Customer Reviews

Justice League: Crisis on Two Earths [Blu-ray]

5 star:		(62)
4 star:		(52)
3 star:		(20)
2 star:		(8)
1 star:		(8)

 

 

Parallel earths, an evil Justice League, and Batman being badasss... JUSTICE LEAGUE: CRISIS ON TWO EARTHS gives the people what they want, and that this flick touts a PG-13 rating is yet one more treat. I've missed the Justice League since the series went off the air, and the solo adventures of Bats and Superman, Wonder Woman and GL are great, but I miss all the interaction.

The plot could've been convoluted, but the clear storytelling makes things easy to follow. It starts with a bare-nekkid Lex Luthor seeking help from the Justice League. Luthor claims to be from an alternate universe, one in which that version of the Justice League calls itself the "Crime Syndicate," and not because someone was trying to be ironic. The Justice League agrees to cross over to put a stop to their crooked doppelgangers, even though everyone's pretty suspicious, especially Superman (because it's still friggin' Luthor) and Batman, who decides to stay behind. I think I'll stop right there with the plot breakdown, other than to mention that, as it falls out, the stakes are much, much higher than mere world domination. The main bad guy spits at world domination.

The pace really moves. The story's good, and it's big in scope. I'm a sucker for mirror universes. But the highlights are the action sequences, thanks to some sharp animation and a pretty good voice cast (although, I miss Kevin Conroy's iconic timbre and I'm still not sure about Mark Harmon as Supes). There are several awesome battle royales, pitting the League against folks who can match and sometimes surpass them in power. Three pick of the pack moments for me: Aquaman actually not being a sissy; Wonder Woman demonstrating crunching warrior skills in her scuffle with Superwoman; and Batman's extended contest of brawn and wits with Owlman. Owl Man, by the way, is about as dangerously unbalanced as they come and in him, Batman finally meets someone who not only can outfight him but is even more detached than he is. James Woods is superb as Owlman. I mentioned earlier that I love that the Dark Knight comes across as a bad mofo here, clearly the underdog in his tussle with Superwoman and then with Owlman, until he applies the underhanded technique of trickeration on them. And - maybe a SPOILER alert here for the rest of this sentence - for someone who doesn't believe in killing, Batman sure has no qualms about offing off two of the more noticeable villains.

It's fun, also, to see how familiar faces are presented in this alternate reality, and can you identify each side character? That's not a Barsoomian; that's an alternate J'onn J'onzz with four arms. On the other side of that coin, I like that they've put the "real" Martian Manhunter in his more updated, much cooler threads. But poor Harley Quin...

Other than the absence of Kevin Conroy and perhaps the presence of Mark Harmon, the only other beefs I have - and they're very minor - concern Ultra Man speaking like a two-bit thug. I dunno, maybe I expected more gravitas coming from the most powerful despot on the planet. And I don't know that the unlikely romance which surfaces halfway thru the film doesn't feel like a filler.

Also on this DVD is the first in a series of animated shorts which will hopefully go on to feature the more obscure DC superheroes. DC SHOWCASE, in its debut, presents the Specter. This 12-minute-long short reeks of that film noir vibe, bolstered by a first person narrative and a funky 1970s-type opening score. Set in Los Angeles, police detective Jim Corrigan investigates the murder of a film producer. If you're not familiar with the Specter and his gristly brand of justice, then you're in for a treat and for a great reveal at the end. Even if you're already down with the supernatural, pasty-skinned Spirit of Vengeance, this short is still very well done, with excellent near-anime and sometimes purposely scratchy visuals and outstanding voice work done by Gary Cole and Alyssa Milano, who plays a femme fatale role.

What I've got is the two disc set. Disc 1 has the feature film, the Specter short; an exclusive first look at the next direct-to-DVD film from DCAU, BATMAN: UNDER THE RED HOOD, and previously released first looks at three other DC Universe Animated Original Movies: GREEN LANTERN: FIRST FLIGHT; SUPERMAN/BATMAN: PUBLIC ENEMIES, and WONDER WOMAN: THE AMAZON PRINCESS. There are also trailers for HALO LEGENDS and NARUTO SHIPPUDEN: THE MOVIE. Disc 2 has: "DCU: THE NEW WORLD" - a 26-minute-long segment in which several of DC's creative forces discuss the evolution of the modern-age superhero and the relevance of a shared superhero universe, from when Superman first appeared with Batman & Robin on the same cover in 1940 to ALL-STAR COMICS #3 and the JSA's debut, from CRISIS ON INFINITE EARTHS to IDENTITY CRISIS and onwards. Also here are two bonus episodes from the JUSTICE LEAGUE television series, the pivotal classic two-parter "A Better World," a parallel Earth story in which Superman finally frags Luthor and what happens after that.

