Customer Reviews

Joy (W/Dvd)

5 star:		(20)
4 star:		(20)
3 star:		(9)
2 star:		(5)
1 star:		(7)

 

 

Don't normally leave reviews, but it was sad to see a single 1 star review for this album from a disappointed fan. As with the last couple of studio releases from Phish, Joy requires a) some interest in Phish and what they're doing and b) an open mind with regards to how the new stuff sounds vs. the old stuff.

I can't see this album being a commercial success, though its not for lack of trying. The first two tracks are clear commercial/radio shots. They're not bad, but I'd be surprised if they gained much mainstream appreciation. Diehard Phish fans will probably find them flat. Backwards Down the Number Line does catch on you after a few listens. The first minute of the song leaves a bad first impression, but by the end of it I'm wishing it would go on a bit longer. The inclusion of a nice live version of it on Track 11 is wise, as it shows the song can lead to a relatively interesting jam.

That said, there are some nice Phish nuggets here that open-minded Phans should appreciate: Sugar Shack is a fun and funky number - give it two listens before you judge. Ocelot has potential for a real nice live jam; I sense the studio isn't doing this song justice. Light starts out with a great electronic/instrumental jam that I look forward to hearing more improvisation upon. And, of course, Time Turns Elastic is a nice long exploration that will become a major 2nd Set contribution for shows to come.

Is it as good as Junta? Of course not. No band in history has ever put out work with he energy and creativity they started with 20+ years ago. That doesn't mean that something a third as good isn't worth creating. So give it a chance. For a band of this longevity, this is a solid effort.

Phish is obviously a band famous for their live performances with elusive jams, extensive solos, and song transitions that melt Moma Dance into Ghost like a little kids ice cream during a hot summer day. I personally own a collection of Hundreds of live bootlegs and love every one of them. Due to this obsession for uniqueness only found in the Live music, Phish's studio albums often get overlooked by fans. I myself fall victim to going years only listening to Phish bootlegs without touching a studio release. Rift and Billy Breathes are my favorite studio albums when I am looking for a change. Even though tickets for their 2009 Summer tour were immediately sold out within less than ten minutes(mostly to scalpers), I do not expect this album to do well from an album sales perspective, yet that does not stop the album from being good in its own right.

Over the Summer Tour Phish mixed in, regularly, most of the songs on this album maybe even playing Time Turns Elastic one too many times for some fans, although I feel the band played a good mix of old and new as a whole. Having gone to 9 shows this summer I was able to hear all the songs a few times. At the moment, I hated them and loved them depending on my mood. Rating by the live renditions my favorite new songs were Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan, Ocelot, and Alaska(not on album), oh how did I almost forget my favorite "Party Time"(available on Joy deluxe edition or the Maryland show bootleg ;} ) a Jon Fishman original in the spirit of HA HA HA HA(also played right before Party Time the first time live). Songs such as Kill Devil Falls and Backwards Down the Number Line saw some nice jams throughout the tour, also.

Oh yeah this is supposed to be a review of the studio album, so on we go. I will have to say that I enjoy the album more than expected. Obviously, most of the studio versions of songs are shorter and more crisp than the live versions. Some of the songs that may have appeared to break the flow of a live show, such as Joy and Light, fit very nicely into the peaceful, transcending nature of this album. Stealing Time From The Faulty Plan plays better live, but the studio version is commendable. Time Turns elastic is a good song in its own right and plays in movements like a classical piece. Twenty Years Later is one of the highlights of the album and takes advantage of the studio production to clean up the voices and guitar licks. As a whole, I feel the production is very crisp and smooth and the album flows to a upbeat, yet relaxing tune.

If you are expecting to hear the next Punch You In The Eye(which I do not believe even has a studio equivalent anyways) or the live jamming Phish(as seen in concert) this album is a waste of time, but if you are looking to hear Phish's studio offering for what it is then Phish's true versatility to shine through in all genres of music may appear.

Currently, the album can be sampled on Phish's MySpace in its entirety for free. I'll see everyone at festival 8 where Phish will do what it does best, but until then check this out its worth the while. Ignore the 1 star DB's this album is a 3 at worst.

