6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Haunting Call, September 27, 2004
Anyone who has heard the call of a loon on a lake at night is bound to be impressed by these birds. This book is full of pictures of loons, with some supporting discussion, and a CD of loon calls.
The book describes and defines loons, including how to find them, their family life, their calls, how to photograph them and loon conservation. The pictures in the book were taken by the late Bill Silliker, Jr., who was a famous wildlife photographer, and the book is clearly a vehicle for his work. Many of Silliker's pictures are first rate and quite striking, especially considering the difficulties of photographing a bird whose colors range from the brightest whites to dark, matte black. Sometimes, however, he shoots into the light when trying to record some element of loon behavior (not a deliberate silhouette) and these photographs are less successful. I must also confess that after 100 pages, even though I love loons, the pictures had developed a certain sameness.
The narrative provided was more of the "aren't loons great" type then being very useful. The book told me little more about loons then several pages in Kenn Kaufman's "Lives of North American Birds" or David Allen Sibley's "Guide to Bird Life and Behavior", although it did make clear to me that the reason loons nest on the water's edge is because they find it impossible to walk on land. Although the book notes that there are 5 species of loons in North America, it is devoted only to the common loon. Serious birders may well have to wait for the Oxford University Press to get to the loons in their series on Bird Families of the World for really detailed information.
I was particularly disappointed by the book's discussion of photographing loons. It's clear that most, if not all, of the pictures in this book were taken from a boat. Having done a little bit of avian photography from a kayak, I know that this type of photography requires some different techniques than shooting from terra firma. I would have liked to see some discussion of how to follow the bird photographer's rule about getting close to the ground when you are on water.
Although its clear that the CD of loon calls was an afterthought, (there is no reference to it in the text about the calls of loons,) listening to it is (pardon the pun) a hoot. While I doubt that anyone would ever mistake any loon call for the sound of another animal, filling your den with the call of these ancient birds is thrilling.
In summary, this looks like a good gift book for someone who likes loons and good pictures of them. It certainly is not a thorough reference book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No