1.0 out of 5 stars
Sloppy writing, but an easy read, July 19, 2005
This review is from: John Peel (Hardcover)
I read this book on the beach in little more than a day, and felt afterwards I knew very little more about the man. This book's bulk is made up by lists and direct quotes from the valedictories of other writers, rock musicians and BBC people -- as much as is legally possible without having to get permission from their publishers.
As other reviewers have written, this is a pretty shabby book, exploiting the fact that Peel had apparently written little of his own autobiography before he died. There are many clues to the speed with which this book was rushed out. For example, on one page Wall says that T Rex's 'Ride a White Swan' went to number one. Just a few pages later, Wall admits that it only went to number two. One sentence contains both 'success' and 'successful' just a few words apart.
Throughout the book, Wall cannot make up his mind whether Peel survived for so long because he was his own man, or whether Peel, like Madonna, repeatedly reinvented himself to find a new audience. Only I'm not sure Wall realises there is any inconsistency in this.
I liked Peel a lot, and can remember listening to him under the dormitory sheets in the 1970s, praising Stevie Wonder's 'Songs in the Key of Life' to the hilt. The presence of Led Zeppelin's Stairway to Heaven in many of Peel's early festive lists also hints at the extent to which his tastes changed.
Personally, I feel that once Peel decided to embrace punk in 1976, he had a pernicious influence over many other BBC deejays. Several deejays such as Andy Kershaw just got too close, and found it hard to want to appreciate any music that Peel had already condemned. And the trouble is that Peel often condemned bands, not because there was anything wrong with their music, but simply because the band had become too successful.
So Peel comes across as the consistent champion of the underdog. I wouldn't go so far as classifying him as an underachiever himself, because no-one in authority ever seemed to think he had much potential. But this book gave me the impression that he could have achieved rather more if he had embraced TV more readily and he hadn't been so timid about flying.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No