Joy is fantastic album and a great return to form. It takes the best elements of their earlier albums, but polishes the rough edges and makes for perhaps their most approachable album. It has the feel of their live performances, but the refined quality of a studio. The jam songs have a clear direction and sense of purpose unlike the songs found on Undermind or Round Room. For someone who's been a fan since the early 90s, i can hear riffs and styles that pull from their early days and then mixed with their on-again/off-again 2000s. Time Turns Elastic shows off their progressive epic style, while Been Around Awhile has their sense of humor. Light shows off their great vocal harmonies. Its almost like a mini trip through their whole career.

The only criticisms i could give are that some of the lyrics are borderline sappy and corny, even though i'm sure they express genuine feelings. Also I'm not wild of the amount layering they do of Trey's vocals upon himself in some songs when the rest of the band has been more than adequate to provide harmony in the past.

A diverse and beautiful album with songs from all band members except for Fishman. If you love Phish, you already know all the songs since they played them on summer tour 2009 before the official release, if not, this is a very accessible introduction to one of rock&roll's greatest bands ever ...

P.S. True Phish fans should get the Joy Deluxe Edition (incl. a second CD plus Live DVD) which is available only at Drygoods!

This is a great album...Those of you who have criticized this record need to listen up...Kill Devil Falls is fantastic as is Time Turns Elastic...Each song has it's own personal flavor and vibe and the production is A++...No this record is not as good as Billy Breathes or as inventive as Rift, but this album given time will prove to provide us with more than a few Phish classics.

Compared to their last few albums, I greatly enjoyed this one.

Sure, some of the songs are kind of silly. I particularly dislike Mike and Page's songs, which is too bad, as I usually enjoy the contrast of their styles compared to Trey's.

Quite a few solid songs, however. If you are a Phish fan, you'll probably get the CD regardless of these reviews. This cd, however, makes the band much more approachable for first-timers, which I believe is a good goal.

They are rocking again live, which really makes me happy to see.

I think Joy picks up where Farmhouse left off. The production and sound of the album is great. Unlike Billy Breathes, it has a very Un-Lillywhite sound to it. Rather than state what has already been stated, I think it's a great album from a great band. Comparisons to albums like Junta or Rift are useless. They are a different band. On it's own, this album is solid. I feel Trey's vocals are the best since "Shine," especially when he starts to cut it loose a bit.

Phish's lyrics have always been hit or miss with reviewers. Has anyone gotten into Phish for their lyrical content? Don't get me wrong, they have some great great songs, but when I listen to Phish, it's not because I can connect with their lyrics. They've always had that oddball factor with Tom Marshall's writing. Why judge it on something that it's not?

Anyone who reads this review after a 1-Star review, don't bother with the 1-Star reviews. Any Phish phan knows that the legacy of the band lies in experiencing them live. And with the exception of Billy Breathes and Joy, the previous studio albums tended to reinforce that notion.

But this isn't just their second best album. This is a statement. Phish is back. Their creativity is back as well.

The album opens with 'Backwards Down the Number Line', a great opener with a catchy hook and thought-provoking lyrics. When I first heard it, it immediately brought me great memories from their 8/11 show in Chicago. 'Sugar Shack' proves that their versatility is back as the reggae tone is completely different from 'Number Line'. 'Kill Devil Falls' fulfills the guys' need to just get down and rock. With Trey opening with a sharp lick and a big opening beat from Fish, you can't help but tap your feet and get into the groove. 'Time Turns Elastic', while long and often ridiculed by some fans, is a totally different approach from the band, and it works. They clearly took time to craft the song, and the classical music-like movements showcase that.

That's a little bit about the album. If you're a phan, you should be able to find a level of good in this record. We all know that Phish is better live than in the studio. But one good sign for the band and for all of us phans is that Phish may be turning a corner in the studio. Good work, boys.

I was not able to see Phish before this year but have been a phan for a few years and this year I got to see them do two amazing shows at Bonnaroo where they debuted two of the songs on this album, "Backwards down the numberline" and "Kill Devil Falls". These songs were great live and I have to say the rest of this album is great as well. One of the best things I like about the album is that they were able to get that Live sound in a studio album. I just wish I lived closer to California so I could go to this years Phish Fest. I hope they tour next spring.

First, I have never been a big fan of the Phish studio albums - not that I did not like them but to me the music always seemed a little bit too slick and the lyrics a little bit too cute.

Having said that, I like "Joy" a lot. In many ways it reminds me of many of the Beetle albums in that the songs grab you the first time you hear them and on a second listen are as comfortable as your favorite jeans. These are songs that will echo in your mind long after the music stops and thats about as good as it gets.