2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
a thought-provoking tool for understanding self defense, June 1, 2002
This review is from: Karate: The Art of Empty Self (Paperback)
the previous reviewer arrests his attention on a single sticking point that is quite irrelevant to the integrity and premise of the main text (his bone of contention rests solely within the brief introduction). Karate: The Art of Empty Self is not a missive on martial theory, nor is it an extrapolation of other men's understanding of the matter. rather the book is comprised of a series of brief and stark perceptions about the grossly misunderstood subject of self defense. formatted in an effective, reader-friendly manner, this book does not purport to educate, but instead invites the reader to interact with its content in order to gain an evolved understanding of the true nature of self defense. and as the previous reviewer discovered, its elegant, clever design ensures that nothing is revealed to the reader that he or she isn't prepared to perceive.
highly recommended.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Find your own peace, July 29, 2004
This review is from: Karate: The Art of Empty Self (Paperback)
I've read numerous martial arts books and articles and found The Art of Empty Self a refreshing and thought-provoking change of pace from the usual. Not a history or biography book, not a personal journey or even a narrative, this is a collection of insights and observations --some pages are only one or two sentences long-- which would be helpful to any true student of martial arts. I feel that I could read this book again every year and find something new speaking to me!
The strident objections given in the other review are actually amusing considering the advice given throughout the book.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
5.0 out of 5 stars
Deeply insightful..., August 20, 2007
This review is from: Karate: The Art of Empty Self (Paperback)
As a 45-year karate practitioner and instructor, I was drawn to Dr. Webster-Doyle's teachings, and sensed his novel methods could enhance the maturity of my students. His enlightened strategy for comprehending the nature of human aggression provides an underpinning for developing tactical skills in voiding it. But, there was far more, being drawn from the author's extensive education and practice in psychology, traditional karate, and education.
His, "Karate: The Art of Empty Self," proved deeply insightful for anyone ready for Dr. Webster-Doyle's revolutionary digression from violence as a solution to violence ... who realize it only begets more violence. Combined with dedicated dojo training, it provides far greater rewards than mere physical training in fighting. Even for those untrained in self-defense, it can thwart aggression.
I acquired more of his works, including Why Is 'Everybody Always Picking On Me? One Encounter, One Chance to name a few. They provided study and workshop teaching in effective, bloodless tactics for stopping physical violence. Throughout, they shared a strategy for overcoming the internal battles with one's own ego ... the source of all violence, from interpersonal to international.
Like all visionaries, Dr. Webster-Doyle has detractors. Their main criticism is that by not heroically jumping into physical engagement, one is cowardly ... a wimp promoting feminism. Granted, their solution is one way to meet aggression ... but with no comprehension of the potential aftermath: hospital or morgue, court or prison. Dr. Webster-Doyle's far more effective approach substitutes cool, rational thinking for unthinking physical resistance ... until an attack in imminent. Then, effective self-defense training equips the student to back up what he says. This is what karate and other arts are supposed to be all about. "In Okinawa, one never strikes the first blow," is a maxim among the island's karate masters. The creator of our style stated it was important that he maintain a soft, almost feminine character, to avoid driving new students away. He also said the secret is to be able to be hard or soft, as the situation demands.
To the criticism that Dr. Webster-Doyle lacks valid scholastic credentials from an accredited school is incorrect, as the Web site they mention states his school was accredited when he graduated. Regardless, if he came down from the planet Mongo, his teachings would be equally valuable for those who have seen enough aggression given and taken in the world, seen it doesn't work, and know there is a better way.
Dale Scott, Costa Rica
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you? Yes
No
