearby Chatsworth (and model for Pemberly) the home of the Duke of Devonshire, some few months after the death of the first Duchess, Georgiana. The family has been devastated by the death of their leader, and are now trying to find their way again, when the surrounding area becomes inflamed by the death of Tess. Of course, it is the powerful Whigs who come under the most suspicion, as many of them are also members of the FreeMasons, an organization looked upon with much skepticism by the townsfolk. There are twists aplenty before Jane puts all the pieces together and provides a solution, but not until after another death. It was The Stillroom Book, as kept by Tess Arnold that finally provided the necessary information for the Justice to secure his prisoner. In the end, however, Jane and Lord Harold must once again say good-bye, and we are left to hope they will meet again, thus providing us with further adventures.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Another excellent and satisfying adventure with Jane, August 2, 2000
I eagerly anticipated this latest volume from Stephanie Barron and I was not disappointed. Barron has created a very believable Jane - and in this case her mother and sister as well. The premise of the story is not strained and set in context of what is known of Jane Austen's life by the 'Editor's Note' at the beginning of the story. Derbyshire, the setting of the story, is described by Elizabeth Bennet in 'Pride and Prejudice'. I love the way Barron has included charaters that could easily be part of an Austen novel, for example, Jane's singing clergyman cousin, Mr. Cooper, who continually talks of his patron. We meet Lord Harold Towbridge again, as well as the Duke of Devonshire and his family, in mourning over the death of the famous Georgiana Cavendish, Duchess of Devonshire. The local characters Jane meets while trying to solve the murder of the stillroom maid, Tess Arnold, are described well and fit the town of Bakewell very well. All in all, an excellent book for both mystery lovers and Jane Austen fans. In some ways it is better than any of the 'sequels' that have been written to Austen's novels, I guess because it fits with my ideas about what Jane Austen must have been like. One further point, I would suggest these books to teenagers who might be reluctant to read Jane Austen. The mystery will draw them in and they will quickly learn to enjoy the characters and wit of the story, which as I said, are very much like an Austen novel.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Darker Tone Than the Earlier Books, September 2, 2001
This review is from: Jane and the Stillroom Maid: Being the Fifth Jane Austen Mystery (Being A Jane Austen Mystery) (Mass Market Paperback)
I continue to be very impressed with this series of mysteries. This one took me a little bit more time to get into, perhaps more because of busyness in my own life than actually having trouble getting into the story, but, as in the past with these books, I ended up being very satisfied. There is a slightly larger cast of supporting characters here than in the past books, and this one is a little less overtly political (not so much worry about Napoleonic France here) but there are certainly class and social issues. Jane is more socially anxious than in the earlier books, as she heads off to the opulant home of her Whig friends. Some of this is a class and political consciousness, and some of this comes from the growing sense that she is older, without money, and without some of the prospects for happiness that she has to admit she yearns for. This is stronger here than in any of th earlier books. Jane's relationship with Sir Harold Trowbridge brings her both great joy and terrible pain, as she confronts the abyss between their social positions and knows that she can never home to cross the divide between them, no matter how beautifully their minds work together and they appreciate each other. The actual plot here is as clear and direct as the plot of the ealier books as well--solving the mystery is not the ultimate satisfaction here. It is coming to that solution with the very satisfying characters.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
![[Start the discussion]](http://g-ecx.images-amazon.com/images/G/01/x-locale/communities/discussion_boards/start-new-discussion-sec._V192250339_.gif){kind=small}