Although both Warner/DC and Marvel/Lion's Gate have had their missteps, DC is definitely winning the direct-to-video war in terms of quality. The feature here is full of beautifully orchestrated and designed fight scenes (even if perhaps at the sake of plot) reminiscent of the best moments of the Justice League series. The new character designs look great and classic, although some of the original voices are to be missed. WB is very smart to be staying very close to Bruce Timm's established DC Animated Universe with their releases ("Gotham Knights" not withstanding). It automatically lends anything done in this style a deserved sense of pedigree.

For once, some of the "Added Value" material actually ADDS value.

Pros:
Great story/feature
Bonus "Spectre" short is nothing short of amazing and wonderfully original. (A+++++)
Four great episodes of the original Justice League. (Two 2-Parters.)
Pilot of live-action 70's "Wonder Woman" has apparently been remastered for HD. Looks very nice.
Great A-List Voice talent.

Cons:
No Kevin Conroy, et al.
Encode/video quality of the Justice League episodes is sub-par and WORSE than standard definition DVD. (All black ink outlines are terribly blurred & jagged.)
Some added value already released on previous WB/DC animated releases.

Having bought the other six movies and enjoyed them to varying degrees, this latest entry into DC's Direct-to-DVD Library is the strongest entry so far. The plot is very strong, characterization spot-on, and the voice-work is close to perfect.

Now, I say close to perfect, because as you may be able to predict, Billy Baldwin is a weak Batman. His voice just sounds wrong coming out of the Dark Knight. Thankfully, Batman doesn't talk much. And the characterization is so perfect. Superman is leader-ish. Wonder Woman has the right kind of spunk. Martian Manhunter is reserved. Flash is playful. And Hal Jordan just blends into the background. Just like in the comic books!

I'm just ribbing you GL fans.

Like all Crisis stories, this is a visual treat. I love spotting all the alternate versions of characters we know. Evil Elongated Man, Evil Vixen, Evil Black Canary, Evil Jimmy Olsen, and "Superwoman's Three Made Men." they make me smile. And the Crime Syndicate is a good set of villains. Owlman and Superwoman steal the show, but Ultraman has his moments. Johnny Quick, too. Power Ring, eh, not much. But, its a great plot, with great pacing for the action, and it's funny! I love it.

I should mention that this is NOT an adaptation of Grant Morrison's "JLA: Earth-2." Other than a good Lex Luthor asking the JLA for help, and Owlman and Superwoman being an item, this DVD and that book are nothing alike. It's apples and oranges. Maybe because it's not an adaptation that this DVD is so strong. When you have to adapt from another medium, you have to sacrifice something along the way, to the detriment of the piece. Having this written specifically for a movie dodges the "Oh, you have to read the Graphic Novel," excuse that some of the other DTVs suffered.



EXTRAS on this Bluray are pilots for the Linda Carder - Wonder Woman TV series, and the Aquaman TV pilot, that spun-off from Smallville, this is exclusive to the Bluray edition.

Four episodes of Justice League: A Better World, parts 1&2 (AKA the Justice Lords episodes). And Exclusive to the Bluray: Twilight, parts 1&2 (AKA, when Superman fights Brainiac and Darkseid).

What is the first in a series of animated shorts, DC Showcase Presents - The Spectre, a 10 minute cartoon. It's good to see obscure characters given a spotlight. Nice and simple. Can't complain.

A documentary, DCU: The New World. It looks at the creation of Identity Crisis going into Infinite Crisis. As a person who has read all of what they're trying to describe, I found this Doc to be very "airy" - lots of big words, without actually telling me anything. Something about how 9/11 changed everything, BAM - Identity Crisis. Very disappointing. JL: The New Frontier still has the best extras.

And a First Look at DC's next Animated Project - Batman: Under the Red Hood. Which, in my opinion, is looking great.

Plus "Looks" into GL: First Flight, Wonder Woman, and S/B: Public Enemies, pad-out the rest of the disk.


A really good feature. Some decent extras. The only thing I miss are the commentary tracks. I found the bluray for the same price as the 2-Disk Edition, so it was a no-brainer which to pick: I get the the Wonder Woman and Aquaman pilots, plus Twilight 1&2 in the bluray. Enjoy, and I'll see you at Batman: Under the Read Hood.

