Most Helpful Customer Reviews
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Compares very favorably to best know management guides, October 30, 2009
This review is from: Just Ask Leadership: Why Great Managers Always Ask the Right Questions (Hardcover)
In my 20+ years in managment, I've read many of the best sellers, including some excellent ones. I'd put "The Fifth Discipline", "Good to Great", "In Search of Excellence", "First Break all the Rules" and almost anything by Jack Welch near the top. I've also read most of Deming, Juran, Crosby, Sherkenbach, and Victor Vroom. You probably recognize Deming, Juran and Crosby. Sherkenbach, also a TQM guru, led Ford Motors' quality program. Vroom wrote "Work and Motivation" back in the 60's -- it is THE seminal work on employee motivation and is still available. If you haven't read it and you have any interest in the subject, you need to.
Of all of these works, only "First Break All The Rules" is as readable as "Just Ask Leadership". A couple of hours of light reading gets you some memorable and practical advice. I was responsible for strategic planning for an 800 employee, $300 million/year organization so I think I know that subject as well as anyone. Chapter 1 of "Just Ask" is as good a guide to strategic planning as I've ever read.
I read Bock's review and I understand his criticism about the loose structure. Unlike many of the best sellers mentioned above, "Just Ask" doesn't boil all of managmement down to a neat half dozen bromides ("stick to the knitting" "loose-tight management" etc). This is not a dispargement of the best sellers. I like those books and I have often found those bromides helpful, despite their triteness. But, "Just Ask" is ultimately about just one thing -- How would your management practices be changed if you started all of your problem solving with a series of questions? You could spend three hours contemplating that question or you could read "Just Ask". I think you'll find reading "Just Ask" to be a much better use of your time.
Yes, "Just Ask" is, ultimately, a one trick pony. But, it's a good trick. One well worth learning -- and one that "Just Ask" teaches well.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Should be required reading, September 2, 2009
This review is from: Just Ask Leadership: Why Great Managers Always Ask the Right Questions (Hardcover)
Unfortunately, so many of us grew up in a command and control environment. Our parents told us what to do. The same thing with school, the teachers told us what to do. Our first employment probably continued the same pattern. So by the time we had risen to any sort of managerial position we were totally indoctrinated in the habit of trying to lead by telling rather than asking.
And we have been done a real disservice.
"Would you rather be asked for your input or told what to do?" According to a survey conducted by the author, 95% of leaders preferred to be asked questions rather than told what to do. But "these same leaders give instructions 58% of the time rather than ask."
"If you want to lead and motivate others, questions are the answer. If we tell our coworkers how to do their jobs, we are essentially limiting their options and stifling their initiative. We're not leading." But, as you will learn from this book, all questions are not created equal. The right question can empower, inspire and challenge. The wrong question - a gotcha you question - enhance the status of the asker but demoralize and create distrust among those being asked.
This book is all about teaching you the right questions to ask and the correct way to ask them. The book is a series of questions in five separate categories. 1) How to improve the vision of the organization 2)How to ensure accountability 3) How to build unity and cooperation 4) How to create better decisions and 5) How to motivate to action. In each chapter there are a series of questions and discussion about those questions.
The questions should not be taken as a strict guide. The entire book is designed to change the mindset from command and control to leadership through asking the right questions in the correct manner.
The book is filled with stories that illustrate the point. The book is short and very easy to read, the discussion centered around each question is short and to the point.
The forward was written by Harry Beckwith. If you like his work, you will love this book. The style and approach of Beckwith is very similar to Cohen's.
While the book is intended for business, the concepts work equally well in education, family and personal relationships. People would much rather be asked than told.
You will need to study the book and internalize the ideas. Changing the mindset to an "ask instead of tell" will take time. But it will be well worth it. Your effectiveness will improve. "When leaders use more questions than commands, the organization's culture flourishes."
Highly recommended for anyone who wants to be more effective in dealing with others.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Plain Speaking for Amazing Results - So Good I Bought 20 Copies, October 9, 2009
This review is from: Just Ask Leadership: Why Great Managers Always Ask the Right Questions (Hardcover)
This is one of those books that at one level seems to state the obvious. Look beyond it and you will find that it is jam packed with nuggets of useful information and practical advice. It is extremely well written and is one of those rare books, that once I had started I could not put down.
Who could have thought that so much common sense could be packed into just 5 chapters. The book is not at all theoretical and instead is rooted very firmly on the practical, can do side of life. Anyone who follows along with the book and ask the questions posed of themselves can't help but see and make big improvements in their business life.
I particularly liked the case study examples and the easy to follow approach.
The depth of the book, as the title implies is how to ask questions and what questions to ask, some of the questions seem simple, but as the examples show, the results are amazing. Each chapter looks at a different aspect of leadership and provides a list of questions that you can ask to improve, it then provides details and insights into why the question is used and how to understand the implications of the answers.
I guess the best way to summarise the book for you is to say that having read it I bought 20 copies to give out to my friend and clients!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
|