1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This is one you really want to read, July 27, 2007
This review is from: Judas: The Gospel of Betrayal (Paperback)
Fred Ramsay sure knows how to tell a story! Judas: The Gospel of Betrayal is a one-sit book: You get it, you sit down to read it, and you can't get up until you're done.
The book is a fictional account of Judas, the disciple who betrayed Jesus, but you don't have to know the actual history to enjoy the story.
If you like mysteries, you'll like this book. If you like historical novels, you'll like this book. If you like Christian novels, you'll like this book. Heck, if you enjoy reading at all, you'll like this book.
Ramsay takes readers on a fast-paced romp. Lots of writers can do that-although he does it far better than the average bear. What's truly unique is readers don't need to know the history to fully enjoy the book. If you know the Bible story, you'll enjoy the book's congruity with the Scriptures. If you don't know the Bible story, you'll simply rock along enjoying the book.
As you may have gathered, I really like this book-and I'm not a big fan of most fiction.
However, I do have a rather large bone to pick about one of the back notes Ramsay included to add historical details should the reader be interested.
In the back note about the Crucifixion, Ramsay says the Bible's description of that day's events cannot be accurate and seemingly dismisses one part of the story concerning the guards. I have two problems with this: First, the story about the Roman guards is supported in other materials, and the guards were definitely Roman, not from the temple as Ramsay posits.
Second, Christians cannot pick and choose which parts of the Scripture to believe. We may not understand it all, but that's simply a matter of further study. Approaching the Bible as if it were a smorgasbord, wherein we pick and choose the items we like, destroys its integrity, and we lose the solid rock on which we stand. Some liberal scholars (so-called) take the pick-and-choose approach, but that's about ego, not about God's word. I don't get the idea Ramsay's part of that sad group.
It may be that Ramsay is hatching a plan. The actions of the Roman guards that he cites are quite inexplicable unless you understand the political intrigue involved. Perhaps this fine writer has set us up for another page-turner. That would be a good thing.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
About Judas: a Gospel of Betrayal, by Fred Ramsay, July 6, 2007
This review is from: Judas: The Gospel of Betrayal (Paperback)
About Judas: a Gospel of Betrayal, by Fred Ramsay
Fred Ramsay is the kind of character who looks at things from an angle that most people have never considered. Once, long ago, I compared him to Gary Larson, the artist behind the "Far Side" cartoons. I explained that when Larson had made a cartoon of a dog scratching, he drew it from the flea's perspective. (I believe the caption was, "The claw, the claw's back! Quick! Grab the kids!") As the rector of our little church, Fred's sermons were compelling not only because of his great knowledge of Scripture but also because this ability to look at things from this "Far Side" perspective.
What does all this have to do with a fictional look at the life of the most despised apostle? The "Far Side" look at Judas has to handle who Judas was, why the other apostles disliked him, how he actually came to betray Christ, and what became of him. The novel is also about how Fred Ramsay handles these differing views of Judas. He does all of this and makes it an interesting, no compelling story.
First, the author knows what he's talking about in terms of the history and culture of the area. Second, the characters in his story are realistic and credible, both from a first century perspective and a twenty-first century point of view. Third, he tells the story in an interesting, intimate way - in the first person. And then, there's that unexpected ending.
Anyone with any interest in reading about the saints and sinners in the early Christian Church, anyone interested in feeling what life under Roman rule was really like, and anyone who wants an easy-to-read story about living in turbulent times will be interested in this book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No