Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
36 of 40 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
"Jump" Best Maxi-Single of 'Confessions' Era, November 8, 2006
Out of all the singles released during Madonna's "Confessions on a Dance Floor" era, I feel "Jump" is by far the best. The song itself is Madonna at her best; a sort of inspirational, pop pick-me-up inspiring people to not allow the pressures and trials of life get you down and go for what you want and never to "look back".
Single wise, this is the first maxi-single in ages to actually include an extended mix. Not only is the extended version of "Jump" true to the original but it adds in great vocal effects at the start and ending to really give the song an epic-dance feel to it. The Jacques Lu Cont mix of Jump removes the upbeat dance feel of the song and adds in a more mysterious, darker tone that actually gives the song new life. The Axwell mix and the Mixshapes are both pretty good as well; very club-ready and unlike some of the past singles, they actually make good use of the vocals and don't completely hack away at the original song and the message.
What also makes "Jump" stand out from the other releases is the unreleased song from 'Confessions' titled "History." To me, it's one of Madonna best b-sides and is album worthy. Heavy-dance beat with a plea for people to take a look at the world we live in and to actually do something to make it better. This, to me, is Madonna at her best; not only does she bring a nice dance beat with great production and a nice show of her vocals, but she also has lyrics that actually SAY something and have meaning.
This is probably the last single from "Confessions" but wow, this is a way to close out another album era. This is a must own and draws strength from the variety and great production each mix was given. While the "Hung Up" and "Get Together" singles both seemed to be a bit repetitive and not do the album-version of the songs justice, this single actually does a great job of offering listeners the song as it was on the album and different interpretations; from a darker, moodier, version as captured by Jacques Lu Cont to the techno-club ready tracks made by Axwell and Mixshapes. Plus, as an added bonus you have the epic-feel Extended mix and the unreleased, remixed version of 'History'. BUY this single, you won't be dissapointed. Are you ready to jump?
|
|
|
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Best of the Four Singles from Confessions, December 4, 2006
I've read a lot of reviews of Madonna's latest singles from Confessions on a Dance Floor. While I do agree that they are not as good as past maxi singles, I don't think they're as bad as all these people make them out to be. You know when you buy mixes like this you always take a risk because usually there is only a couple of good ones and the b-side is an added bonus. I was very dissapointed in the Hung Up single, the Sorry single had good points but was way worth the price just for the remix of "Let It Will Be"-which I had just discovered seeing the concert on TV two weeks ago! I loved it! Get Together was an improvement over Sorry, just because I think the song is slower and it's nice to hear remixes of it. Jump, however is good from start to finish. Nothing brilliant, but worth getting, if only for the unreleased song "History". If you're a big Madonna fan, you'll enjoy the b-side a lot, but I don't think casual fans would really go for it. It's in the same vein as "Get Together", only more upbeat and longer. Very nice song. I would like to see more b-sides like this rather than all mixes on these singles. I felt like "Fighting Spirit" should be on one of these releases rather than on the limited edition of the album. Don't always decide on your purchases based on these reviews. If you're a Madonna fanatic, get them all. If you're not, then just get "Jump". It seems to be the best.
|
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A great single., December 16, 2006
Okay, Madonna has gotten really cheap when it comes to sleeve art. She used the Gap Ad photos for sleeve covers on Nothing Fails, Love Profusion imports, and the Revisited EP. The cover for Hung up was from an already existing photo in the full album, Get Together looked like a publicity shot, and Jump.. well..
But the single is far better than it's appearance.
RADIO EDIT
I personally think making a radio edit of a song that is already less than four minutes long is pretty silly. There is nothing wrong with this track, it sounds precisely like the album version, the missing seconds are hardly noticed.
JACQUES LU CONT MIX
I love this mix. I think Stuart's mixes have been very hit or miss. His mix of Get Together was terrible. He removed all the decent parts of the song and added some crappy bass-line. But I thought his extended version of Hung Up was by FAR the best version on it's single. THe only reason his mix of Jump isn't my favorite here is because the other mixes are equally impressive. This mix has a trance quality to it, although I think it's still too Pop to be considered a 'trance track'. He chooses to loop the line "Just Take My Hand" and "My Sisters and Me' to a steady beat with throbbing synths and it's delicious. On a dancefloor it's magic. It's also not too long, like some of the mixes from Ray Of Light.. the ones that stretched out into double digits.
AXWELL MIX
The first mix I heard, it somehow was leaked onto the internet in August, months before it's November release. Of course whenever you downloaded something unauthorized, the track inevitably has a certain unofficial sound to it. It just didn't really impress me until I played it on my CD. It's got a great club beat. It's fun. Although my least favorite of the mixes, it's still a better than any of the mixes on Get Together.
MISSHAPES MIX
My favorite by far. Of all the mixes, this one still thrives outside the club. An edited version is available on iTunes, but it's the full length mix (which isn't even all that long) is by far THE BETTER CHOICE. This mix is totally creative and fun. It's very pop, very danceable, enough removed from the original to sound like a brand new song. This is hands down my favorite mix from all four singles combined. No question in my mind. This mix is fabulous.
EXTENDED VERSION
Awkward and unecessary the extended version feels amateur at best. It has a very 'lazy' feel to it. The only real difference is the opening, which is a minute or two longer and features Madonna's line "I can make it alone" overdubbed about 100 times. This goes on a good minute before the bassline comes in and the song opens. The song is still great, but when you've got a perfect album version, one wonders why this even exists. It's not like they even extended it all that far. Maybe if this track was 10 minutes, or even just 8 minutes...
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
Interact With Your Music: Discover, listen to, and buy new music, all from the pages of SPIN's digital edition, free to Amazon customers.
- the new music site from IMDb and Amazon.
