2.0 out of 5 stars
Budgets for beginners, December 21, 2010
This review is from: The Jossey-Bass Academic Administrator's Guide to Budgets and Financial Management (Jossey-Bass Academic Administrator's Guides) (Paperback)
It is not clear who the real audience of this book is. For the most part, this book seems to be written for someone planning to take a position working on budgets in a university setting -- it provides a very basic background with more of a philosophical perspective than concrete advice on working with numbers. The chapter on "potential pitfalls in fiscal management" would be particularly useful for new budget managers. In contrast, the chapter on "dealing with budget cuts" provides some valuable perspectives into alternative approaches planning and implementing substantial budget reductions across multiple units -- advice that is probably more useful for an administrator responsible for making major decisions that impact many facets of a college or university with different units that each have distinct budgets.
In short, if you are a new budget analyst for a department, school, or college, or if you are a new dean with little budgeting experience you may find this book useful. It is short, fast reading, and well written. In contrast, if you have been in the business for a little while and are looking for tips on how to be more effective, you will probably not learn very much from this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
3.0 out of 5 stars
Very Elementary, November 8, 2010
This review is from: The Jossey-Bass Academic Administrator's Guide to Budgets and Financial Management (Jossey-Bass Academic Administrator's Guides) (Paperback)
This could have been given one star or five, depending on the book's potential audience. Any academic with a barebones sense of how universities work and an elementary awareness of budgeting will find the book to be too basic to be useful. An innocent individual with little sense of how such institutions operate may find it very useful. Hence, I split the difference and gave it three stars.
If you don't know the difference between operating budgets and capital budgets, this book will be useful. If you don't know the meaning of 'fiscal year' versus 'calendar year' or revenues versus expenditures, this book is for you. If you're a person trying to read a balance sheet and wonder what kind of items might be included under 'Transfers', this book will not tell you. If you want to know whether or not most university athletics areas pay their own way or why university renovation costs are so high, this book will not tell you. If you were not aware of the fact that university budgeting requires guidelines and timetables, you need to read this book.
The book is largely philosophical, i.e., it tells you what you should be thinking about and what you need to do (in the most general of terms). It does not provide crisp statistical information, detailed information on best practices or guides to financial terminology (though there is a two and a quarter page glossary at the end (which explains such words as 'endowment' and 'appropriation'). It will tell you what 'responsibility centered management' means, but it will not give you a mini- case study on how this has worked (or failed) at a representative institution.
In short, it is very, very basic. It also includes some surprising statements, for example, the description of cost centered management as requiring individual units to 'stand on their own bottoms'. The usual phrasing is 'float on their own bottoms' or the unit as a 'tub' which 'floats on its own bottom'. Standing on one's own bottom requires a physical capacity beyond most humans and the phrasing undercuts our faith in the author's authority. I don't say that to be snarky; I simply want to warn potential readers that they are likely to require something more advanced.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No