Most Helpful Customer Reviews
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent overview--just as the title says, January 10, 1997
By A Customer
This is an excellent, concise history of Japan. The emphasis is
on the major historical events. I was glad to see the inclusion
of cultural, artistic and religious milestones as well. There
are summaries and datelines at the ends of each chapter as well
as a glossary, all of which are quite useful features, especially
if this book is to be used as an adjunct to formal study; I
found it extremely handy in helping me organize the facts mentally.
This is a history clearly written by a Nipponophile. There
is an emphasis on the post-Meiji history, which is probably not
inappropriate. Any insights into the Japanese psyche and
philosophy can be inferred generally from historical events, but
the treatment is not exhaustive. This book delivers what it
says: a concise history of Japan. For those who want to know
the essentials of Japanese history start here. For those
who want to know what makes Japan as a people tick psychologically,
you'll need more detail, however.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
11 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Too dry for my taste, October 23, 2001
As a casual history reader, I found this book way too dry. Although it delivers on its premise, namely sketching out a history of Japan, it was a relief to finally put the book down after having read it. This book I bought for the dual purpose of being entertained and learn something in the process, but it could only fulfill the latter requirement. It may be unfair to ask of a book to be engaging and still tell a whole country's history in under 300 pages, so I'm probably unfair - the book just reads too much like a textbook, and that wasn't really what I had hoped for. Not knowing too much about Japanese history from other sources, I can't comment on the accuracy of the text, but there's an annoyingly high frequency of simple spelling errors, etc. Lastly, there's only one map of Japan in the Southeast Asian setting, and it's buried deep inside of the book. I really missed a map of Japan in the book!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
8 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Dry and disjointed, December 3, 2005
To cut to the chase, this book is quite poorly written and does not serve its purpose well at all. The writing is extraordinarily dry, essentially like being at a *really* bad powerpoint presentation, as in: Here's a fact. Here's another fact. Here's another fact.... There is no insight gluing the facts together, and no craft of writing to integrate the sentences into a coherent whole. Just one "bullet point" after another.
Although this weakness had been implied by a couple of prior reviews, as a serious student of Japanese language and culture and an avid reader, I figured I could overcome. But it is simply not sensible to spend one's time plowing through such a book, which is in any case unlikely to result in anything remembered (I made it less than halfway before giving up).
In addition to the incredibly dull writing, the book lacks the insight of a Japan specialist. The author has written books on India, Pakistan, China, Philippines, and so on. Japan is a complex topic, and the depth of coverage betrays the fact that Japan is "just one" of his areas of study. It is always best to go with a true expert.
Finally, one notices that there are no positive reviews from newspapers or magazines, or even other authors, on the book itself. It is published by a relatively obscure publisher, and appears to have been written in quite a rush. This is not a work built to stand the test of time.
I will return this book to amazon for a refund (I very seldom do this), and will try a different author. To those that come after, I offer a strong warning that the quality of this book is unlikely to provide what you are looking for.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|