From Publishers Weekly
Lipsyte ( The Contender ; The Brave ) kicks off his Superstar Lineup series of sports biographies with two thoughtful works. Thorpe uses the story of "perhaps the greatest all-around male athlete in American history" as a lens through which to examine the effects of racism on Native Americans, adroitly placing Jim Thorpe in the larger context of Native American history. Lipsyte is particularly good at outlining the chilling effects of the white-run government schools on Thorpe, who later had to fight against an image of himself as "a great performing animal." The same measured approach raises the Schwarzenegger book above the ordinary as well. Here Lipsyte situates Arnold among the famous strong men of history (Samson, Hercules), then places Schwarzenegger's bodybuilding fame in the context of fitness crazes of the past 150 years, skillfully synthesizing some of the important recent work in sports history and sociology. Schwarzenegger emerges warts and all, with Lipsyte touching on reports of the hero's father's Nazi sympathies, Schwarzenegger's steroid use and bullying of weaker people. Both works offer balanced portraits of memorable individuals. Photos not seen by PW . Ages 10-14.
Copyright 1993 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
From School Library Journal
Grade 5-8-Lipsyte tells the story of one of the great all-round athletes of this century. He writes in his usual fast-paced and clear style, and paints unvarnished portraits of such legendary sports figures as coach Pop Warner. Nor does he gloss over corruption of the past; for example, Thorpe was in college for about six years, doing little else than participating in sports. Most of the emphasis here is on his Native American heritage, and the controversy surrounding the loss of his Olympic gold medals for playing semi-pro baseball. However, for all the concentration on his background, readers don't gain much understanding of what kind of person Thorpe was. Partly this seems due to the fact that he was such a total jock. Sports was his life, and he wasn't one to talk a great deal about himself. Black-and-white photographs and reproductions appear throughout; they are small and of variable quality. Edward Rivinus's Jim Thorpe (Steck-Vaughn, 1990) is for a younger audience; Lipsyte offers fuller and more thoughtful coverage.
Todd Morning, Schaumburg Township Public Library, ILCopyright 1994 Reed Business Information, Inc.
--This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.