English:
The best animated ever made by DC Comics/Warner Bros!

A great story! Amazing actor performances! Thril animation! Almost perfect character interaction! Fabulous soundtrack!

This movie became an item that you cannot let it go! Vicious! They're all there! Every one that makes Justice League a Comic Blockbuster!

Portuguese:
O melhor filme animado já feito pela DC Comics/Warner Bros!

Um ótimo enredo! Atuações espetaculares dos atores! Animação animal! Interação quase perfeita entre os personagens! Trilha sonora fabulosa!

Este filme se tornou um item indispensável! Viciante! E estão todos lá! Cada um dos que fizeram a Liga da Justiça um arrasa quarteirão nos quadrinhos!

Overall this was a strong entry in the ever-expanding line of DC animated features. Its main downfall, to my obsessive mind, is its somewhat shabby treatment of my favorite hero, Green Lantern.

The first line GL has begins with "For all my power..." Sadly, in the rest of this film, he rarely demonstrates this power. He never really steps up, has little to say, and never does anything really remarkable or impressive. In his first battle, he is completely dominated by the evil Marvels, who effortlessly plow through his shields to get at him. Later, these same Marvels who made such light work of Green Lantern are punched around by relative lightweights like Aquaman. If Green Lantern is so helpless against these underlings, you have to wonder what chance he'd have against any of the main members of the Crime Syndicate, unless it's his own counterpart, Power Ring. He even has trouble handling evil Halo, of all people.

GL is generally considered the second most powerful member of the JLA, after Superman. In the early comics, it was usually Hal who would, at the critical moment, do something ingenious and unexpected with his ring that would turn the tide and save the day. There's no sign of that here. He shows no initiative and no personality. They might even have remembered that Hal is one of the world's greatest pilots when Owl Man's plane becomes available.

My main consolation in this is that Batman is stripped of the weird mantle of invincibility which has clung to him in recent years. I enjoyed seeing him manhandled by opponents who are vastly superior to him. He is just a guy in a suit, after all.

Dc for the last couple of years has been in competition with Marvel in releasing made for DVD movies. Some were good, some were eh.. and some including this one were awesome! I have absolutely no problems with this movie. While character development in some of the heroes was not a priority, nor should it have been for major established characters like Superman, Batman and Flash who have been pretty much covered in the previous movies and Justice League TV series. This Green Lantern could have been explored a bit more, but again, not a major issue as they use him more to flesh out the backround. This is the first movie that truly does Wonder Woman justice in action, attitude and fighting skills. She kicks major butt here. Martian Manhunter actually is presented well and not someone who has these massive personal and power defiencies. Heck, you even briefly get to see characters (in villian form) like Halo, Vibe and Gypsy, and they don't make you cringe. Then there is the Crime Syndicate, great character development in the villians as these are the characters many people wouldn't be familiar with from anything previously done. Think Justice League without the self sacrificing for humanity. Instead, total self serving attitutdes, and in the case of Superwoman some s/m subtext thrown in. All in all, considering what had been done before, I was interested in watching it, but wasn't expecting to be blown away by it. I was happily proven wrong. This just made my top best Justice League episode/movie list. Would I want more character development in an on-going series? Yes. Hoever, for a movie to give you the flavor of what the comics are like this was great! I would love to see another movie done with this animated style, acting/voices and story.

What I really was looking forward to seeing was the Spectre back-up feature. If you've no clue who the Spectre is, I'll give you the general synopsis. Created by Jerry Seigel (1/2 of the Superman creative team) in the 1940's, the Spectre was cop named Jim Corrigan who had been killed by mobsters, and was brought back to Earth as a ghost who seeks vengence for the murdered. Up until the early 90's, I wasn't a Spectre fan. That was until the John Ostrander/Tom Mandrake series really delved into the complexities of the character's mission, faith and of being human in general. From that point on, I've made it a point to see where they've taken the character and have always wondered what it would be like to see in film. This short proved that this should be an on-going series, probably made for Adult Swim on Cartoon Network as it can be a bit classic horror in nature. Even better, they decided to give it a slight 70's film noir feel in music style and animated film look. To answer quick questions by people who know the character. Does the Spectre kill the "bad" guys in this short? Yes. Does he do it in classic ironic Spectre style? Yes. All in all, a perfect first introduction to the character that needs to be continued!

