76 of 83 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
quite helpful review book for step 3 but not complete/errors, May 19, 2009
This review is from: Kaplan Medical USMLE Master the Boards Step 3 (Paperback)
I have gone through pretty much all of the step 3 review books in the market including FA, Crush step 3, the nail the board, Board and ward, and Strong Medicine. I also have read the Kaplan Q book step 3
This volume surpass all of the above in terms of the quality of content, amount of fine detail, board relevancy, and the author's unique insights into the material as a good teacher himself.
He tend to shed a lot of good insight into the board questions. I had met him once in person when I was a medical student at the FHMC in Queens, NY.
But this book is not perfect (There is no such thing as a perfect board review book, we all know it). I wish there are more complete index, which is pretty bad and too brief. It takes some time to find a topic with "rushed out" kind of index.
Also, there are a few errors. It says that Mitral valve prolapse with even regurgitaion does not need endocarditis Prophylaxis but I have been able to verify with a few medical references including Harrison-the recent update- and Washington manual that MR with regurgitation needs prophylaxis.
the author boldly claims that there is no prophylatic therapy for cluster headache with some rather unconvincing logic, but I have read from several respectful sources that beta blockade or Calcium channel blockade must be given for prophylatic RX for cluster HA.
I also found this misleading information about ASCUS in Pap smear results. It says that if pap results in ASUC, the patient need HPV testing, But it does not mention the important fact that if the patient is a high risk group, ASUCS must mandate immediate Colposcopy biopsy.
Other shortcoming is the Leukemia section, which he almost neglect to cover the important facts about ALL and AML but throw in very vague mixed information under title "Acute leukemia".
Other than the index, it is a decent volume and very reasonable priced.
I would not recommend it as a sole review source though. Step 3 seem to ask the understanding of the concepts and application of the further managements contrast to the step 2 which is more of recognition of the key words and classic signs. Thus I reject this book's so called Guarantee passing score Claim....I highly recommend a second review book beside this for a better performance on step 3.It is really unreasonable to claim that this book has "everthing" to do pass step 3.
I never recommend Strong Medicine, which is consistent of skeletal bullet list of the information without no actual bread and butter for each disease presentation. This book fails to demonstrate the competency and confidence of the material presented with a fair amount of wrong information as well.
FA is also not recommended since its missing out too many topics and is also very boring to read with little insights. I only use the 100 CCS cases on the back of this book.
Board and Ward is not recommended as well since its too basic to tackle the step 3 questions, which tend to ask much more in dept understanding and managements than mere factual key words, which is what is all about Board and Ward. It was useful for step 2 though and NBME Shelf exams.
PS: I passed the step 3 with 217/91%,(October 2010) which I have to give a lot of credit toward this great book. Peace after the agony of waiting for the score, which sent to me via a lengthy email @ 12 PM, midnight third wednesday. Yet the matching process is yet to be known. Career in medicine consumes my soul and the person itself. Prayers for all.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
20 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Best of the 3 Gold Standard Reviews, July 6, 2010
This review is from: Kaplan Medical USMLE Master the Boards Step 3 (Paperback)
As much as I hate Kaplan (the McDonald's of exams and USMLE with no hesitation to milk profit from poor students), this book is probably the best of the 3 books, which are:
1- This one
2- Crush by Brochert
3- First Aid
I personally like this the best and is the most complete and exam-oriented book. Heavy emphasis is placed throughout on what to do in the CCS scenarios and are, in my opinion, even better than the stand-alone section in FA, which is fairly worthless apart from a few cases which are valuable (so look through them somehow).
Brochert is a little too similar to USMLE 2CK, and while this exam appears similar, there are some differences which books really need to bring out, at least heavier CCS emphasis. Most books however, appear to have given up by the time it gets to USMLE 3 and just want to publish something that will sell, FA is classic for that and the standard deteriorates rapidly as you progress from USMLE 1 to 2 to 3... Sorry but making money comes second when it comes to my grade and I am a little annoyed as you can tell.
The money-back guarantee is probably crippled with restrictions but in fairness I cannot tell and base this on the cover disclosure. For the quality of the print, it should be a little cheaper and this is where it loses half a star in my opinion (a new highlighter will show on the other side of the page). The guarantee is nonetheless reassuring when you see the authors have confidence in their text, and that makes a difference, especially as it doesn't take much these days to publish a book ridden with errors and factual inaccuracies.
There are some sections in this book which are written phenomenally (cardiology) and others, less so. There, depending on your strengths, you may need help online for further clarification (nothing like having wikipedia open along with reading the book when unsure... my personal golden advice!). On the less well written chapters, this book loses the other half star.
There you go, 4/5 and probably the best out there.
Let me know if you need any further clarification... Last piece of advice, don't get bogged down with CCS, it's only 20% and there is a day and half of pure questions that are not CCS. Be careful not to lose focus here in your preparations.
Good luck
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
18 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
pretty decent book, May 5, 2009
This review is from: Kaplan Medical USMLE Master the Boards Step 3 (Paperback)
I just bought this book recently and have been studying with it for the Step 3 exam. If you're looking for something that basically sums up the Kaplan material into one book, you might like this. I doubt it would be the only thing you need to score well but it definitely helps out. Certain chapters dont have as much material as you'd hope but the Ob/Gyn chapters in my opinion are pretty good. However, it is not got for the C.C.S portion of the exam. I havn't found a book that can be used for that portion of the exam as of yet.
Combine this book with First Aid for the Step 3 and a few months of UsmleWorld, it should help out.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
