1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
America's John Wayne, March 13, 2011
This review is from: John Wayne's America: The Politics of Celebrity (Hardcover)
I'll try to make this comment short, although John Wayne was a complex man and Gary Wills' book is 380 pages long. The subject of this discursive biography (1907 - 1979) was born in Iowa, moved to California at an early age, worked his way into low-budget Westerns, and during the 1940s had risen into box-office stardom. He more or less stayed there during the 50s, 60s, and much of the 70s. Wayne was an American icon. There are monumental statues of him larger than life, a major airport bears his name, he was awarded the Medal of Freedom, America's highest civilian honor.
Yet, what he did was act in the movies. Gary Wills does a perceptive and erudite number on Wayne, separating the man from the myth. That's as it should be in a factual document. If it were a hagiography, instead of "John Wayne's America" it would have to be called "John Wayne, America."
Actually, it's not nearly the mean-spirited analysis some might expect. It's by no means a tabloid expose. John Wayne emerges as a genuine human being, at least as virtuous as most of the rest of us. He could make fun of his own image, walking through brick walls on "Laugh In." And the "politics" of the subtitle has more to do with social relations within a community than with Wayne's sometimes fierce nationalism and anti-communism. Wills also seems to have done his routinely thorough job of research his subject and has interviewed just about everyone left alive with an opinion on Wayne and his career.
When it comes to stripping the myth away from the man, unwrapping the package, so to speak, Wills pay considerably more attention to people who had a hand in shaping the legend of John Wayne, particularly director John Ford, with whom Wayne had a prickly friendship but whose talent helped make Wayne into the myth he became. In later years, it was Wayne's star presence that helped keep aging auteurs like Ford and Hawks afloat. Wayne's personal life -- marriages and so forth -- are hardly mentioned. Ford was far more brutal towards Wayne for not enlisting during World War II than Wills ever is. The author gives us a reasonable understanding of Wayne's awkward and arguable position. With Ford, you were either in or out.
Mostly, time and space are given over to an analysis of Wayne's best movies such as "Stagecoach", "Red River," and "The Searchers," and including a couple of examples that I, for one, wouldn't ordinarily think of as among Wayne's better efforts: "The Shepherd of the Hills" and "Big Jake." Full credit is given to Wayne for his subtle but sometimes superb performances.
But it's not the directors alone that made Wayne the icon, nor was it just his talent. It was the embodiment of certain exceptionally American sentiments in his Westerns. More simply put, it was the city versus the freedom of the countryside. Everybody hates the city, even those who love it. That's why everybody moves to New Jersey and Florida and Oxnard. It's as close as they can get to Monument Valley and still have Starbuck's. In the country, especially as it was two hundred years ago, people could be free of federalist constraints and make their own rules. It was the appeal of Thomas Jefferson over Alexander Hamilton. The city caused people of different kinds to mix with each other, sometimes uncomfortably, and it brought anonymity and corruption. All real Americans are eager to cut off financial aid to the cities while giving tax breaks to the farmers, even if the farmer's name is Tenneco, Incorporated. The city is libraries. The frontier is experience. City people deserve to suffer while those on the frontier need to be rewarded for the risks they've taken.
I'm exaggerating here to make a point, but it's Wills' point and it makes sense in terms not only of our own history but our own current affairs.
I wouldn't avoid reading this because I expected it to be a hatchet job. And I wouldn't avoid reading it because I thought it would substitute the figure of John Wayne for that of Uncle Sam. I'd invite anyone to read it, though I disagree with some of Will's meditations, because we'd all be better off looking at the essence instead of the accident. Fooling ourselves can be fun. We all need fantasies from time to time. They provide us with guidelines for actions. But, when their values are adopted as axioms, in the long run they don't lead us anywhere except into trouble.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Most Serious and Egaging Wayne Biography, July 31, 2007
This review is from: John Wayne's America: The Politics of Celebrity (Hardcover)
Wills, author of many other works, including the amazing Lincoln at Gettysburg, sets an examination of Wayne's films squarely in the American zeitgeist - given them added heft and importance.
Wills will appear at San Francisco's Grace Cathedral on October 15, 2007, for a conversation with Dean Alan Jones. It will also be webcast live and archived for later listening. More information is available at: http://www.gracecathedral.org/calendar/detail.php?eid=1053.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No