Quick Review:

Main Movie
Story A-
Character Development B
Action A+
Animation A

Spectre Backup Feature
Story A+
Character Development C (but for a first introduction, not really needed. You'll get the idea.)
Action A+
Animation A+

The Justice League has done it all in the DCAU. Saved the world from alien attacks, saved other worlds in need of help and even saved themselves from the people they have sworn to protect. Now, they face something new. What would you say if you suddenly visited by your arch enemy claming he is from another dimension, and in his world he is a good guy?! Well, in Bruce Timms newest DCAU film, `Justice League: Crisis On Two Earths' Superman, Batman and the other JL members will find out.

The whole `Crisis' Story line has a grand history in the world of DC comics. From the Silver Age all the way to the mid 1980s there was a great deal of confusion around the story arcs of the heroes we have grown to love. DC had a great answer, let's bring all these arcs together, say they are all from different Earths in different dimension and kill as many characters as we can. The `Crisis' story in this film is actually one of the very first that has been re-visited a few times in the past 25 years, and for a 78 minute movie it is also one of the simplest to follow. That is a big plus for fans of the DCAU who might not be knowledgeable on the Crisis Lore. So the JL are visited by a good Lex Luthor who tells them about a world where the super powered men and women just happen to be the bad guys and what is worse, they like to kill. They are pretty much the JL through a broken mirror and Lex has no choice but to bring the good guys from another world to his to win the day.

I have been a fan of the DCAU for a while and so far I have enjoyed all the Warner Premiere films they have given us. Crisis was a fun movie to watch. While the character development was nowhere in sight it was a blast. I think that this film was made more for the comic fan. You know your characters you know the Crisis lore, just sit back and enjoy. What character development they did show in this film was done very well. Martian Manhunter had a great role to play, while he was not part of a great deal of the action. The voice acting was top notch. It was a little discomforting at first to hear Batman with a slightly higher pitch than normal, but the Batman persona was still there and at times he even made me laugh. Mark Harmon was great as Superman and Gina Torres was deliciously evil as Superwoman. Still, by far the best acting came from James Woods. Owlman was a villain that kept everything low pitched and emotionless. That is the kind of villain that becomes very frightening because the mystery leads to extreme unpredictability.

DC fans are gonna love this film, especially with all the surprises that are thrown in. You are going to see a few additional familiar faces and a few new faces that are going to make love it even more. This one made me very happy because it was taken from a story I wanted to see brought to the DCAU and the next film, is based upon the aftermath of `Death In The Family', another story I wanted to see. Take the time to see this movie, and make sure you see the two disc addition so you are able to see the DC Showcase short of `The Spectre'

REVISED REVIEW --

I have noticed that there have been many reviewers who've said that they don't have a point of reference for this film. First, I will provide the background, then I will give my review of the film.

BACKGROUND --

This film is loosely based on the 1999 graphic novel "JLA: Earth-2" by Grant Morrison, Mark Waid in the 2003 and the 1980s "Crisis on Infinite Earths" mini-series by Marv Wolfman. Both feature a group of supervillians from an alternate universe intermittently referred to as the Crime Syndicate who are the polar opposite of the Justice League.

The core of the group features the following characters:

1. Ultraman -- Superman's counterpart; he was an ambitious astronaut who had a space shuttle accident. Aliens discovered and saved him from his near fatal wounds. Their medical assistance, while sparing his life and giving him superhuman powers caused him such post-operative stress that it destroyed his mind. When he returned to his Earth, he started his reign of terror. His deadly sin is Anger.

2. Owlman -- Batman's counterpart -- both Batman's and Owlman's relatives were brutally murdered when they were very young. While Batman made the decision to hunt down and capture criminals, Owlman learned a different lesson from this traumatic event. He identified with his murderous oppressors and became a head of organized crime in Gotham City. His deadly sin is Envy.

3. Power Ring -- Green Lantern's counterpart -- The premise of the Green Lantern is that a brave, worthy soul is chosen by a ring and he uses said ring as an instrument of justice. Conversely, Power Ring's ring, Volsthom, is subtly in control of its host and uses its human vessel for its own ends. The human's deadly sin is Sloth; his ring's deadly sin is Avarice.

4. Superwoman -- Wonder Woman's counterpart; in the Earth-2 graphic novel, she has a secret identity as editor of the Daily Globe. While Wonder Woman is something of a Amazonian diplomat, Superwoman is a viking. In comic books, she also is secretly married to Ultraman despite the fact that she truly despises him. Her deadly sin is Lust.

