From Publishers Weekly
This is an ambitious and for the most part successful attempt to compress 16 centuries of Jewish life in France into a compact account, though it is necessarily wide in reach rather than deep, and for a popular work the writing is surprisingly stiff and formalAperhaps an unfortunate by-product of such a tight compression. Some of the most important moments of French Jewish history (the Dreyfus Affair, the Holocaust and the resistance, for example) are given only cursory treatment and are narrated without dramatic verve. But Benbassa's command of the secondary literature is impressive. A professor of Jewish history at the Sorbonne, she reminds us that France was not just Paris, and her examination of Jewish life, emphasizing its regional variety, outside the French capital is important. Benbassa argues that France's intricate relationship with "its" Jews and their modern history of emancipation served as a paradigm for Jews in the Balkans and the Near East. "'Frenchness' became an integral part of the identity of these Jews," she states. She offers a close inspection of this paradigm from the time of the ancient Romans through the latest immigration to France from North Africa. Both the specialist and the general reader will find much that is useful here. There are interesting asides on social history: the role of women, styles of clothing and variations in language, though these asides are sometimes not fully developed. Overall, the work's examination of anti-Semitism, Zionism, modernism and the prolonged effects of the French Revolution more than make up for its defects.
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
From Library Journal
This survey of the life of the Jews in France from Roman times to the near-present offers a very useful summary of a troubled history. As the extensive bibliographies show, very little has been published on this subject in EnglishAcertainly nothing as broadly conceived as this book. Benbassa (Jewish history, the Sorbonne) reports on the way French Jews were alternately tolerated and distrusted in, and eventually deported from, France throughout history. But in every era described, they were never expelled entirely. Disappointingly, however, Benbassa refuses to recount the sufferings of French Jews (other writers, she explains, have repeatedly dealt with these tragedies). Consequently, the reader is left with the impression that, because they were often recognized by French civil and ecclesiastical officials for their value to society as bankers, artisans, and merchants, Jews in France had it pretty good. The book contains a useful chronology (which in some cases offers more information than the text itself). Recommended for academic libraries and large public libraries with Judaica collections.AJames A. Overbeck, Atlanta-Fulton P.L., Atlanta
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
Copyright 1999 Reed Business Information, Inc.
