9 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The Book was Better, April 30, 2008
This review is from: Java Fundamentals I and II LiveLesson (Video Training) (Pt. 1-2) (Misc. Supplies)
I expected to play this on my DVD player and follow along with my laptop for any step-by-step code examples. I had great hopes of seeing programming concepts creatively illustrated in ways that just can't be accomplished in a book.
Instead, my DVD player didn't recognize the discs and I could only play them on my computer. This was basically fourteen hours of staring at code already written in a NetBeans editor while a faceless (and somewhat monotone) voice explained how the code works. The mouse pointer moves around or highlights some text to point out a particular area of code, the lessons sometimes shift to JavaDoc or a diagram, and you see Paul's face while he gives the intro and summary of each lesson... but it wasn't enough to keep me engaged.
Most if not all of the examples come from the book Java How to Program by Deitel & Associates, also around a hundred bucks. Personally, I'd prefer the book. If I'm staring at a pre-existing code sample, it's easier to read on paper. This does come with a small supplemental book with code samples but it's black and white, whereas the Java How to Program is in beautiful color.
Overall, this LiveLessons DVD pack isn't horrible - I simply think the Deitel book is a better value and I can only recommend this DVD product if you have two hundred dollars to spend and you wish to buy both the Java How to Program book and purchase this LiveLessons as a supplemental to break up the pace of your reading (it's a big book).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great course to learn Java, January 20, 2010
This review is from: Java Fundamentals I and II LiveLesson (Video Training) (Pt. 1-2) (Misc. Supplies)
Original review by Biagio Beatrice, JUG Lugano [...]
Java Fundamentals I and II is a multimedia Java programming language course. It's composed by 14 hours of video tutorials in 2 Dvd plus one book with code used in the video tutorials.
In the first Dvd, 7 hours of video are dedicated to the basic Java concepts: statements, classes and objects.
In the second dvd are approached the object oriented concept like inheritance and polymorphism.
In both Dvd there are tutorials about Netbeans and Eclipse very useful to the beginners.
The course don't need to be installed, there's a software that play video tutorials, you put inside and go. It run on Windows 2000, XP , Vista and on Mac but not on Linux (!!) you should use wine to run it on Linux but i didn't tested it. It would be fine if it could run on Linux too.
The Dvd needs at least 1280x960 video resolution so should not work fine on all personal computers. The course doesn't run on a dvd player, that improvement would be nice too , because you can work on the code you're learning while watching it on Tv.
The interface is simple and very easy to use.
Video tutorials are in English, Steve Dietel talk in all of them. It is not available another language or subtitles, but the English is clear for a non English speaker too. A good improvement could be to add subtitles, so it would be easier for non English speaker to follow the course.
Another good improvement would be add a bookmark, so if you have to stop for any reason the tutorial you can easily start from that point.
The strong point of the course is the "live code" approach , that means Java concepts in a working context. I found very easy to learn while working . For a lot of people this is the best approach and it's not boring indeed. To go further there's a lot of stuff on the editor website [...].
It's not required Object Oriented programming skill to follow the course, it's easy for people that have few experience in programming. Everything you need is in the course.
A very nice feature is that after the course you learn how to help yourself with Java API, essential skill for a Java programmer.
I found Java Fundamentals very nice and complete, is highly suggested for people that never have played with Java but have generic programming skill, after the course the student will be able to write simple programs and to go further with practice. It could be a good inspiration for teacher too I suggest for the beginners to start the course following the tutorials on Netbeans or Eclipse, so you can easily repeat and improve the code of the course. Another good improvement would be to put some exercise about topic covered.
Topics covered: Introduction to Java applications, introduction to Classes and Objects, Control Statements, Methods, Arrays, Classes and Objects, Inheritance, Polymorphism, Introduction to Graphical User Interfaces and Event Handling, Exception Handling, The Collection Framework, Introduction to NetBeans, Introduction to Eclipse.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No