5. Johnny Quick --- Flash's counterpart; while Earth 1's Flash acquired his powers by a freak accident, Quick possesses his because he is taking radioactive steriods which seem to be slowly killing him. In many ways, he is the most unstable of this group. His deadly sin is Gluttony.

The Syndicate's primary nemesis is none other than Earth-2's intelligent, impossibly vain but nonetheless well-meaning Lex Luthor.


REVIEW OF THE FILM --

I don't believe in spoilers.

With that said, I want to tell the readers that the three most compelling characters in the movie were Superwoman (Wonder Woman's counterpart), Owlman (Batman's "anti-ego") and Batman, himself.

Superman, Green Lantern, Flash, Ultraman, Johnny Quick and Power Ring were given very little to do in this film and the Martian Manhunter's role seemed forced. [ The underutilization of these characters was a bit disappointing and the gratuitous Manhunter subplot caused me to rank this a bit lower than I really wanted to.]

However, Superwoman, Owlman and Batman chewed up the scenery!

SUPERWOMAN --- Superwoman (and her surprising crew of henchmen) was given a lot of screen time. Her action sequences were amazing and her twisted interaction with Batman was to die for. If you ever wondered what Wonder Woman would be like if she ever stopped repressing her hot-blooded Amazonian tendencies, this rendering of the breath-taking reckless Superwoman will be a treat.

BATMAN --- For his part, Batman is presented as his most Machiavellian self. He makes moralistically ambiguous decisions in this film that remind the viewer of just how he can be. If DC decides in future films to detail Batman's eventual expulsion from the JLA (a retelling of Mark Waid's "Tower of Babel" would be an excellent sequel to this film), the viewer can point to the decisions Batman made here as part of the reason why. While there is very little examination of Batman's actions here, his teammates must have been stunned by his ruthlessness.

OWLMAN ---- And I believe Owlman will become a fan favorite. While each character's reaction to the discovery of parallel universes is unique, Owlman's is as poignant as they come. In reflection (and Owlman's reaction is certainly open to several interpretations), it appeared to me the revelation of anti-matter universes caused Owlman to have a (very understated) nervous breakdown.

James Woods does a fantastic job showing the nuances of Owlman's character. He is equally a frustrated genius, opportunist, philosopher and (in the most nihilistic of ways) nearly heroic. While many villains we have seen in the DC animated past have been driven by money or a desire to rule the world, we have never seen one who so aggressively rejects the premise the super-criminal as alpha-male archetype.

I give this film a 3.5.

This won't be the longest review, but I really enjoyed this. This is one of the best stories from Warner Animation for DVD to come out for a while. All the characters on both earths were well done. Don't be afraid to stand up to a corrupt power, "Evil only wins when good men do nothing". How can you not like a superhero movie with a ideas and quotes like that?

The movie really had a lot going for it. The idea of an alternate Batman (Owlman) who was never a good man is an excellent one; and Superwoman and Owlman are quite compelling.
The movie really revolves around Superwoman, Owlman and Batman, and the particular mental instability of the two primary villains is disturbingly believable. The writing flows smoothly and doesn't jar.
But in spite of these strong advantages, ultimately I thought the movie was something of a flop. Other than the three mentioned, the other characters are mostly filler, and as good as Batman in some ways is in this one, the voice was utterly and completely wrong (perhaps chosen to sound very similar to Owlman's). The use of characters who serve no real purpose (Martian Manhunter) and acquire no real development acts as a brake on opening up the genuine dramatic possibilities offered by the situation. Had this been a Batman movie, rather than a Justice League movie, and had Kevin Conroy or Bruce Greenwood played Batman, it could well have been one of the best animated movies; but bad acting and a failure to excise irrelevant material severely weakened the film to the point of disappointment.
I think the root of the failure is that they took a clearly conceived Owlman, and used him as the base for Batman, modifying him just enough to be a pretty dark hero; whereas, given audience familiarity with Batman, the reverse procedure would have made more sense. Indeed, the reverse procedure does seem like what they did with Superwoman: they took Wonder Woman and twisted her enough to really become a sadistic villain - and the scene where she snaps Batman's rib is one of the two most memorable in the movie. But the other villians, indeed, the other heroes, don't have much of a defined character, and certainly were not genuinely alternate versions of their putative counterparts. If they had taken with everyone the approach they took with Wonder Woman/Superwoman it would have been a much more significant work.