78 of 100 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Someone explain this series to me.., September 10, 2003
Because I don't get it. Schools seem to love them - is there some special highly-technical educational matrix that this junk fits into that I need a degree in education to understand? My 1st-grade daughter reads everything, and on her second day her teacher recommended this book. We read it together, and I had to stop every other sentence and talk about how we don't call people stupid, how we don't judge others by the fact that you can beat them up, how you don't deal with being afraid by calling everyone names and hitting them, and how you don't go rummaging through other people's belongings and taking whatever you want. It's ridiculous. Unless the point is to get parents to spend time teaching kids how not to behave - but we get enough of that from real-life. There will be plenty of time for our children to become discriminating readers who know when they're reading a fun book - but at this age,at this stage, they are learning how to behave around others. When these books are encouraged by adults, a 1st-grader can't be blamed for thinking this is encouraged behavior.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
10 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Go read this book speedy-quick. By Kate., July 8, 1998
By A Customer
My name is Katherine. I used to be 5, but now I'm 6. I took this book to my school. My teacher loved it. She laughed. She read it to the class and her name is Mrs. Sellars. This book is funny and I like 'em and they're just cool. Junie's a kindergartner, I'm a kindergartner. She's p.m., I'm p.m. I wish she had a movie about Junie B. Jones. This book is about Junie taking the bus to school, but she didn't. I love the bus. And I like Junie B. The End.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Very Poor Influence on Its Targeted Readers, July 13, 2011
I'm delighted that my 5 (almost 6) year old daughter loves to read, and I was thrilled that my wife managed to find some books that are at her reading level and yet tell real, and to some degree, compelling stories.
But after my 16 year old daughter caught a whiff of the books and told me they may not be so great, I read "Junie B. Jones and the Stupid Smelly Bus" for myself. On the surface, it's no worse than what my 5 year old has seen in life before. But the fact is that literature does something to us, more than entertaining us. As I learned in graduate school in English literature and have been learning ever since as a father, teacher, and pastor, literature not only delights but (as Horace said) teaches by delighting.
So what does "Junie B. Jones and the Stupid Smelly Bus" teach?
1. It teaches that hating things is normal and even funny.
"I HATE THIS STUPID DUMB CIRCLE."
"That Jim I hate."
"I hate it in this stupid smelly bus."
2. She calls lots of things stupid.
3. Some of the pictures are pictures of how I want my kids NOT to act: going "Ta Da! Here I am, aren't I cute?", covering her ears and stamping her foot when she doesn't like something, and giving a sassy and pretentious turn of the head back to another child. I've seen this exact pose on my 5 year-old, and now I think I know where it came from!
4. The humor in the book comes mostly from Junie doing things like hiding in the supply closet, wandering the school at will, and invading the nurse's office and dumping out band-aids and playing with crutches and plays with the phone. And, of course, calling 911 and having a fire truck, police car, and ambulance arrive because of the "emergency" she claimed to be having.
The consequences of all of this? Her Mother (there's not Dad in the book) tells her that what she did was very wrong. That's it.
The book is targeted for kindergarteners through 3rd graders. Is this what we want to communicate to them? Is this really the kind of literature that Publisher's Weekly and School Library Journal want to promote?
Yikes!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No